Cargando…
The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report
The diagnosis of fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTD) is primarily based on initial visual recognition of a suspected case followed by confirmatory laboratory testing, which is often limited to specialized facilities. Although molecular and serodiagnostic tools have advanced, a substantial gap r...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
MDPI
2019
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6958312/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31554262 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/tropicalmed4040122 |
_version_ | 1783487384546967552 |
---|---|
author | Hay, Roderick Denning, David W Bonifaz, Alexandro Queiroz-Telles, Flavio Beer, Karlyn Bustamante, Beatriz Chakrabarti, Arunaloke Chavez-Lopez, Maria de Guadalupe Chiller, Tom Cornet, Muriel Estrada, Roberto Estrada-Chavez, Guadalupe Fahal, Ahmed Gomez, Beatriz L Li, Ruoyu Mahabeer, Yesholata Mosam, Anisa Soavina Ramarozatovo, Lala Rakoto Andrianarivelo, Mala Rapelanoro Rabenja, Fahafahantsoa van de Sande, Wendy Zijlstra, Eduard E |
author_facet | Hay, Roderick Denning, David W Bonifaz, Alexandro Queiroz-Telles, Flavio Beer, Karlyn Bustamante, Beatriz Chakrabarti, Arunaloke Chavez-Lopez, Maria de Guadalupe Chiller, Tom Cornet, Muriel Estrada, Roberto Estrada-Chavez, Guadalupe Fahal, Ahmed Gomez, Beatriz L Li, Ruoyu Mahabeer, Yesholata Mosam, Anisa Soavina Ramarozatovo, Lala Rakoto Andrianarivelo, Mala Rapelanoro Rabenja, Fahafahantsoa van de Sande, Wendy Zijlstra, Eduard E |
author_sort | Hay, Roderick |
collection | PubMed |
description | The diagnosis of fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTD) is primarily based on initial visual recognition of a suspected case followed by confirmatory laboratory testing, which is often limited to specialized facilities. Although molecular and serodiagnostic tools have advanced, a substantial gap remains between the desirable and the practical in endemic settings. To explore this issue further, we conducted a survey of subject matter experts on the optimal diagnostic methods sufficient to initiate treatment in well-equipped versus basic healthcare settings, as well as optimal sampling methods, for three fungal NTDs: mycetoma, chromoblastomycosis, and sporotrichosis. A survey of 23 centres found consensus on the key role of semi-invasive sampling methods such as biopsy diagnosis as compared with swabs or impression smears, and on the importance of histopathology, direct microscopy, and culture for mycetoma and chromoblastomycosis confirmation in well-equipped laboratories. In basic healthcare settings, direct microscopy combined with clinical signs were reported to be the most useful diagnostic indicators to prompt referral for treatment. The survey identified that the diagnosis of sporotrichosis is the most problematic with poor sensitivity across the most widely available laboratory tests except fungal culture, highlighting the need to improve mycological diagnostic capacity and to develop innovative diagnostic solutions. Fungal microscopy and culture are now recognized as WHO essential diagnostic tests and better training in their application will help improve the situation. For mycetoma and sporotrichosis, in particular, advances in identifying specific marker antigens or genomic sequences may pave the way for new laboratory-based or point-of-care tests, although this is a formidable task given the large number of different organisms that can cause fungal NTDs. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6958312 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2019 |
publisher | MDPI |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-69583122020-01-23 The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report Hay, Roderick Denning, David W Bonifaz, Alexandro Queiroz-Telles, Flavio Beer, Karlyn Bustamante, Beatriz Chakrabarti, Arunaloke Chavez-Lopez, Maria de Guadalupe Chiller, Tom Cornet, Muriel Estrada, Roberto Estrada-Chavez, Guadalupe Fahal, Ahmed Gomez, Beatriz L Li, Ruoyu Mahabeer, Yesholata Mosam, Anisa Soavina Ramarozatovo, Lala Rakoto Andrianarivelo, Mala Rapelanoro Rabenja, Fahafahantsoa van de Sande, Wendy Zijlstra, Eduard E Trop Med Infect Dis Article The diagnosis of fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTD) is primarily based on initial visual recognition of a suspected case followed by confirmatory laboratory testing, which is often limited to specialized facilities. Although molecular and serodiagnostic tools have advanced, a substantial gap remains between the desirable and the practical in endemic settings. To explore this issue further, we conducted a survey of subject matter experts on the optimal diagnostic methods sufficient to initiate treatment in well-equipped versus basic healthcare settings, as well as optimal sampling methods, for three fungal NTDs: mycetoma, chromoblastomycosis, and sporotrichosis. A survey of 23 centres found consensus on the key role of semi-invasive sampling methods such as biopsy diagnosis as compared with swabs or impression smears, and on the importance of histopathology, direct microscopy, and culture for mycetoma and chromoblastomycosis confirmation in well-equipped laboratories. In basic healthcare settings, direct microscopy combined with clinical signs were reported to be the most useful diagnostic indicators to prompt referral for treatment. The survey identified that the diagnosis of sporotrichosis is the most problematic with poor sensitivity across the most widely available laboratory tests except fungal culture, highlighting the need to improve mycological diagnostic capacity and to develop innovative diagnostic solutions. Fungal microscopy and culture are now recognized as WHO essential diagnostic tests and better training in their application will help improve the situation. For mycetoma and sporotrichosis, in particular, advances in identifying specific marker antigens or genomic sequences may pave the way for new laboratory-based or point-of-care tests, although this is a formidable task given the large number of different organisms that can cause fungal NTDs. MDPI 2019-09-24 /pmc/articles/PMC6958312/ /pubmed/31554262 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/tropicalmed4040122 Text en © 2019 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/). |
spellingShingle | Article Hay, Roderick Denning, David W Bonifaz, Alexandro Queiroz-Telles, Flavio Beer, Karlyn Bustamante, Beatriz Chakrabarti, Arunaloke Chavez-Lopez, Maria de Guadalupe Chiller, Tom Cornet, Muriel Estrada, Roberto Estrada-Chavez, Guadalupe Fahal, Ahmed Gomez, Beatriz L Li, Ruoyu Mahabeer, Yesholata Mosam, Anisa Soavina Ramarozatovo, Lala Rakoto Andrianarivelo, Mala Rapelanoro Rabenja, Fahafahantsoa van de Sande, Wendy Zijlstra, Eduard E The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title | The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title_full | The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title_fullStr | The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title_full_unstemmed | The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title_short | The Diagnosis of Fungal Neglected Tropical Diseases (Fungal NTDs) and the Role of Investigation and Laboratory Tests: An Expert Consensus Report |
title_sort | diagnosis of fungal neglected tropical diseases (fungal ntds) and the role of investigation and laboratory tests: an expert consensus report |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6958312/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31554262 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/tropicalmed4040122 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT hayroderick thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT denningdavidw thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT bonifazalexandro thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT queiroztellesflavio thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT beerkarlyn thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT bustamantebeatriz thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chakrabartiarunaloke thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chavezlopezmariadeguadalupe thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chillertom thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT cornetmuriel thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT estradaroberto thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT estradachavezguadalupe thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT fahalahmed thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT gomezbeatrizl thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT liruoyu thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT mahabeeryesholata thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT mosamanisa thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT soavinaramarozatovolala thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT rakotoandrianarivelomala thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT rapelanororabenjafahafahantsoa thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT vandesandewendy thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT zijlstraeduarde thediagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT hayroderick diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT denningdavidw diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT bonifazalexandro diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT queiroztellesflavio diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT beerkarlyn diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT bustamantebeatriz diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chakrabartiarunaloke diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chavezlopezmariadeguadalupe diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT chillertom diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT cornetmuriel diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT estradaroberto diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT estradachavezguadalupe diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT fahalahmed diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT gomezbeatrizl diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT liruoyu diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT mahabeeryesholata diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT mosamanisa diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT soavinaramarozatovolala diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT rakotoandrianarivelomala diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT rapelanororabenjafahafahantsoa diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT vandesandewendy diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport AT zijlstraeduarde diagnosisoffungalneglectedtropicaldiseasesfungalntdsandtheroleofinvestigationandlaboratorytestsanexpertconsensusreport |