Cargando…

Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years

PURPOSE: To comprehensively assess the Randot Preschool stereo test in young children, including testability, normative values, test/retest reliability and sensitivity and specificity for detecting binocular vision disorders. METHODS: We tested 1005 children aged 2–11 years with the Randot Preschool...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Read, Jenny C. A., Rafiq, Sheima, Hugill, Jess, Casanova, Therese, Black, Carla, O’Neill, Adam, Puyat, Vicente, Haggerty, Helen, Smart, Kathryn, Powell, Christine, Taylor, Kate, Clarke, Michael P., Vancleef, Kathleen
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6837395/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31697704
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0224402
_version_ 1783467072699760640
author Read, Jenny C. A.
Rafiq, Sheima
Hugill, Jess
Casanova, Therese
Black, Carla
O’Neill, Adam
Puyat, Vicente
Haggerty, Helen
Smart, Kathryn
Powell, Christine
Taylor, Kate
Clarke, Michael P.
Vancleef, Kathleen
author_facet Read, Jenny C. A.
Rafiq, Sheima
Hugill, Jess
Casanova, Therese
Black, Carla
O’Neill, Adam
Puyat, Vicente
Haggerty, Helen
Smart, Kathryn
Powell, Christine
Taylor, Kate
Clarke, Michael P.
Vancleef, Kathleen
author_sort Read, Jenny C. A.
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: To comprehensively assess the Randot Preschool stereo test in young children, including testability, normative values, test/retest reliability and sensitivity and specificity for detecting binocular vision disorders. METHODS: We tested 1005 children aged 2–11 years with the Randot Preschool stereo test, plus a cover/uncover test to detect heterotropia. Monocular visual acuity was assessed in both eyes using Keeler Crowded LogMAR visual acuity test for children aged 4 and over. RESULTS: Testability was very high: 65% in two-year-olds, 92% in three-year-olds and ~100% in older children. Normative values: In 389 children aged 2–5 with apparently normal vision, 6% of children scored nil (stereoblind). In those who obtained a threshold, the mean log threshold was 2.06 log(10) arcsec, corresponding to 114 arcsec, and the median threshold was 100 arcsec. Most older children score 40 arcsec, the best available score. We found a small sex difference, with girls scoring slightly but significantly better. Test/retest reliability: ~99% for obtaining any score vs nil. Agreement between stereo thresholds is poor in children aged 2–5; 95% limit of agreement = 0.7 log(10) arcsec: five-fold change in stereo threshold may occur without any change in vision. In children over 5, the test essentially acts only as a binary classifier since almost all non-stereoblind children score 40 arcsec. Specificity (true negative rate): >95%. Sensitivity (true positive rate): poor, <50%, i.e. around half of children with a demonstrable binocular vision abnormality score well on the Randot Preschool. CONCLUSIONS: The Randot Preschool is extremely accessible for even very young children, and is very reliable at classifying children into those who have any stereo vision vs those who are stereoblind. However, its ability to quantify stereo vision is limited by poor repeatability in children aged 5 and under, and a very limited range of scores relevant to children aged over 5.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6837395
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-68373952019-11-14 Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years Read, Jenny C. A. Rafiq, Sheima Hugill, Jess Casanova, Therese Black, Carla O’Neill, Adam Puyat, Vicente Haggerty, Helen Smart, Kathryn Powell, Christine Taylor, Kate Clarke, Michael P. Vancleef, Kathleen PLoS One Research Article PURPOSE: To comprehensively assess the Randot Preschool stereo test in young children, including testability, normative values, test/retest reliability and sensitivity and specificity for detecting binocular vision disorders. METHODS: We tested 1005 children aged 2–11 years with the Randot Preschool stereo test, plus a cover/uncover test to detect heterotropia. Monocular visual acuity was assessed in both eyes using Keeler Crowded LogMAR visual acuity test for children aged 4 and over. RESULTS: Testability was very high: 65% in two-year-olds, 92% in three-year-olds and ~100% in older children. Normative values: In 389 children aged 2–5 with apparently normal vision, 6% of children scored nil (stereoblind). In those who obtained a threshold, the mean log threshold was 2.06 log(10) arcsec, corresponding to 114 arcsec, and the median threshold was 100 arcsec. Most older children score 40 arcsec, the best available score. We found a small sex difference, with girls scoring slightly but significantly better. Test/retest reliability: ~99% for obtaining any score vs nil. Agreement between stereo thresholds is poor in children aged 2–5; 95% limit of agreement = 0.7 log(10) arcsec: five-fold change in stereo threshold may occur without any change in vision. In children over 5, the test essentially acts only as a binary classifier since almost all non-stereoblind children score 40 arcsec. Specificity (true negative rate): >95%. Sensitivity (true positive rate): poor, <50%, i.e. around half of children with a demonstrable binocular vision abnormality score well on the Randot Preschool. CONCLUSIONS: The Randot Preschool is extremely accessible for even very young children, and is very reliable at classifying children into those who have any stereo vision vs those who are stereoblind. However, its ability to quantify stereo vision is limited by poor repeatability in children aged 5 and under, and a very limited range of scores relevant to children aged over 5. Public Library of Science 2019-11-07 /pmc/articles/PMC6837395/ /pubmed/31697704 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0224402 Text en © 2019 Read et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Read, Jenny C. A.
Rafiq, Sheima
Hugill, Jess
Casanova, Therese
Black, Carla
O’Neill, Adam
Puyat, Vicente
Haggerty, Helen
Smart, Kathryn
Powell, Christine
Taylor, Kate
Clarke, Michael P.
Vancleef, Kathleen
Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title_full Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title_fullStr Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title_full_unstemmed Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title_short Characterizing the Randot Preschool stereotest: Testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
title_sort characterizing the randot preschool stereotest: testability, norms, reliability, specificity and sensitivity in children aged 2-11 years
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6837395/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31697704
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0224402
work_keys_str_mv AT readjennyca characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT rafiqsheima characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT hugilljess characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT casanovatherese characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT blackcarla characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT oneilladam characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT puyatvicente characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT haggertyhelen characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT smartkathryn characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT powellchristine characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT taylorkate characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT clarkemichaelp characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years
AT vancleefkathleen characterizingtherandotpreschoolstereotesttestabilitynormsreliabilityspecificityandsensitivityinchildrenaged211years