Cargando…
MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes
Training of diabetes (DM) skills is critical to assure competency of DM survival skills (e.g. glucose testing) for immediate self-care. While DM assessments exist, we sought to develop a culturally acceptable DM Skills and Knowledge Assessment (DM-SKA) tool. A systematic search of Pubmed/Medline and...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7207771/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.1404 |
_version_ | 1783530683311849472 |
---|---|
author | Hakimian, Stephanie Karam, Susan Pardilla, Kim Coyne, Kasey Touma, Emilie K Larsen, Diane Holl, Jane L Wallia, Amisha Grace, Prince |
author_facet | Hakimian, Stephanie Karam, Susan Pardilla, Kim Coyne, Kasey Touma, Emilie K Larsen, Diane Holl, Jane L Wallia, Amisha Grace, Prince |
author_sort | Hakimian, Stephanie |
collection | PubMed |
description | Training of diabetes (DM) skills is critical to assure competency of DM survival skills (e.g. glucose testing) for immediate self-care. While DM assessments exist, we sought to develop a culturally acceptable DM Skills and Knowledge Assessment (DM-SKA) tool. A systematic search of Pubmed/Medline and Scopus (1980-2017) of assessments for DM knowledge was performed. 24 studies were identified, only 33% reported minority populations. Studies were classified by topic: measurement of DM skills, objectives of DM training, assessments of DM education, and other non-patient assessments. Content from existing assessments was adapted to create a 12 question DM-SKA to address 6 domains: DM, blood glucose and self-monitoring, support services, identification management of hypo and hyperglycemia, and insulin administration. To assess cultural acceptance, cognitive evaluations were conducted in individual user sessions and focus groups. The DM-SKA had a baseline Flesch reading score of 81.3 (low complexity language) and Flesch-Kincaid reading grade level of 5.3. Of 39 approached, 85% (N=33) participated (6 inpatients refused, feeling “overwhelmed”). Participants were diverse, including 8 clinicians, 10 patients/caregivers, and 15 laypersons; 46% were non-Hispanic whites, 33% non-Hispanic blacks, 12% Hispanics, and 9% Asian Americans. Mean age of patient/caregiver/laypersons was 57.8±17 (44% > age 65) and 40.1±12 years for clinicians (12.5% > age 65). All clinicians reported that appropriate DM skill domains were included and felt patients would complete the tool. All patients/caregivers and laypersons (N=25) verbalized adequate comprehension of each question; 96% reported willingness to complete the DM-SKA if provided and 88% reported their family, friends or someone in their community would be willing to complete it. However, both providers (N=2) and patients (N=2) reported concerns about assessment format and delivery [e.g. “testing” or “quiz”]. Some younger (<65 years) patients/caregiver/laypersons (N= 4) reported concerns about potential willingness of elderly family members to complete the tool. However, acceptability of the DM-SKA was noted from all participants >65 years. Vision problems and older age were identified as potential barriers. Of those offered the assessment (N = 25), 5 (20%) participants needed assistance [N=2 vision, N=3 English as second language]. Mean DM-SKA score was 10.2±1.7 of 12. Incorrect answers mostly occurred for questions with multiple correct answers. The DM-SKA has acceptable literacy characteristics, cognitive validity, and cultural acceptability by racial/ethnic minority populations, including elderly persons. Future work includes integration into clinical workflows and incorporation of patient preferences. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7207771 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-72077712020-05-13 MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes Hakimian, Stephanie Karam, Susan Pardilla, Kim Coyne, Kasey Touma, Emilie K Larsen, Diane Holl, Jane L Wallia, Amisha Grace, Prince J Endocr Soc Healthcare Delivery and Education Training of diabetes (DM) skills is critical to assure competency of DM survival skills (e.g. glucose testing) for immediate self-care. While DM assessments exist, we sought to develop a culturally acceptable DM Skills and Knowledge Assessment (DM-SKA) tool. A systematic search of Pubmed/Medline and Scopus (1980-2017) of assessments for DM knowledge was performed. 24 studies were identified, only 33% reported minority populations. Studies were classified by topic: measurement of DM skills, objectives of DM training, assessments of DM education, and other non-patient assessments. Content from existing assessments was adapted to create a 12 question DM-SKA to address 6 domains: DM, blood glucose and self-monitoring, support services, identification management of hypo and hyperglycemia, and insulin administration. To assess cultural acceptance, cognitive evaluations were conducted in individual user sessions and focus groups. The DM-SKA had a baseline Flesch reading score of 81.3 (low complexity language) and Flesch-Kincaid reading grade level of 5.3. Of 39 approached, 85% (N=33) participated (6 inpatients refused, feeling “overwhelmed”). Participants were diverse, including 8 clinicians, 10 patients/caregivers, and 15 laypersons; 46% were non-Hispanic whites, 33% non-Hispanic blacks, 12% Hispanics, and 9% Asian Americans. Mean age of patient/caregiver/laypersons was 57.8±17 (44% > age 65) and 40.1±12 years for clinicians (12.5% > age 65). All clinicians reported that appropriate DM skill domains were included and felt patients would complete the tool. All patients/caregivers and laypersons (N=25) verbalized adequate comprehension of each question; 96% reported willingness to complete the DM-SKA if provided and 88% reported their family, friends or someone in their community would be willing to complete it. However, both providers (N=2) and patients (N=2) reported concerns about assessment format and delivery [e.g. “testing” or “quiz”]. Some younger (<65 years) patients/caregiver/laypersons (N= 4) reported concerns about potential willingness of elderly family members to complete the tool. However, acceptability of the DM-SKA was noted from all participants >65 years. Vision problems and older age were identified as potential barriers. Of those offered the assessment (N = 25), 5 (20%) participants needed assistance [N=2 vision, N=3 English as second language]. Mean DM-SKA score was 10.2±1.7 of 12. Incorrect answers mostly occurred for questions with multiple correct answers. The DM-SKA has acceptable literacy characteristics, cognitive validity, and cultural acceptability by racial/ethnic minority populations, including elderly persons. Future work includes integration into clinical workflows and incorporation of patient preferences. Oxford University Press 2020-05-08 /pmc/articles/PMC7207771/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.1404 Text en © Endocrine Society 2020. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com |
spellingShingle | Healthcare Delivery and Education Hakimian, Stephanie Karam, Susan Pardilla, Kim Coyne, Kasey Touma, Emilie K Larsen, Diane Holl, Jane L Wallia, Amisha Grace, Prince MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title | MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title_full | MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title_fullStr | MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title_full_unstemmed | MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title_short | MON-139 Development of a Culturally Competent Skills and Knowledge Assessment Tool for Patients with Diabetes |
title_sort | mon-139 development of a culturally competent skills and knowledge assessment tool for patients with diabetes |
topic | Healthcare Delivery and Education |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7207771/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.1404 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT hakimianstephanie mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT karamsusan mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT pardillakim mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT coynekasey mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT toumaemiliek mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT larsendiane mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT holljanel mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT walliaamisha mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes AT graceprince mon139developmentofaculturallycompetentskillsandknowledgeassessmenttoolforpatientswithdiabetes |