Is the initiation of selfing linked to a hermaphrodite’s female or male reproductive function?

ABSTRACT: There is an ongoing debate about whether simultaneous hermaphrodites capable of selfing should prefer selfing over outcrossing or vice versa. While many theoretical models predict a transmission advantage for alleles that favour selfing, empirical studies often reveal low selfing rates. Despite these considerations, the underlying mechanisms that determine reproductive strategies in simultaneously hermaphroditic animals are poorly understood. In our study on the facultatively selfing free-living flatworm, Macrostomum hystrix, we ask whether the initiation of selfing, as inferred from the differential spatial distribution of received sperm, is linked to an individual’s female or male reproductive function. Specifically, the initiation of selfing could (i) be linked to the male function, when an individual is unable to donate sperm to others and hence donates sperm to self, or it could (ii) be linked to the female function, when an individual fails to receive sperm from others—and hence is unable to fertilize its eggs via outcrossing—thus inducing it to self-fertilize. We experimentally created a social environment that allowed focals to outcross via sperm donation, but simultaneously prevented them from receiving sperm—by pairing them with a partner lacking the male copulatory organ—so that fertilization of the focal’s eggs was restricted to selfing. Our results suggest that such focals generally do not initiate selfing, while we readily observe selfing in isolated worms. This suggests that in isolated M. hystrix, it is the male function that is linked to the initiation of selfing, likely due to a lack of opportunities for sperm donation. SIGNIFICANCE STATEMENT: A variety of simultaneously hermaphroditic animals are capable of reproducing via both selfing and outcrossing. While the reproductive choices of such animals can be modelled by the joint action of genetic (e.g. inbreeding depression) and ecological factors (e.g. partner availability), experimental evaluation of theoretical results is often lacking. By manipulating the social environment of focal individuals, we here provide evidence that explores the respective role that the co-occurring male and female sex functions have on the initiation of selfing in a simultaneously hermaphroditic flatworm species. Specifically, our results suggest that the initiation of selfing is linked to the worm’s male function. Insights about which function is linked to the initiation of selfing may ultimately help to better understand reproductive decisions in simultaneous hermaphrodites. ELECTRONIC SUPPLEMENTARY MATERIAL: The online version of this article (10.1007/s00265-020-2816-3) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.