Prenatal alcohol history – setting a threshold for diagnosis requires a level of detail and accuracy that does not exist

BACKGROUND: The revised 2015 Canadian Guidelines requires a more specific prenatal alcohol exposure (PAE) threshold for a Fetal Alcohol Spectrum Disorder (FASD) diagnosis. The unintended consequences of adhering to the suggested PAE threshold for an FASD diagnosis and the challenges professionals face in obtaining an accurate PAE history were explored. METHODS: Using a mixed methods study design, the study was carried out in two parts (Quantitative and Qualitative). PAE history and FASD diagnosis was reviewed retrospectively from 146 patient charts referred for an FASD assessment between 2011 and 2016. The challenges experienced when collecting the PAE history were explored through interviews with 23 professionals. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS (IBM SPSS Statistics 20.0). RESULTS: Of 146 assessments, only 21.9% met the revised 2015 PAE guidelines while 79.4% met the previous 2005 PAE criteria. Of 146 clients, 54.1% met brain criteria for FASD yet of those only 29.1% met the revised PAE criteria whereas 70.9% did not and therefore could lose their FASD diagnosis under a diligent application of PAE level suggested in the 2015 Guidelines. Thematic analysis of the interview data indicated that obtaining a reliable PAE history was challenging and a combination of methods are employed to get credible information. CONCLUSION: Confirming PAE history can be difficult, but ensuring reliable and accurate details on quantity, frequency, and timing of exposure is impossible in a clinical setting. Three out of every four individuals in the present study lost their FASD diagnosis following implementation of 2015 Canadian FASD Guidelines. A threshold might also imply that alcohol consumption below threshold is safe. The 2015 Canadian Guidelines need further refinement regarding the PAE criteria.