Cargando…

T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS

BACKGROUND: Functional deficits associated with the Clinical High Risk (CHR) status very often lead to inability to attend school, unemployment, as well as social isolation, thus calling for predictors of individual functional outcomes which may facilitate the identification of people requiring care...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Antonucci, Linda, Pigoni, Alessandro, Sanfelici, Rachele, Kambeitz-Ilankovic, Lana, Dwyer, Dominic, Ruef, Anne, Chisholm, Katharine, Haidl, Theresa, Rosen, Marlene, Kambeitz, Joseph, Ruhrmann, Stephan, Schultze-Lutter, Frauke, Falkai, Peter, Lencer, Rebekka, Dannlowski, Udo, Upthegrove, Rachel, Salokangas, Raimo, Pantelis, Christos, Meisenzahl, Eva, Wood, Stephen, Brambilla, Paolo, Borgwardt, Stefan, Bertolino, Alessandro, Koutsouleris, Nikolaos
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Oxford University Press 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7234647/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa029.783
_version_ 1783535812800937984
author Antonucci, Linda
Pigoni, Alessandro
Sanfelici, Rachele
Kambeitz-Ilankovic, Lana
Dwyer, Dominic
Ruef, Anne
Chisholm, Katharine
Haidl, Theresa
Rosen, Marlene
Kambeitz, Joseph
Ruhrmann, Stephan
Schultze-Lutter, Frauke
Falkai, Peter
Lencer, Rebekka
Dannlowski, Udo
Upthegrove, Rachel
Salokangas, Raimo
Pantelis, Christos
Meisenzahl, Eva
Wood, Stephen
Brambilla, Paolo
Borgwardt, Stefan
Bertolino, Alessandro
Koutsouleris, Nikolaos
author_facet Antonucci, Linda
Pigoni, Alessandro
Sanfelici, Rachele
Kambeitz-Ilankovic, Lana
Dwyer, Dominic
Ruef, Anne
Chisholm, Katharine
Haidl, Theresa
Rosen, Marlene
Kambeitz, Joseph
Ruhrmann, Stephan
Schultze-Lutter, Frauke
Falkai, Peter
Lencer, Rebekka
Dannlowski, Udo
Upthegrove, Rachel
Salokangas, Raimo
Pantelis, Christos
Meisenzahl, Eva
Wood, Stephen
Brambilla, Paolo
Borgwardt, Stefan
Bertolino, Alessandro
Koutsouleris, Nikolaos
author_sort Antonucci, Linda
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Functional deficits associated with the Clinical High Risk (CHR) status very often lead to inability to attend school, unemployment, as well as social isolation, thus calling for predictors of individual functional outcomes which may facilitate the identification of people requiring care irrespective of transition to psychosis. Studies have revealed that a pattern of cortical and subcortical gray matter volumes (GMV) anomalies measured at baseline in CHR individuals could predict their functional abilities at follow up. Furthermore, literature is consistent in revealing the crucial role of several environmental adverse events in increasing the risk of developing either transition to psychosis, or a worse overall personal functioning. Therefore, the aim of this study is to employ machine learning to test the individual and combined ability of baseline GMV data and of history of environmental adverse events in predicting good vs. poor social and occupational outcome in CHR individuals at follow up. METHODS: 92 CHR individuals recruited from the 7 discovery PRONIA sites were included in this project. Social and occupational impairment at follow up (9–12 months) were respectively measured through the Global Functioning: Social (GF:S) and Role (GF:R) scale, and CHR with a follow up rating of 7 or below were labeled as having a poor functional outcome. This way, we could separate our cohort in 52 poor outcome CHR and 40 good outcome CHR. GMV data were preprocessed following published procedures which allowed also to correct for site effects. The environmental classifier was built based on Childhood Trauma Questionnaire, Bullying Scale, and Premorbid Adjustment Scale (childhood, early adolescence, late adolescence and adulthood) scores. Raw scores have been normalized according to the psychometric properties of the healthy samples used for validating these questionnaires and scale, in order to obtain individual scores of deviation from the normative occurrence of adverse environmental events. GMV and environmental-based predictive models were independently trained and tested within a leave-site-out cross validation framework using a Support Vector Machine algorithm (LIBSVM) through the NeuroMiner software, and their predictions were subsequently combined through stacked generalization procedures. RESULTS: Our GMV-based model could predict follow up social outcome with 67.4% Balanced Accuracy (BAC) and significance (p=0.01), while it could not predict occupational outcome (46.6% BAC). On the other hand, our environmental-based model could discriminate both poor vs. good social and occupational outcomes at follow up with, respectively, 71% and 66.4% BACs, and significance (both p=0.0001). Specifically, the most reliable features in the environmental classifier were scores reflecting deviations from the normative values in childhood trauma and adult premorbid adjustment, for social outcome prediction, and in bullying experiences and late adolescence premorbid adjustment, for occupational outcome prediction. Only for social outcome prediction, stacked models outperformed individual classifiers’ predictions (74.3% BAC, p=0.0001). DISCUSSION: Environmental features seem to be more accurate than GMV in predicting both social and occupational outcomes in CHR. Interestingly, the predictions of follow up social and occupational outcomes rely on different patterns of occurrence of specific environmental adverse events, thus providing novel insights about how environmental adjustment disabilities, bullying and traumatic premorbid experiences may impact on different bad outcomes associated with the CHR status.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7234647
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Oxford University Press
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-72346472020-05-23 T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS Antonucci, Linda Pigoni, Alessandro Sanfelici, Rachele Kambeitz-Ilankovic, Lana Dwyer, Dominic Ruef, Anne Chisholm, Katharine Haidl, Theresa Rosen, Marlene Kambeitz, Joseph Ruhrmann, Stephan Schultze-Lutter, Frauke Falkai, Peter Lencer, Rebekka Dannlowski, Udo Upthegrove, Rachel Salokangas, Raimo Pantelis, Christos Meisenzahl, Eva Wood, Stephen Brambilla, Paolo Borgwardt, Stefan Bertolino, Alessandro Koutsouleris, Nikolaos Schizophr Bull Poster Session III BACKGROUND: Functional deficits associated with the Clinical High Risk (CHR) status very often lead to inability to attend school, unemployment, as well as social isolation, thus calling for predictors of individual functional outcomes which may facilitate the identification of people requiring care irrespective of transition to psychosis. Studies have revealed that a pattern of cortical and subcortical gray matter volumes (GMV) anomalies measured at baseline in CHR individuals could predict their functional abilities at follow up. Furthermore, literature is consistent in revealing the crucial role of several environmental adverse events in increasing the risk of developing either transition to psychosis, or a worse overall personal functioning. Therefore, the aim of this study is to employ machine learning to test the individual and combined ability of baseline GMV data and of history of environmental adverse events in predicting good vs. poor social and occupational outcome in CHR individuals at follow up. METHODS: 92 CHR individuals recruited from the 7 discovery PRONIA sites were included in this project. Social and occupational impairment at follow up (9–12 months) were respectively measured through the Global Functioning: Social (GF:S) and Role (GF:R) scale, and CHR with a follow up rating of 7 or below were labeled as having a poor functional outcome. This way, we could separate our cohort in 52 poor outcome CHR and 40 good outcome CHR. GMV data were preprocessed following published procedures which allowed also to correct for site effects. The environmental classifier was built based on Childhood Trauma Questionnaire, Bullying Scale, and Premorbid Adjustment Scale (childhood, early adolescence, late adolescence and adulthood) scores. Raw scores have been normalized according to the psychometric properties of the healthy samples used for validating these questionnaires and scale, in order to obtain individual scores of deviation from the normative occurrence of adverse environmental events. GMV and environmental-based predictive models were independently trained and tested within a leave-site-out cross validation framework using a Support Vector Machine algorithm (LIBSVM) through the NeuroMiner software, and their predictions were subsequently combined through stacked generalization procedures. RESULTS: Our GMV-based model could predict follow up social outcome with 67.4% Balanced Accuracy (BAC) and significance (p=0.01), while it could not predict occupational outcome (46.6% BAC). On the other hand, our environmental-based model could discriminate both poor vs. good social and occupational outcomes at follow up with, respectively, 71% and 66.4% BACs, and significance (both p=0.0001). Specifically, the most reliable features in the environmental classifier were scores reflecting deviations from the normative values in childhood trauma and adult premorbid adjustment, for social outcome prediction, and in bullying experiences and late adolescence premorbid adjustment, for occupational outcome prediction. Only for social outcome prediction, stacked models outperformed individual classifiers’ predictions (74.3% BAC, p=0.0001). DISCUSSION: Environmental features seem to be more accurate than GMV in predicting both social and occupational outcomes in CHR. Interestingly, the predictions of follow up social and occupational outcomes rely on different patterns of occurrence of specific environmental adverse events, thus providing novel insights about how environmental adjustment disabilities, bullying and traumatic premorbid experiences may impact on different bad outcomes associated with the CHR status. Oxford University Press 2020-05 2020-05-18 /pmc/articles/PMC7234647/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa029.783 Text en © The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Maryland Psychiatric Research Center. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution Non-Commercial License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/), which permits non-commercial re-use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. For commercial re-use, please contact journals.permissions@oup.com
spellingShingle Poster Session III
Antonucci, Linda
Pigoni, Alessandro
Sanfelici, Rachele
Kambeitz-Ilankovic, Lana
Dwyer, Dominic
Ruef, Anne
Chisholm, Katharine
Haidl, Theresa
Rosen, Marlene
Kambeitz, Joseph
Ruhrmann, Stephan
Schultze-Lutter, Frauke
Falkai, Peter
Lencer, Rebekka
Dannlowski, Udo
Upthegrove, Rachel
Salokangas, Raimo
Pantelis, Christos
Meisenzahl, Eva
Wood, Stephen
Brambilla, Paolo
Borgwardt, Stefan
Bertolino, Alessandro
Koutsouleris, Nikolaos
T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title_full T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title_fullStr T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title_full_unstemmed T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title_short T223. MULTIVARIATE PREDICTION OF FOLLOW UP SOCIAL AND OCCUPATIONAL OUTCOME IN CLINICAL HIGH-RISK INDIVIDUALS BASED ON GRAY MATTER VOLUMES AND HISTORY OF ENVIRONMENTAL ADVERSE EVENTS
title_sort t223. multivariate prediction of follow up social and occupational outcome in clinical high-risk individuals based on gray matter volumes and history of environmental adverse events
topic Poster Session III
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7234647/
http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbaa029.783
work_keys_str_mv AT antonuccilinda t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT pigonialessandro t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT sanfelicirachele t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT kambeitzilankoviclana t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT dwyerdominic t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT ruefanne t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT chisholmkatharine t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT haidltheresa t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT rosenmarlene t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT kambeitzjoseph t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT ruhrmannstephan t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT schultzelutterfrauke t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT falkaipeter t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT lencerrebekka t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT dannlowskiudo t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT upthegroverachel t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT salokangasraimo t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT pantelischristos t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT meisenzahleva t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT woodstephen t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT brambillapaolo t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT borgwardtstefan t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT bertolinoalessandro t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents
AT koutsoulerisnikolaos t223multivariatepredictionoffollowupsocialandoccupationaloutcomeinclinicalhighriskindividualsbasedongraymattervolumesandhistoryofenvironmentaladverseevents