Cargando…
A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial
PURPOSE: Uncertainty exists regarding the best way to communicate cardiovascular risk (CVR) to patients, and it is unclear whether the comprehension and perception of CVR varies according to the format used. The aim of the present work was to determine whether a strategy designed for communicating C...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6977759/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31971952 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0226398 |
_version_ | 1783490581952987136 |
---|---|
author | Escortell-Mayor, Esperanza del Cura-González, Isabel Ojeda-Ruiz, Elena Sanz-Cuesta, Teresa Rodríguez-Salceda, Isidro García-Soltero, Jesús Rojas-Giraldo, María-José Herrera-Municio, Pedro Jorge-Formariz, Alicia Lorenzo-Lobato, Ángela Cabello-Ballesteros, Luisa Riesgo-Fuertes, Rosario Garrido-Elustondo, Sofía Morey-Montalvo, Mariel Rico-Blázquez, Milagros Rodríguez-Barrientos, Ricardo Fuente-Arriaran, María-Dolores Sierra-Ocaña, Gloria Serrano-Serrano, Encarnación Sanz-Velasco, Carmelina Carrascoso-Calvo, Roberto Recio-Velasco, Juan Carlos Sanz-Sanz, Marta Rumayor-Zarzuelo, Mercedes Bermejo-Mayoral, Olga-Inés Galán-Esteban, Josefina Sarría-Santamera, Antonio |
author_facet | Escortell-Mayor, Esperanza del Cura-González, Isabel Ojeda-Ruiz, Elena Sanz-Cuesta, Teresa Rodríguez-Salceda, Isidro García-Soltero, Jesús Rojas-Giraldo, María-José Herrera-Municio, Pedro Jorge-Formariz, Alicia Lorenzo-Lobato, Ángela Cabello-Ballesteros, Luisa Riesgo-Fuertes, Rosario Garrido-Elustondo, Sofía Morey-Montalvo, Mariel Rico-Blázquez, Milagros Rodríguez-Barrientos, Ricardo Fuente-Arriaran, María-Dolores Sierra-Ocaña, Gloria Serrano-Serrano, Encarnación Sanz-Velasco, Carmelina Carrascoso-Calvo, Roberto Recio-Velasco, Juan Carlos Sanz-Sanz, Marta Rumayor-Zarzuelo, Mercedes Bermejo-Mayoral, Olga-Inés Galán-Esteban, Josefina Sarría-Santamera, Antonio |
author_sort | Escortell-Mayor, Esperanza |
collection | PubMed |
description | PURPOSE: Uncertainty exists regarding the best way to communicate cardiovascular risk (CVR) to patients, and it is unclear whether the comprehension and perception of CVR varies according to the format used. The aim of the present work was to determine whether a strategy designed for communicating CVR information to patients with poorly controlled high blood pressure (HBP), but with no background of cardiovascular disease, was more effective than usual care in the control of blood pressure (BP) over the course of a year. METHODS: A pragmatic, two-arm, cluster-randomized controlled trial was performed. Consecutive patients aged 40–65 years, all diagnosed with HBP in the last 12 months, and all of whom showed poor control of their condition (systolic BP ≥140 mmHg and/or diastolic BP ≥90 mmHg), were recruited at 22 primary healthcare centres. Eleven centres were randomly assigned to the usual care arm, and 11 to the informative intervention arm (Educore arm). At the start of the study, the Educore arm subjects were shown the "low risk SCORE table", along with impacting images and information pamphlets encouraging the maintenance of good cardiovascular health. The main outcome variable measured was the control of HBP; the secondary outcome variables were SCORE table score, total plasma cholesterol concentration, use of tobacco, adherence to prescribed treatment, and quality of life. RESULTS: The study participants were 411 patients (185 in the Educore arm and 226 in the usual care arm). Multilevel logistic regression showed that, at 12 months, the Educore intervention achieved better control of HBP (OR = 1.57; 1.02 to 2.41). No statistically significant differences were seen between the two arms at 12 months with respect to the secondary outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to usual care, the Educore intervention was associated with better control of HBP after adjusting for age, baseline SBP and plasma cholesterol, at 12 months. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-6977759 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-69777592020-02-07 A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial Escortell-Mayor, Esperanza del Cura-González, Isabel Ojeda-Ruiz, Elena Sanz-Cuesta, Teresa Rodríguez-Salceda, Isidro García-Soltero, Jesús Rojas-Giraldo, María-José Herrera-Municio, Pedro Jorge-Formariz, Alicia Lorenzo-Lobato, Ángela Cabello-Ballesteros, Luisa Riesgo-Fuertes, Rosario Garrido-Elustondo, Sofía Morey-Montalvo, Mariel Rico-Blázquez, Milagros Rodríguez-Barrientos, Ricardo Fuente-Arriaran, María-Dolores Sierra-Ocaña, Gloria Serrano-Serrano, Encarnación Sanz-Velasco, Carmelina Carrascoso-Calvo, Roberto Recio-Velasco, Juan Carlos Sanz-Sanz, Marta Rumayor-Zarzuelo, Mercedes Bermejo-Mayoral, Olga-Inés Galán-Esteban, Josefina Sarría-Santamera, Antonio PLoS One Research Article PURPOSE: Uncertainty exists regarding the best way to communicate cardiovascular risk (CVR) to patients, and it is unclear whether the comprehension and perception of CVR varies according to the format used. The aim of the present work was to determine whether a strategy designed for communicating CVR information to patients with poorly controlled high blood pressure (HBP), but with no background of cardiovascular disease, was more effective than usual care in the control of blood pressure (BP) over the course of a year. METHODS: A pragmatic, two-arm, cluster-randomized controlled trial was performed. Consecutive patients aged 40–65 years, all diagnosed with HBP in the last 12 months, and all of whom showed poor control of their condition (systolic BP ≥140 mmHg and/or diastolic BP ≥90 mmHg), were recruited at 22 primary healthcare centres. Eleven centres were randomly assigned to the usual care arm, and 11 to the informative intervention arm (Educore arm). At the start of the study, the Educore arm subjects were shown the "low risk SCORE table", along with impacting images and information pamphlets encouraging the maintenance of good cardiovascular health. The main outcome variable measured was the control of HBP; the secondary outcome variables were SCORE table score, total plasma cholesterol concentration, use of tobacco, adherence to prescribed treatment, and quality of life. RESULTS: The study participants were 411 patients (185 in the Educore arm and 226 in the usual care arm). Multilevel logistic regression showed that, at 12 months, the Educore intervention achieved better control of HBP (OR = 1.57; 1.02 to 2.41). No statistically significant differences were seen between the two arms at 12 months with respect to the secondary outcomes. CONCLUSIONS: Compared to usual care, the Educore intervention was associated with better control of HBP after adjusting for age, baseline SBP and plasma cholesterol, at 12 months. Public Library of Science 2020-01-23 /pmc/articles/PMC6977759/ /pubmed/31971952 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0226398 Text en © 2020 Escortell-Mayor et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Escortell-Mayor, Esperanza del Cura-González, Isabel Ojeda-Ruiz, Elena Sanz-Cuesta, Teresa Rodríguez-Salceda, Isidro García-Soltero, Jesús Rojas-Giraldo, María-José Herrera-Municio, Pedro Jorge-Formariz, Alicia Lorenzo-Lobato, Ángela Cabello-Ballesteros, Luisa Riesgo-Fuertes, Rosario Garrido-Elustondo, Sofía Morey-Montalvo, Mariel Rico-Blázquez, Milagros Rodríguez-Barrientos, Ricardo Fuente-Arriaran, María-Dolores Sierra-Ocaña, Gloria Serrano-Serrano, Encarnación Sanz-Velasco, Carmelina Carrascoso-Calvo, Roberto Recio-Velasco, Juan Carlos Sanz-Sanz, Marta Rumayor-Zarzuelo, Mercedes Bermejo-Mayoral, Olga-Inés Galán-Esteban, Josefina Sarría-Santamera, Antonio A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title | A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title_full | A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title_fullStr | A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title_full_unstemmed | A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title_short | A primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: The Education and Coronary Risk Evaluation (Educore) study—A pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
title_sort | primary healthcare information intervention for communicating cardiovascular risk to patients with poorly controlled hypertension: the education and coronary risk evaluation (educore) study—a pragmatic, cluster-randomized trial |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6977759/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31971952 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0226398 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT escortellmayoresperanza aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT delcuragonzalezisabel aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT ojedaruizelena aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzcuestateresa aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rodriguezsalcedaisidro aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT garciasolterojesus aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rojasgiraldomariajose aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT herreramuniciopedro aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT jorgeformarizalicia aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT lorenzolobatoangela aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT cabelloballesterosluisa aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT riesgofuertesrosario aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT garridoelustondosofia aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT moreymontalvomariel aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT ricoblazquezmilagros aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rodriguezbarrientosricardo aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT fuentearriaranmariadolores aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sierraocanagloria aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT serranoserranoencarnacion aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzvelascocarmelina aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT carrascosocalvoroberto aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT reciovelascojuancarlos aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzsanzmarta aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rumayorzarzuelomercedes aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT bermejomayoralolgaines aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT galanestebanjosefina aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sarriasantameraantonio aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT aprimaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT escortellmayoresperanza primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT delcuragonzalezisabel primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT ojedaruizelena primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzcuestateresa primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rodriguezsalcedaisidro primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT garciasolterojesus primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rojasgiraldomariajose primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT herreramuniciopedro primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT jorgeformarizalicia primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT lorenzolobatoangela primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT cabelloballesterosluisa primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT riesgofuertesrosario primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT garridoelustondosofia primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT moreymontalvomariel primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT ricoblazquezmilagros primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rodriguezbarrientosricardo primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT fuentearriaranmariadolores primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sierraocanagloria primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT serranoserranoencarnacion primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzvelascocarmelina primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT carrascosocalvoroberto primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT reciovelascojuancarlos primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sanzsanzmarta primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT rumayorzarzuelomercedes primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT bermejomayoralolgaines primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT galanestebanjosefina primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT sarriasantameraantonio primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial AT primaryhealthcareinformationinterventionforcommunicatingcardiovascularrisktopatientswithpoorlycontrolledhypertensiontheeducationandcoronaryriskevaluationeducorestudyapragmaticclusterrandomizedtrial |