Cargando…

SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?

INTRODUCTION: Bone metabolism assessment includes total alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and more specifically the bone-alkaline phosphatase (BAP) as markers of bone formation. Its measurement is important for diagnosis and in bone pathology treatment following-up. In our setting, a ten-fold price for BAP...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sequera, Ana M, Ruibal, Gabriela Fernanda, Chavarria, Eleonora Nuñez, Fideleff, Gabriel, Iparraguirre, María Jose, Farelo, Hilda Ines
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7208963/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.2168
_version_ 1783530969386450944
author Sequera, Ana M
Ruibal, Gabriela Fernanda
Chavarria, Eleonora Nuñez
Fideleff, Gabriel
Iparraguirre, María Jose
Farelo, Hilda Ines
author_facet Sequera, Ana M
Ruibal, Gabriela Fernanda
Chavarria, Eleonora Nuñez
Fideleff, Gabriel
Iparraguirre, María Jose
Farelo, Hilda Ines
author_sort Sequera, Ana M
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Bone metabolism assessment includes total alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and more specifically the bone-alkaline phosphatase (BAP) as markers of bone formation. Its measurement is important for diagnosis and in bone pathology treatment following-up. In our setting, a ten-fold price for BAP has raised the necesity to review in how many cases its request has been justified. AIM: Establish through an appropiate statistical analysis, cut-off values of ALP that could guarantee to perform BAP measurements. Its analysis would allow us to make a demand adequacy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective study was carried out on laboratory analysis orders of 405 adult women. We separate them into the following groups: (G1): 48 premenopausal womens (pre) and 357 post menopausal women (pos): (G2)133 <60 years-old, (G3)135: 60-69 years-old and (G4)89: >70 years-old. All patients had measurements of both analytes; ALP (colorimetric method, Roche Cobas, Reference value (RefV)=40-130 UI/L) and BAP (QLIA, Liaison Diasorin, RefV pre=3-19 ug/mL, pos=6-26 ug/mL). Statistic analysis: ROC-Plot to define cut-off value (we define as true positive BAP values over RefV). Kruskal Wallis, Dunn test to compare all the groups. RESULTS: (median and range): ALP(UI/L) G1: 81(38-265) G2: 88(47-211)*, G3: 85(39-213) y G4: 80(40-138) (*p<0.05 G2vsG4). BAP (ug/L) G1: 13.6(5.1-106), G2: 14.3(3.5-61.5)*, G3: 13.9(2.9-52.5) and G4: 11.6(2.0-29.6), (*p<0.05 G2vsG4). We observe that 73% of G1, 93.5% of G2, 92.6% of G3, 97.7% of G4 has showed normal values. The ROC plot analysis showed the best cut-off for ALP in G1=87 (S=92%,Sp=85%,AUC=0.955). If, using this cut off we had processed 18 BAP which 6 patients would have been normal (33.4%). In G2=127 (S=100%, Sp=97.6%, AUC=0.996) using this cut off we had processed 13 BAP, which 4 patients would have been normal (30.8%). Meanwhile in G3=102(S=100%, Sp=85.6%, AUC=0.97) we had processed 30 BAP and G4=120 (S=100%, Sp=96.5%, AUC=0.966) we had processed only 6 BAP. CONCLUSIONS: Application of the calculated cut-off allowed us to investigate 97% of the pathological BAPs. The measurement of ALP first, would guarantee to process only 17% of the requested BAPs. This suggestion would result in a significant saving of our resources, maintaining the quality of care. It is necessary to apply cut-off according to age to justify the BAP assesment. Physicians must define the appropriate exceptions.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7208963
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-72089632020-05-13 SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request? Sequera, Ana M Ruibal, Gabriela Fernanda Chavarria, Eleonora Nuñez Fideleff, Gabriel Iparraguirre, María Jose Farelo, Hilda Ines J Endocr Soc Bone and Mineral Metabolism INTRODUCTION: Bone metabolism assessment includes total alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and more specifically the bone-alkaline phosphatase (BAP) as markers of bone formation. Its measurement is important for diagnosis and in bone pathology treatment following-up. In our setting, a ten-fold price for BAP has raised the necesity to review in how many cases its request has been justified. AIM: Establish through an appropiate statistical analysis, cut-off values of ALP that could guarantee to perform BAP measurements. Its analysis would allow us to make a demand adequacy. MATERIALS AND METHODS: A retrospective study was carried out on laboratory analysis orders of 405 adult women. We separate them into the following groups: (G1): 48 premenopausal womens (pre) and 357 post menopausal women (pos): (G2)133 <60 years-old, (G3)135: 60-69 years-old and (G4)89: >70 years-old. All patients had measurements of both analytes; ALP (colorimetric method, Roche Cobas, Reference value (RefV)=40-130 UI/L) and BAP (QLIA, Liaison Diasorin, RefV pre=3-19 ug/mL, pos=6-26 ug/mL). Statistic analysis: ROC-Plot to define cut-off value (we define as true positive BAP values over RefV). Kruskal Wallis, Dunn test to compare all the groups. RESULTS: (median and range): ALP(UI/L) G1: 81(38-265) G2: 88(47-211)*, G3: 85(39-213) y G4: 80(40-138) (*p<0.05 G2vsG4). BAP (ug/L) G1: 13.6(5.1-106), G2: 14.3(3.5-61.5)*, G3: 13.9(2.9-52.5) and G4: 11.6(2.0-29.6), (*p<0.05 G2vsG4). We observe that 73% of G1, 93.5% of G2, 92.6% of G3, 97.7% of G4 has showed normal values. The ROC plot analysis showed the best cut-off for ALP in G1=87 (S=92%,Sp=85%,AUC=0.955). If, using this cut off we had processed 18 BAP which 6 patients would have been normal (33.4%). In G2=127 (S=100%, Sp=97.6%, AUC=0.996) using this cut off we had processed 13 BAP, which 4 patients would have been normal (30.8%). Meanwhile in G3=102(S=100%, Sp=85.6%, AUC=0.97) we had processed 30 BAP and G4=120 (S=100%, Sp=96.5%, AUC=0.966) we had processed only 6 BAP. CONCLUSIONS: Application of the calculated cut-off allowed us to investigate 97% of the pathological BAPs. The measurement of ALP first, would guarantee to process only 17% of the requested BAPs. This suggestion would result in a significant saving of our resources, maintaining the quality of care. It is necessary to apply cut-off according to age to justify the BAP assesment. Physicians must define the appropriate exceptions. Oxford University Press 2020-05-08 /pmc/articles/PMC7208963/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.2168 Text en © Endocrine Society 2020. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs licence (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/), which permits non-commercial reproduction and distribution of the work, in any medium, provided the original work is not altered or transformed in any way, and that the work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Bone and Mineral Metabolism
Sequera, Ana M
Ruibal, Gabriela Fernanda
Chavarria, Eleonora Nuñez
Fideleff, Gabriel
Iparraguirre, María Jose
Farelo, Hilda Ines
SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title_full SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title_fullStr SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title_full_unstemmed SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title_short SUN-LB73 Is It Possible to Optimize Resources in Bone-Alkaline Phosphatase Medical Request?
title_sort sun-lb73 is it possible to optimize resources in bone-alkaline phosphatase medical request?
topic Bone and Mineral Metabolism
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7208963/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1210/jendso/bvaa046.2168
work_keys_str_mv AT sequeraanam sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest
AT ruibalgabrielafernanda sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest
AT chavarriaeleonoranunez sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest
AT fideleffgabriel sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest
AT iparraguirremariajose sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest
AT farelohildaines sunlb73isitpossibletooptimizeresourcesinbonealkalinephosphatasemedicalrequest