Cargando…
A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers: www.nutritools.org
Background: Health researchers may struggle to choose suitable validated dietary assessment tools (DATs) for their target population. The aim of this review was to identify and collate information on validated UK DATs and validation studies for inclusion on a website to support researchers to choose...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Taylor & Francis
2019
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7114915/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30882230 http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2019.1566207 |
_version_ | 1783513986876047360 |
---|---|
author | Hooson (Jzh), Jozef Hutchinson (Jyh), Jayne Warthon-Medina, Marisol Hancock, Neil Greathead, Katharine Knowles, Bethany Vargas-Garcia, Elisa Gibson, Lauren E. Bush, Linda A. Margetts, Barrie Robinson, Sian Ness, Andy Alwan, Nisreen A. Wark, Petra A. Roe, Mark Finglas, Paul Steer, Toni Page, Polly Johnson, Laura Roberts, Katharine Amoutzopoulos, Birdem Burley, Victoria J. Greenwood, Darren C. Cade, Janet E. |
author_facet | Hooson (Jzh), Jozef Hutchinson (Jyh), Jayne Warthon-Medina, Marisol Hancock, Neil Greathead, Katharine Knowles, Bethany Vargas-Garcia, Elisa Gibson, Lauren E. Bush, Linda A. Margetts, Barrie Robinson, Sian Ness, Andy Alwan, Nisreen A. Wark, Petra A. Roe, Mark Finglas, Paul Steer, Toni Page, Polly Johnson, Laura Roberts, Katharine Amoutzopoulos, Birdem Burley, Victoria J. Greenwood, Darren C. Cade, Janet E. |
author_sort | Hooson (Jzh), Jozef |
collection | PubMed |
description | Background: Health researchers may struggle to choose suitable validated dietary assessment tools (DATs) for their target population. The aim of this review was to identify and collate information on validated UK DATs and validation studies for inclusion on a website to support researchers to choose appropriate DATs. Design: A systematic review of reviews of DATs was undertaken. DATs validated in UK populations were extracted from the studies identified. A searchable website was designed to display these data. Additionally, mean differences and limits of agreement between test and comparison methods were summarized by a method, weighting by sample size. Results: Over 900 validation results covering 5 life stages, 18 nutrients, 6 dietary assessment methods, and 9 validation method types were extracted from 63 validated DATs which were identified from 68 reviews. These were incorporated into www.nutritools.org. Limits of agreement were determined for about half of validations. Thirty four DATs were FFQs. Only 17 DATs were validated against biomarkers, and only 19 DATs were validated in infant/children/adolescents. Conclusions: The interactive www.nutritools.org website holds extensive validation data identified from this review and can be used to guide researchers to critically compare and choose a suitable DAT for their research question, leading to improvement of nutritional epidemiology research. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7114915 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2019 |
publisher | Taylor & Francis |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-71149152020-04-16 A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers: www.nutritools.org Hooson (Jzh), Jozef Hutchinson (Jyh), Jayne Warthon-Medina, Marisol Hancock, Neil Greathead, Katharine Knowles, Bethany Vargas-Garcia, Elisa Gibson, Lauren E. Bush, Linda A. Margetts, Barrie Robinson, Sian Ness, Andy Alwan, Nisreen A. Wark, Petra A. Roe, Mark Finglas, Paul Steer, Toni Page, Polly Johnson, Laura Roberts, Katharine Amoutzopoulos, Birdem Burley, Victoria J. Greenwood, Darren C. Cade, Janet E. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr Reviews Background: Health researchers may struggle to choose suitable validated dietary assessment tools (DATs) for their target population. The aim of this review was to identify and collate information on validated UK DATs and validation studies for inclusion on a website to support researchers to choose appropriate DATs. Design: A systematic review of reviews of DATs was undertaken. DATs validated in UK populations were extracted from the studies identified. A searchable website was designed to display these data. Additionally, mean differences and limits of agreement between test and comparison methods were summarized by a method, weighting by sample size. Results: Over 900 validation results covering 5 life stages, 18 nutrients, 6 dietary assessment methods, and 9 validation method types were extracted from 63 validated DATs which were identified from 68 reviews. These were incorporated into www.nutritools.org. Limits of agreement were determined for about half of validations. Thirty four DATs were FFQs. Only 17 DATs were validated against biomarkers, and only 19 DATs were validated in infant/children/adolescents. Conclusions: The interactive www.nutritools.org website holds extensive validation data identified from this review and can be used to guide researchers to critically compare and choose a suitable DAT for their research question, leading to improvement of nutritional epidemiology research. Taylor & Francis 2019-03-18 /pmc/articles/PMC7114915/ /pubmed/30882230 http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2019.1566207 Text en © 2019 The Author(s). Published with license by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) ), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Reviews Hooson (Jzh), Jozef Hutchinson (Jyh), Jayne Warthon-Medina, Marisol Hancock, Neil Greathead, Katharine Knowles, Bethany Vargas-Garcia, Elisa Gibson, Lauren E. Bush, Linda A. Margetts, Barrie Robinson, Sian Ness, Andy Alwan, Nisreen A. Wark, Petra A. Roe, Mark Finglas, Paul Steer, Toni Page, Polly Johnson, Laura Roberts, Katharine Amoutzopoulos, Birdem Burley, Victoria J. Greenwood, Darren C. Cade, Janet E. A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers: www.nutritools.org |
title | A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
title_full | A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
title_fullStr | A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
title_full_unstemmed | A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
title_short | A systematic review of reviews identifying UK validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
title_sort | systematic review of reviews identifying uk validated dietary assessment
tools for inclusion on an interactive guided website for researchers:
www.nutritools.org |
topic | Reviews |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7114915/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/30882230 http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/10408398.2019.1566207 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT hoosonjzhjozef asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT hutchinsonjyhjayne asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT warthonmedinamarisol asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT hancockneil asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT greatheadkatharine asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT knowlesbethany asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT vargasgarciaelisa asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT gibsonlaurene asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT bushlindaa asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT margettsbarrie asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT robinsonsian asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT nessandy asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT alwannisreena asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT warkpetraa asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT roemark asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT finglaspaul asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT steertoni asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT pagepolly asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT johnsonlaura asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT robertskatharine asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT amoutzopoulosbirdem asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT burleyvictoriaj asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT greenwooddarrenc asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT cadejanete asystematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT hoosonjzhjozef systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT hutchinsonjyhjayne systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT warthonmedinamarisol systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT hancockneil systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT greatheadkatharine systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT knowlesbethany systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT vargasgarciaelisa systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT gibsonlaurene systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT bushlindaa systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT margettsbarrie systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT robinsonsian systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT nessandy systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT alwannisreena systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT warkpetraa systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT roemark systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT finglaspaul systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT steertoni systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT pagepolly systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT johnsonlaura systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT robertskatharine systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT amoutzopoulosbirdem systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT burleyvictoriaj systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT greenwooddarrenc systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg AT cadejanete systematicreviewofreviewsidentifyingukvalidateddietaryassessmenttoolsforinclusiononaninteractiveguidedwebsiteforresearcherswwwnutritoolsorg |