Cargando…
Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests
SIMPLE SUMMARY: The utilization of animal donors of rumen fluid for laboratory experiments can raise ethical concerns due to invasive methods of collection (rumen cannulated or intubated animals). Societies are strongly oriented to support cruelty free experiments and alternatives to the collection...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
MDPI
2019
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6826744/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31623149 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani9100815 |
_version_ | 1783465163152687104 |
---|---|
author | Spanghero, Mauro Chiaravalli, Maria Colombini, Stefania Fabro, Carla Froldi, Federico Mason, Federico Moschini, Maurizio Sarnataro, Chiara Schiavon, Stefano Tagliapietra, Franco |
author_facet | Spanghero, Mauro Chiaravalli, Maria Colombini, Stefania Fabro, Carla Froldi, Federico Mason, Federico Moschini, Maurizio Sarnataro, Chiara Schiavon, Stefano Tagliapietra, Franco |
author_sort | Spanghero, Mauro |
collection | PubMed |
description | SIMPLE SUMMARY: The utilization of animal donors of rumen fluid for laboratory experiments can raise ethical concerns due to invasive methods of collection (rumen cannulated or intubated animals). Societies are strongly oriented to support cruelty free experiments and alternatives to the collection of rumen fluids from live animals are urgently requested from the scientific community. Thus, in order to attenuate the dependence of laboratories on animal donors, this study compared the rumen inoculum collected at slaughter with the fermentation liquid from a rumen continuous fermenter and both rumen inoculum were used fresh or preserved (by refrigeration, chilling and freeze-drying). The results support the possibility of using continuous fermenters to generate inoculum for in vitro purposes, and short-term refrigeration is confirmed to be a valuable storage system to facilitate transfer inoculum from the collection sites. These findings should attenuate the need for laboratories’ frequent collections from animals while continuing research in ruminant nutrition. ABSTRACT: The utilization of animal donors of rumen fluid for laboratory experiments can raise ethical concerns, and alternatives to the collection of rumen fluids from live animals are urgently requested. The aim of this study was to compare the fresh rumen fluid (collected at slaughter, W) with that obtained from a continuous fermenter (RCF) and three methods of rumen fluid preservation (refrigeration, R, chilling, C, and freeze-drying, FD). The fermentability of different inoculum was evaluated by three in vitro tests (neutral detergent fiber (NDF) and crude protein (CP) degradability and gas production, NDFd, RDP and GP, respectively) using six feeds as substrates. Despite the two types of inoculum differed in terms of metabolites and microbiota concentration, the differences in vitro fermentability between the two liquids were less pronounced than expected (−15 and 20% for NDFd and GP when the liquid of fermenter was used and no differences for RDP). Within each in vitro test, the data obtained from rumen and from fermenter liquids were highly correlated for the six feeds, as well as between W and R (r: 0.837–0.985; p < 0.01). The low fermentative capacity was found for C and, particularly, FD for liquids. RCF could be used to generate inoculum for in vitro purposes and short-term refrigeration is a valuable practice to manage inoculum. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6826744 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2019 |
publisher | MDPI |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-68267442019-11-18 Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests Spanghero, Mauro Chiaravalli, Maria Colombini, Stefania Fabro, Carla Froldi, Federico Mason, Federico Moschini, Maurizio Sarnataro, Chiara Schiavon, Stefano Tagliapietra, Franco Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: The utilization of animal donors of rumen fluid for laboratory experiments can raise ethical concerns due to invasive methods of collection (rumen cannulated or intubated animals). Societies are strongly oriented to support cruelty free experiments and alternatives to the collection of rumen fluids from live animals are urgently requested from the scientific community. Thus, in order to attenuate the dependence of laboratories on animal donors, this study compared the rumen inoculum collected at slaughter with the fermentation liquid from a rumen continuous fermenter and both rumen inoculum were used fresh or preserved (by refrigeration, chilling and freeze-drying). The results support the possibility of using continuous fermenters to generate inoculum for in vitro purposes, and short-term refrigeration is confirmed to be a valuable storage system to facilitate transfer inoculum from the collection sites. These findings should attenuate the need for laboratories’ frequent collections from animals while continuing research in ruminant nutrition. ABSTRACT: The utilization of animal donors of rumen fluid for laboratory experiments can raise ethical concerns, and alternatives to the collection of rumen fluids from live animals are urgently requested. The aim of this study was to compare the fresh rumen fluid (collected at slaughter, W) with that obtained from a continuous fermenter (RCF) and three methods of rumen fluid preservation (refrigeration, R, chilling, C, and freeze-drying, FD). The fermentability of different inoculum was evaluated by three in vitro tests (neutral detergent fiber (NDF) and crude protein (CP) degradability and gas production, NDFd, RDP and GP, respectively) using six feeds as substrates. Despite the two types of inoculum differed in terms of metabolites and microbiota concentration, the differences in vitro fermentability between the two liquids were less pronounced than expected (−15 and 20% for NDFd and GP when the liquid of fermenter was used and no differences for RDP). Within each in vitro test, the data obtained from rumen and from fermenter liquids were highly correlated for the six feeds, as well as between W and R (r: 0.837–0.985; p < 0.01). The low fermentative capacity was found for C and, particularly, FD for liquids. RCF could be used to generate inoculum for in vitro purposes and short-term refrigeration is a valuable practice to manage inoculum. MDPI 2019-10-16 /pmc/articles/PMC6826744/ /pubmed/31623149 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani9100815 Text en © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Article Spanghero, Mauro Chiaravalli, Maria Colombini, Stefania Fabro, Carla Froldi, Federico Mason, Federico Moschini, Maurizio Sarnataro, Chiara Schiavon, Stefano Tagliapietra, Franco Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title | Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title_full | Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title_fullStr | Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title_full_unstemmed | Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title_short | Rumen Inoculum Collected from Cows at Slaughter or from a Continuous Fermenter and Preserved in Warm, Refrigerated, Chilled or Freeze-Dried Environments for In Vitro Tests |
title_sort | rumen inoculum collected from cows at slaughter or from a continuous fermenter and preserved in warm, refrigerated, chilled or freeze-dried environments for in vitro tests |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6826744/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31623149 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani9100815 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT spangheromauro rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT chiaravallimaria rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT colombinistefania rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT fabrocarla rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT froldifederico rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT masonfederico rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT moschinimaurizio rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT sarnatarochiara rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT schiavonstefano rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests AT tagliapietrafranco rumeninoculumcollectedfromcowsatslaughterorfromacontinuousfermenterandpreservedinwarmrefrigeratedchilledorfreezedriedenvironmentsforinvitrotests |