Cargando…

OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)

Approximately 50% of Primary Aldosteronism (PA) cases are unilateral, potentially curable by adrenalectomy. However far fewer patients progress to surgery, partly due to difficulties in identifying unilateral disease. AVS is the current criterion standard method for lateralisation. However it is an...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Wu, Xilin, Goodchild, Emily, Senanayake, Russell, Bashari, Waiel, Salsbury, Jackie, Argentesi, Giulia, O’Toole, Samuel Matthew, Matson, Matthew, Parvanta, Laila, Marker, Alison, Berney, Daniel, Sadhev, Anju, Bird, Nicholas, McConnachie, Alexander, Cruickshank, Kennedy, Cheow, Heok K, Gurnell, Mark, Drake, William, Brown, Morris Jonathan
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7208751/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.519
_version_ 1783530919507787776
author Wu, Xilin
Goodchild, Emily
Senanayake, Russell
Bashari, Waiel
Salsbury, Jackie
Argentesi, Giulia
O’Toole, Samuel Matthew
Matson, Matthew
Parvanta, Laila
Marker, Alison
Berney, Daniel
Sadhev, Anju
Bird, Nicholas
McConnachie, Alexander
Cruickshank, Kennedy
Cheow, Heok K
Gurnell, Mark
Drake, William
Brown, Morris Jonathan
author_facet Wu, Xilin
Goodchild, Emily
Senanayake, Russell
Bashari, Waiel
Salsbury, Jackie
Argentesi, Giulia
O’Toole, Samuel Matthew
Matson, Matthew
Parvanta, Laila
Marker, Alison
Berney, Daniel
Sadhev, Anju
Bird, Nicholas
McConnachie, Alexander
Cruickshank, Kennedy
Cheow, Heok K
Gurnell, Mark
Drake, William
Brown, Morris Jonathan
author_sort Wu, Xilin
collection PubMed
description Approximately 50% of Primary Aldosteronism (PA) cases are unilateral, potentially curable by adrenalectomy. However far fewer patients progress to surgery, partly due to difficulties in identifying unilateral disease. AVS is the current criterion standard method for lateralisation. However it is an invasive procedure, technically difficult to perform, and only available in few specialist centres. MATCH is a prospective, multicentre study comparing the diagnostic accuracy of AVS with (11)C-metomidate PET-CT, a non-invasive functional scan (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier NCT02945904). Patients fulfilling Endocrine Society criteria for PA undergo both investigations in random order. At a multidisciplinary meeting PET-CT results are scored first, followed by AVS. Patients are offered surgery if one or both investigations indicate unilateral disease. Each investigation will be re-scored by an independent, blinded endpoints committee, without knowledge of other investigations or outcomes in the same patient. Hierarchical primary outcomes are the change in aldosterone renin ratio (ARR) and average home SBP readings. If no superiority is observed for either investigation, non-inferiority of PET-CT will be tested. MATCH is powered to detect 25% superiority, or non-inferiority within a margin of 18%. Factors predicting cure will be assessed as secondary outcomes. These include BP response to aldosterone antagonists, correlation of standardised uptake value (SUV) max ratio of adenoma to adjacent normal adrenal, and phenotyping / genotyping of tumours. Target recruitment of 140 patients has been achieved. Interesting observations to date include a high prevalence of hypokalaemia (73%), reflective of our referral base and inclusion criteria. The surgery rate is also high at 66%, consistent with finding frequent patients in whom only one investigation yields a positive result. The following case illustrates such a patient. A slim 45-year-old lady with PA and failed ONDST had inconclusive AVS (selectivity index in right adrenal vein 2.6). PET-CT revealed a 29mm metomidate-avid left adrenal nodule (SUVmax ratio 1.52, >1.25 suggestive of unilateral disease). Left adrenalectomy was recommended based on PET-CT, and achieved biochemical and clinical cure. However she required hydrocortisone replacement for 14 months. Her relatively low right adrenal vein cortisol, despite successful cannulation, was attributed to contralateral suppression by co-secretion of cortisol from her adenoma. This was confirmed by finding high CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 mRNA expression in her tumour, typical of a KCNJ5 mutation, confirmed as L168R on Sanger sequencing. PA is a high risk subset of hypertension. Under-treatment has serious public health consequences. (11)C-Metomidate PET CT has the potential to simplify the investigation pathway and allow more patients to receive potentially curable treatment.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7208751
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-72087512020-05-13 OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs) Wu, Xilin Goodchild, Emily Senanayake, Russell Bashari, Waiel Salsbury, Jackie Argentesi, Giulia O’Toole, Samuel Matthew Matson, Matthew Parvanta, Laila Marker, Alison Berney, Daniel Sadhev, Anju Bird, Nicholas McConnachie, Alexander Cruickshank, Kennedy Cheow, Heok K Gurnell, Mark Drake, William Brown, Morris Jonathan J Endocr Soc Cardiovascular Endocrinology Approximately 50% of Primary Aldosteronism (PA) cases are unilateral, potentially curable by adrenalectomy. However far fewer patients progress to surgery, partly due to difficulties in identifying unilateral disease. AVS is the current criterion standard method for lateralisation. However it is an invasive procedure, technically difficult to perform, and only available in few specialist centres. MATCH is a prospective, multicentre study comparing the diagnostic accuracy of AVS with (11)C-metomidate PET-CT, a non-invasive functional scan (ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier NCT02945904). Patients fulfilling Endocrine Society criteria for PA undergo both investigations in random order. At a multidisciplinary meeting PET-CT results are scored first, followed by AVS. Patients are offered surgery if one or both investigations indicate unilateral disease. Each investigation will be re-scored by an independent, blinded endpoints committee, without knowledge of other investigations or outcomes in the same patient. Hierarchical primary outcomes are the change in aldosterone renin ratio (ARR) and average home SBP readings. If no superiority is observed for either investigation, non-inferiority of PET-CT will be tested. MATCH is powered to detect 25% superiority, or non-inferiority within a margin of 18%. Factors predicting cure will be assessed as secondary outcomes. These include BP response to aldosterone antagonists, correlation of standardised uptake value (SUV) max ratio of adenoma to adjacent normal adrenal, and phenotyping / genotyping of tumours. Target recruitment of 140 patients has been achieved. Interesting observations to date include a high prevalence of hypokalaemia (73%), reflective of our referral base and inclusion criteria. The surgery rate is also high at 66%, consistent with finding frequent patients in whom only one investigation yields a positive result. The following case illustrates such a patient. A slim 45-year-old lady with PA and failed ONDST had inconclusive AVS (selectivity index in right adrenal vein 2.6). PET-CT revealed a 29mm metomidate-avid left adrenal nodule (SUVmax ratio 1.52, >1.25 suggestive of unilateral disease). Left adrenalectomy was recommended based on PET-CT, and achieved biochemical and clinical cure. However she required hydrocortisone replacement for 14 months. Her relatively low right adrenal vein cortisol, despite successful cannulation, was attributed to contralateral suppression by co-secretion of cortisol from her adenoma. This was confirmed by finding high CYP11B1 and CYP11B2 mRNA expression in her tumour, typical of a KCNJ5 mutation, confirmed as L168R on Sanger sequencing. PA is a high risk subset of hypertension. Under-treatment has serious public health consequences. (11)C-Metomidate PET CT has the potential to simplify the investigation pathway and allow more patients to receive potentially curable treatment. Oxford University Press 2020-05-08 /pmc/articles/PMC7208751/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.519 Text en © Endocrine Society 2020. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Cardiovascular Endocrinology
Wu, Xilin
Goodchild, Emily
Senanayake, Russell
Bashari, Waiel
Salsbury, Jackie
Argentesi, Giulia
O’Toole, Samuel Matthew
Matson, Matthew
Parvanta, Laila
Marker, Alison
Berney, Daniel
Sadhev, Anju
Bird, Nicholas
McConnachie, Alexander
Cruickshank, Kennedy
Cheow, Heok K
Gurnell, Mark
Drake, William
Brown, Morris Jonathan
OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title_full OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title_fullStr OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title_full_unstemmed OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title_short OR34-07 Prospective Multicentre Study Comparing (11)C-metomidate PET CT with Adrenal Vein Sampling (AVS) in the Detection of Unilateral Aldosterone-Producing Adenomas (APAs)
title_sort or34-07 prospective multicentre study comparing (11)c-metomidate pet ct with adrenal vein sampling (avs) in the detection of unilateral aldosterone-producing adenomas (apas)
topic Cardiovascular Endocrinology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7208751/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.519
work_keys_str_mv AT wuxilin or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT goodchildemily or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT senanayakerussell or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT bashariwaiel or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT salsburyjackie or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT argentesigiulia or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT otoolesamuelmatthew or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT matsonmatthew or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT parvantalaila or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT markeralison or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT berneydaniel or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT sadhevanju or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT birdnicholas or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT mcconnachiealexander or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT cruickshankkennedy or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT cheowheokk or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT gurnellmark or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT drakewilliam or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas
AT brownmorrisjonathan or3407prospectivemulticentrestudycomparing11cmetomidatepetctwithadrenalveinsamplingavsinthedetectionofunilateralaldosteroneproducingadenomasapas