Cargando…

2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia

BACKGROUND: Anterior nares (AN) MRSA PCR can help identify MRSA colonization as a risk factor for MRSA pneumonia and can be especially useful, given high NPV, in making treatment decisions when lower respiratory tract (LRT) cultures are lacking. Oropharynx (OP) MRSA carriage without AN colonization...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Kessler, Michael, Biswas, Sandip, Choera, Tsokyi, Chen, Derrick, Lepak, Alexander
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6810833/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofz360.1833
_version_ 1783462336039747584
author Kessler, Michael
Biswas, Sandip
Choera, Tsokyi
Chen, Derrick
Lepak, Alexander
Lepak, Alexander
author_facet Kessler, Michael
Biswas, Sandip
Choera, Tsokyi
Chen, Derrick
Lepak, Alexander
Lepak, Alexander
author_sort Kessler, Michael
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Anterior nares (AN) MRSA PCR can help identify MRSA colonization as a risk factor for MRSA pneumonia and can be especially useful, given high NPV, in making treatment decisions when lower respiratory tract (LRT) cultures are lacking. Oropharynx (OP) MRSA carriage without AN colonization can occur suggesting the potential benefit of duel site screening, but doubles resource utilization. We evaluated concordance between the AN and OP sites and whether the addition of OP MRSA PCR testing provides clinical benefit. METHODS: MRSA PCR was performed using Xpert SA Nasal Complete (Cepheid; FDA-cleared and modified). Results were retrieved from January 2017 to July 2018 for adult in-patients who received both AN and OP testing within the same calendar day. Medical charts were reviewed for a clinical course, respiratory culture results, and effect of discordant PCR results. RESULTS: AN and OP MRSA PCRs were performed on 1,419 adult inpatients, concordance was 96.5% (n = 1370, see Table). In 38 of 49 discordant cases, PCR was used to evaluate the etiology of pneumonia. Of those, 22 (58%) had LRT culture results available within 48 h to direct therapy. We further evaluated the value of OP PCR by focusing on AN-/OP+ (n = 22) discordant results, of which 16 were used to evaluate pneumonia. LRT culture results were available in 7 (44%) of these cases. Three had isolation of MRSA; however, the remaining 4 were culture-negative but still received vancomycin for an average of 5 days. Of the 9 that were AN−, OP+, and without culture results, only 4 had clinical signs and symptoms consistent with MRSA pneumonia. OP MRSA PCR is $303. CONCLUSION: OP and AN MRSA PCR screening are highly concordant in patients with pneumonia. 355 AN/OP PCRs (4/1419), at > $100,000 in additional healthcare costs, were needed to detect one potentially missed MRSA pneumonia compared with AN PCR only approach. Our results suggest addition of OP MRSA PCR: (1) has limited clinical utility for pneumonia evaluation as it is unlikely to be discordant with AN testing, which will not significantly alter the very high NPV and when discordant (AN-/OP+) has a <50% PPV, (2) is unlikely to be cost-effective, and (3) has unintended consequences such as overuse of MRSA therapy. Additionally, there is an opportunity to improve PCR ordering to include only those situations in which LRT cultures are lacking. [Image: see text] DISCLOSURES: Alexander Lepak, MD, Paratek Pharmaceuticals: Research Grant; Tetraphase Pharmaceuticals: Research Grant.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6810833
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-68108332019-10-28 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia Kessler, Michael Biswas, Sandip Choera, Tsokyi Chen, Derrick Lepak, Alexander Lepak, Alexander Open Forum Infect Dis Abstracts BACKGROUND: Anterior nares (AN) MRSA PCR can help identify MRSA colonization as a risk factor for MRSA pneumonia and can be especially useful, given high NPV, in making treatment decisions when lower respiratory tract (LRT) cultures are lacking. Oropharynx (OP) MRSA carriage without AN colonization can occur suggesting the potential benefit of duel site screening, but doubles resource utilization. We evaluated concordance between the AN and OP sites and whether the addition of OP MRSA PCR testing provides clinical benefit. METHODS: MRSA PCR was performed using Xpert SA Nasal Complete (Cepheid; FDA-cleared and modified). Results were retrieved from January 2017 to July 2018 for adult in-patients who received both AN and OP testing within the same calendar day. Medical charts were reviewed for a clinical course, respiratory culture results, and effect of discordant PCR results. RESULTS: AN and OP MRSA PCRs were performed on 1,419 adult inpatients, concordance was 96.5% (n = 1370, see Table). In 38 of 49 discordant cases, PCR was used to evaluate the etiology of pneumonia. Of those, 22 (58%) had LRT culture results available within 48 h to direct therapy. We further evaluated the value of OP PCR by focusing on AN-/OP+ (n = 22) discordant results, of which 16 were used to evaluate pneumonia. LRT culture results were available in 7 (44%) of these cases. Three had isolation of MRSA; however, the remaining 4 were culture-negative but still received vancomycin for an average of 5 days. Of the 9 that were AN−, OP+, and without culture results, only 4 had clinical signs and symptoms consistent with MRSA pneumonia. OP MRSA PCR is $303. CONCLUSION: OP and AN MRSA PCR screening are highly concordant in patients with pneumonia. 355 AN/OP PCRs (4/1419), at > $100,000 in additional healthcare costs, were needed to detect one potentially missed MRSA pneumonia compared with AN PCR only approach. Our results suggest addition of OP MRSA PCR: (1) has limited clinical utility for pneumonia evaluation as it is unlikely to be discordant with AN testing, which will not significantly alter the very high NPV and when discordant (AN-/OP+) has a <50% PPV, (2) is unlikely to be cost-effective, and (3) has unintended consequences such as overuse of MRSA therapy. Additionally, there is an opportunity to improve PCR ordering to include only those situations in which LRT cultures are lacking. [Image: see text] DISCLOSURES: Alexander Lepak, MD, Paratek Pharmaceuticals: Research Grant; Tetraphase Pharmaceuticals: Research Grant. Oxford University Press 2019-10-23 /pmc/articles/PMC6810833/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofz360.1833 Text en © The Author(s) 2019. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of Infectious Diseases Society of America. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Abstracts
Kessler, Michael
Biswas, Sandip
Choera, Tsokyi
Chen, Derrick
Lepak, Alexander
Lepak, Alexander
2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title_full 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title_fullStr 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title_full_unstemmed 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title_short 2153. Clinical Impact of Addition of Oropharynx MRSA PCR to Anterior Nares MRSA PCR for Patients Admitted with Pneumonia
title_sort 2153. clinical impact of addition of oropharynx mrsa pcr to anterior nares mrsa pcr for patients admitted with pneumonia
topic Abstracts
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6810833/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/ofid/ofz360.1833
work_keys_str_mv AT kesslermichael 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia
AT biswassandip 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia
AT choeratsokyi 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia
AT chenderrick 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia
AT lepakalexander 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia
AT lepakalexander 2153clinicalimpactofadditionoforopharynxmrsapcrtoanteriornaresmrsapcrforpatientsadmittedwithpneumonia