Cargando…
Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients
BACKGROUND: Multiple approaches have been proposed to measure low socio-economic status. In France the concept of precariousness, akin to social deprivation, was developed and is widely used. EPICES is a short questionnaire that was developed to measure this concept. This study aimed to evaluate Dif...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7117693/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32240217 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0230661 |
_version_ | 1783514424008507392 |
---|---|
author | Guilloteau, Adrien Binquet, Christine Bourredjem, Abderrahmane Fournel, Isabelle Lalanne-Mistrih, Marie Laure Nacher, Mathieu Rochemont, Devi Cabie, André Mimeau, Emmanuelle Mislin-Tritsch, Caroline Joux, Julien Lannuzel, Annie Bonithon-Kopp, Claire Béjot, Yannick Devilliers, Hervé |
author_facet | Guilloteau, Adrien Binquet, Christine Bourredjem, Abderrahmane Fournel, Isabelle Lalanne-Mistrih, Marie Laure Nacher, Mathieu Rochemont, Devi Cabie, André Mimeau, Emmanuelle Mislin-Tritsch, Caroline Joux, Julien Lannuzel, Annie Bonithon-Kopp, Claire Béjot, Yannick Devilliers, Hervé |
author_sort | Guilloteau, Adrien |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Multiple approaches have been proposed to measure low socio-economic status. In France the concept of precariousness, akin to social deprivation, was developed and is widely used. EPICES is a short questionnaire that was developed to measure this concept. This study aimed to evaluate Differential Item Functioning (DIF) in the EPICES questionnaire between contrasted areas: mainland France, French West Indies (FWI) and French Guiana (FG). METHODS: The population was taken from the INDIA study, which aimed to evaluate the impact of social inequalities on stroke characteristics and prognosis. Eligible people were patients referred to neurology or emergency departments for a suspicion of stroke. We assessed the DIF using hybrid ordinal logistic regression method, derived from item response theory. RESULTS: We analysed 1 553 stroke patients, including 768 from FWI (49.5%), 289 from FG (18.6%) and 496 from mainland (31.9%). We identified five items with a moderate to large DIF in area comparisons: “meeting with a social worker”, “complementary health insurance”, “home-owning”, “financial difficulties” and “sport activities”. Correlation between EPICES score and the latent variable was strong (r = 0.84). CONCLUSION: This is the first attempt to assess the DIF of the EPICES score between different French populations. We found several items with DIF, which can be explained by individual interpretation or local context. However, the DIFs did not lead to a large difference between the latent variable and the EPICES score, which indicates that it can be used to assess precariousness and social deprivation between contrasted areas. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7117693 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-71176932020-04-09 Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients Guilloteau, Adrien Binquet, Christine Bourredjem, Abderrahmane Fournel, Isabelle Lalanne-Mistrih, Marie Laure Nacher, Mathieu Rochemont, Devi Cabie, André Mimeau, Emmanuelle Mislin-Tritsch, Caroline Joux, Julien Lannuzel, Annie Bonithon-Kopp, Claire Béjot, Yannick Devilliers, Hervé PLoS One Research Article BACKGROUND: Multiple approaches have been proposed to measure low socio-economic status. In France the concept of precariousness, akin to social deprivation, was developed and is widely used. EPICES is a short questionnaire that was developed to measure this concept. This study aimed to evaluate Differential Item Functioning (DIF) in the EPICES questionnaire between contrasted areas: mainland France, French West Indies (FWI) and French Guiana (FG). METHODS: The population was taken from the INDIA study, which aimed to evaluate the impact of social inequalities on stroke characteristics and prognosis. Eligible people were patients referred to neurology or emergency departments for a suspicion of stroke. We assessed the DIF using hybrid ordinal logistic regression method, derived from item response theory. RESULTS: We analysed 1 553 stroke patients, including 768 from FWI (49.5%), 289 from FG (18.6%) and 496 from mainland (31.9%). We identified five items with a moderate to large DIF in area comparisons: “meeting with a social worker”, “complementary health insurance”, “home-owning”, “financial difficulties” and “sport activities”. Correlation between EPICES score and the latent variable was strong (r = 0.84). CONCLUSION: This is the first attempt to assess the DIF of the EPICES score between different French populations. We found several items with DIF, which can be explained by individual interpretation or local context. However, the DIFs did not lead to a large difference between the latent variable and the EPICES score, which indicates that it can be used to assess precariousness and social deprivation between contrasted areas. Public Library of Science 2020-04-02 /pmc/articles/PMC7117693/ /pubmed/32240217 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0230661 Text en © 2020 Guilloteau et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Guilloteau, Adrien Binquet, Christine Bourredjem, Abderrahmane Fournel, Isabelle Lalanne-Mistrih, Marie Laure Nacher, Mathieu Rochemont, Devi Cabie, André Mimeau, Emmanuelle Mislin-Tritsch, Caroline Joux, Julien Lannuzel, Annie Bonithon-Kopp, Claire Béjot, Yannick Devilliers, Hervé Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title | Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title_full | Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title_fullStr | Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title_full_unstemmed | Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title_short | Social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: Using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the EPICES questionnaire in stroke patients |
title_sort | social deprivation among socio-economic contrasted french areas: using item response theory analysis to assess differential item functioning of the epices questionnaire in stroke patients |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7117693/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32240217 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0230661 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT guilloteauadrien socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT binquetchristine socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT bourredjemabderrahmane socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT fournelisabelle socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT lalannemistrihmarielaure socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT nachermathieu socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT rochemontdevi socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT cabieandre socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT mimeauemmanuelle socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT mislintritschcaroline socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT jouxjulien socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT lannuzelannie socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT bonithonkoppclaire socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT bejotyannick socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT devilliersherve socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients AT socialdeprivationamongsocioeconomiccontrastedfrenchareasusingitemresponsetheoryanalysistoassessdifferentialitemfunctioningoftheepicesquestionnaireinstrokepatients |