Cargando…

O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS

BACKGROUND: Psychiatry aspires to disease understanding and precision medicine. Biological research supporting such missions in psychosis may be compromised by continued reliance on clinical phenomenology in the search for pathophysiological mechanisms. A transdiagnostic deep phenotyping approach, s...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Clementz, Brett, Trotti, Rebekah, Pearlson, Godfrey D, Keshavan, Matcheri, Gershon, Elliot, Keedy, Sarah, Ivleva, Elena, McDowell, Jennifer E, Tamminga, Carol
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7234003/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa028.015
_version_ 1783535663945089024
author Clementz, Brett
Trotti, Rebekah
Pearlson, Godfrey D
Keshavan, Matcheri
Gershon, Elliot
Keedy, Sarah
Ivleva, Elena
McDowell, Jennifer E
Tamminga, Carol
author_facet Clementz, Brett
Trotti, Rebekah
Pearlson, Godfrey D
Keshavan, Matcheri
Gershon, Elliot
Keedy, Sarah
Ivleva, Elena
McDowell, Jennifer E
Tamminga, Carol
author_sort Clementz, Brett
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Psychiatry aspires to disease understanding and precision medicine. Biological research supporting such missions in psychosis may be compromised by continued reliance on clinical phenomenology in the search for pathophysiological mechanisms. A transdiagnostic deep phenotyping approach, such as that used by the Bipolar-Schizophrenia Network for Intermediate Phenotypes (B-SNIP), offers a promising strategy for discovery of biological mechanisms underlying psychosis syndromes. The B-SNIP consortium has identified biological subtypes of psychosis, Biotypes, which outperform conventional DSM diagnoses when accounting for variance of multiple external validating measures. While these biological distinctions are scientifically remarkable, their resulting clinical manifestations and potential utility in clinical practice is of paramount importance. METHODS: Approximately 1500 psychosis cases and 450 healthy persons were administered the B-SNIP biomarker battery (including MRI, EEG, ocular motor, and cognition measures). Psychosis cases were also clinically characterized using multiple measures, including MADRS, PANSS, YMRS, and Birchwood. Numerical taxonomy approaches were used for identifying biologically homogenous psychosis subgroups (gap and TWO-STEP cluster identifications, k-means clustering, and canonical discriminant analysis). ANOVA models were used to analyze external validating measures. Multivariate discriminant models were used to identify clinical features differentiating conventional psychosis syndromes and psychosis Biotypes. RESULTS: There was remarkable similarity between previously published biomarker profiles for DSM psychosis syndromes and a new sample of psychosis cases (average r=.92). Numerical taxonomy on biomarker data recovered three subgroups (replicating previous findings), and the biomarker profiles were highly similar to previous results (average r=.87). Schizoaffective cases were both the most diverse and the most clearly differentiated from schizophrenia and bipolar cases (on conative negative symptoms, depression, and mania) in clinical feature space. The only feature that uniquely distinguished schizophrenia was social-relational negative symptoms. Biotype-1 was characterized by accentuations on clinical features consistent with their biomarker deviations (relational negative symptoms, poor social functioning, and dysfunction of cognition). Alternatively, Biotype-2, also consistent with their biomarker deviations, had clinical features indicating neurophysiological dysregulation (most specifically physiological and behavioral dysregulation). Biotype-3 cases, the most normal across biomarkers, were noticeably absent of Biotype-1 clinical features and had more restricted clinical manifestations than any other Biotype or DSM subgroup. We illustrate three possible Biotype-specific treatment targets. DISCUSSION: Replication of B-SNIP psychosis Biotypes indicates the possible utility and importance of neurobiological subtyping within psychosis that can yield specific treatment targets. In an analysis of clinical features, B-SNIP found that Biotypes have unique and defining clinical features that are consistent with their neurobiological profiles. Biotypes and DSM psychosis subgroups are neither neurobiologically nor clinically redundant. Specific treatment targets for psychosis Biotypes are not derivable from conventional clinical psychosis diagnoses. B-SNIP outcomes provide a background for future work that could establish psychiatry as a laboratory discipline, at least with regard to care of psychosis patients. This path is hypothetical at the moment but aspirational for the field.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7234003
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-72340032020-05-23 O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS Clementz, Brett Trotti, Rebekah Pearlson, Godfrey D Keshavan, Matcheri Gershon, Elliot Keedy, Sarah Ivleva, Elena McDowell, Jennifer E Tamminga, Carol Schizophr Bull Oral Session: Digital Health/Methods BACKGROUND: Psychiatry aspires to disease understanding and precision medicine. Biological research supporting such missions in psychosis may be compromised by continued reliance on clinical phenomenology in the search for pathophysiological mechanisms. A transdiagnostic deep phenotyping approach, such as that used by the Bipolar-Schizophrenia Network for Intermediate Phenotypes (B-SNIP), offers a promising strategy for discovery of biological mechanisms underlying psychosis syndromes. The B-SNIP consortium has identified biological subtypes of psychosis, Biotypes, which outperform conventional DSM diagnoses when accounting for variance of multiple external validating measures. While these biological distinctions are scientifically remarkable, their resulting clinical manifestations and potential utility in clinical practice is of paramount importance. METHODS: Approximately 1500 psychosis cases and 450 healthy persons were administered the B-SNIP biomarker battery (including MRI, EEG, ocular motor, and cognition measures). Psychosis cases were also clinically characterized using multiple measures, including MADRS, PANSS, YMRS, and Birchwood. Numerical taxonomy approaches were used for identifying biologically homogenous psychosis subgroups (gap and TWO-STEP cluster identifications, k-means clustering, and canonical discriminant analysis). ANOVA models were used to analyze external validating measures. Multivariate discriminant models were used to identify clinical features differentiating conventional psychosis syndromes and psychosis Biotypes. RESULTS: There was remarkable similarity between previously published biomarker profiles for DSM psychosis syndromes and a new sample of psychosis cases (average r=.92). Numerical taxonomy on biomarker data recovered three subgroups (replicating previous findings), and the biomarker profiles were highly similar to previous results (average r=.87). Schizoaffective cases were both the most diverse and the most clearly differentiated from schizophrenia and bipolar cases (on conative negative symptoms, depression, and mania) in clinical feature space. The only feature that uniquely distinguished schizophrenia was social-relational negative symptoms. Biotype-1 was characterized by accentuations on clinical features consistent with their biomarker deviations (relational negative symptoms, poor social functioning, and dysfunction of cognition). Alternatively, Biotype-2, also consistent with their biomarker deviations, had clinical features indicating neurophysiological dysregulation (most specifically physiological and behavioral dysregulation). Biotype-3 cases, the most normal across biomarkers, were noticeably absent of Biotype-1 clinical features and had more restricted clinical manifestations than any other Biotype or DSM subgroup. We illustrate three possible Biotype-specific treatment targets. DISCUSSION: Replication of B-SNIP psychosis Biotypes indicates the possible utility and importance of neurobiological subtyping within psychosis that can yield specific treatment targets. In an analysis of clinical features, B-SNIP found that Biotypes have unique and defining clinical features that are consistent with their neurobiological profiles. Biotypes and DSM psychosis subgroups are neither neurobiologically nor clinically redundant. Specific treatment targets for psychosis Biotypes are not derivable from conventional clinical psychosis diagnoses. B-SNIP outcomes provide a background for future work that could establish psychiatry as a laboratory discipline, at least with regard to care of psychosis patients. This path is hypothetical at the moment but aspirational for the field. Oxford University Press 2020-05 2020-05-18 /pmc/articles/PMC7234003/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa028.015 Text en © The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Oral Session: Digital Health/Methods
Clementz, Brett
Trotti, Rebekah
Pearlson, Godfrey D
Keshavan, Matcheri
Gershon, Elliot
Keedy, Sarah
Ivleva, Elena
McDowell, Jennifer E
Tamminga, Carol
O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title_full O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title_fullStr O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title_full_unstemmed O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title_short O3.4. PSYCHOSIS PHENOTYPES FROM B-SNIP FOR CLINICAL ADVANCES: BIOTYPE CHARACTERISTICS AND TARGETS
title_sort o3.4. psychosis phenotypes from b-snip for clinical advances: biotype characteristics and targets
topic Oral Session: Digital Health/Methods
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7234003/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa028.015
work_keys_str_mv AT clementzbrett o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT trottirebekah o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT pearlsongodfreyd o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT keshavanmatcheri o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT gershonelliot o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT keedysarah o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT ivlevaelena o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT mcdowelljennifere o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets
AT tammingacarol o34psychosisphenotypesfrombsnipforclinicaladvancesbiotypecharacteristicsandtargets