Cargando…

Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy

PURPOSE: The limited radiotherapy resources for global cancer control have resulted in increased interest in developing time- and cost-saving innovations to expand access to those resources. Hypofractionated regimens could minimize cost and increase access for limited-resource countries. In this inv...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Irabor, Omoruyi Credit, Swanson, William, Shaukat, Fiza, Wirtz, Johanna, Mallum, Abba Aji, Ngoma, Twalib, Elzawawy, Ahmed, Nguyen, Paul, Incrocci, Luca, Ngwa, Wilfred
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: American Society of Clinical Oncology 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7193821/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32343628
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JGO.19.00261
_version_ 1783528258063564800
author Irabor, Omoruyi Credit
Swanson, William
Shaukat, Fiza
Wirtz, Johanna
Mallum, Abba Aji
Ngoma, Twalib
Elzawawy, Ahmed
Nguyen, Paul
Incrocci, Luca
Ngwa, Wilfred
author_facet Irabor, Omoruyi Credit
Swanson, William
Shaukat, Fiza
Wirtz, Johanna
Mallum, Abba Aji
Ngoma, Twalib
Elzawawy, Ahmed
Nguyen, Paul
Incrocci, Luca
Ngwa, Wilfred
author_sort Irabor, Omoruyi Credit
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: The limited radiotherapy resources for global cancer control have resulted in increased interest in developing time- and cost-saving innovations to expand access to those resources. Hypofractionated regimens could minimize cost and increase access for limited-resource countries. In this investigation, we estimated the percentage cost-savings per radiotherapy course and increased radiotherapy access in African countries after adopting hypofractionation for breast and prostate radiotherapy. For perspective, results were compared with high-income countries. METHODS: The cost and course of breast and prostate radiotherapy for conventional and hypofractionated regimens in low-resource facilities were calculated using the Radiotherapy Cost Estimator tool developed by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and then compared with another activity-based costing model. The potential maximum cost savings in each country over 7 years for breast and prostate radiotherapy were then estimated using cancer incidence data from the Global Cancer Observatory database with use rates applied. The increase in radiotherapy access was estimated by current national capacities from the IAEA directory. RESULTS: The estimated cost per course of conventional and hypofractionated regimens were US$2,232 and $1,339 for breast treatment, and $3,389 and $1,699 for prostate treatment, respectively. The projected potential maximum cost savings with full hypofractionation implementation were $1.1 billion and $606 million for breast and prostate treatment, respectively. The projected increase of radiotherapy access due to implementing hypofractionation varied between +0.3% to 25% and +0.4% to 36.0% for breast and prostate treatments, respectively. CONCLUSION: This investigation demonstrates that adopting hypofractionated regimens as standard treatment of breast and prostate cancers can result in substantial savings and increase radiotherapy access in developing countries. Given reduced delivery cost and treatment times, we anticipate a substantial increase in radiotherapy access with additional innovations that will allow progressive hypofractionation without compromising quality.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7193821
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher American Society of Clinical Oncology
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-71938212020-06-03 Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy Irabor, Omoruyi Credit Swanson, William Shaukat, Fiza Wirtz, Johanna Mallum, Abba Aji Ngoma, Twalib Elzawawy, Ahmed Nguyen, Paul Incrocci, Luca Ngwa, Wilfred JCO Glob Oncol Review Articles PURPOSE: The limited radiotherapy resources for global cancer control have resulted in increased interest in developing time- and cost-saving innovations to expand access to those resources. Hypofractionated regimens could minimize cost and increase access for limited-resource countries. In this investigation, we estimated the percentage cost-savings per radiotherapy course and increased radiotherapy access in African countries after adopting hypofractionation for breast and prostate radiotherapy. For perspective, results were compared with high-income countries. METHODS: The cost and course of breast and prostate radiotherapy for conventional and hypofractionated regimens in low-resource facilities were calculated using the Radiotherapy Cost Estimator tool developed by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) and then compared with another activity-based costing model. The potential maximum cost savings in each country over 7 years for breast and prostate radiotherapy were then estimated using cancer incidence data from the Global Cancer Observatory database with use rates applied. The increase in radiotherapy access was estimated by current national capacities from the IAEA directory. RESULTS: The estimated cost per course of conventional and hypofractionated regimens were US$2,232 and $1,339 for breast treatment, and $3,389 and $1,699 for prostate treatment, respectively. The projected potential maximum cost savings with full hypofractionation implementation were $1.1 billion and $606 million for breast and prostate treatment, respectively. The projected increase of radiotherapy access due to implementing hypofractionation varied between +0.3% to 25% and +0.4% to 36.0% for breast and prostate treatments, respectively. CONCLUSION: This investigation demonstrates that adopting hypofractionated regimens as standard treatment of breast and prostate cancers can result in substantial savings and increase radiotherapy access in developing countries. Given reduced delivery cost and treatment times, we anticipate a substantial increase in radiotherapy access with additional innovations that will allow progressive hypofractionation without compromising quality. American Society of Clinical Oncology 2020-04-28 /pmc/articles/PMC7193821/ /pubmed/32343628 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JGO.19.00261 Text en © 2020 by American Society of Clinical Oncology https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial No Derivatives 4.0 License: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/
spellingShingle Review Articles
Irabor, Omoruyi Credit
Swanson, William
Shaukat, Fiza
Wirtz, Johanna
Mallum, Abba Aji
Ngoma, Twalib
Elzawawy, Ahmed
Nguyen, Paul
Incrocci, Luca
Ngwa, Wilfred
Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title_full Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title_fullStr Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title_full_unstemmed Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title_short Can the Adoption of Hypofractionation Guidelines Expand Global Radiotherapy Access? An Analysis for Breast and Prostate Radiotherapy
title_sort can the adoption of hypofractionation guidelines expand global radiotherapy access? an analysis for breast and prostate radiotherapy
topic Review Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7193821/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32343628
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/JGO.19.00261
work_keys_str_mv AT iraboromoruyicredit cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT swansonwilliam cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT shaukatfiza cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT wirtzjohanna cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT mallumabbaaji cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT ngomatwalib cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT elzawawyahmed cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT nguyenpaul cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT incrocciluca cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy
AT ngwawilfred cantheadoptionofhypofractionationguidelinesexpandglobalradiotherapyaccessananalysisforbreastandprostateradiotherapy