Cargando…

Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients

OBJECTIVE: COVID-19 patients may present mild symptoms. The identification of paucisymptomatic patients is paramount in order to interrupt the transmission chain of the virus. Olfactory loss could be one of those early symptoms which might help in the diagnosis of COVID-19 patients. In this study, w...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Calvo-Henriquez, Christian, Maldonado-Alvarado, Byron, Chiesa-Estomba, Carlos, Rivero-Fernández, Irene, Sanz-Rodriguez, Marta, Villarreal, Ithzel María, Rodriguez-Iglesias, Miguel, Mariño-Sánchez, Franklin, Rivero-de-Aguilar, Alejandro, Lechien, Jerome R., Martínez-Capoccioni, Gabriel, Saussez, Sven, Capasso, Robson, Karkos, Petros D., Schriever, Valentin, Martin-Martin, Carlos, Alobid, Isam, Santamaría-Gadea, Alfonso, Fragola, Claudio, Mayo-Yáñez, Miguel, Pérez-Freixo, Hugo, Ninchritz-Becerra, Elisabeth, Soriano-Reixach, María, Mondragon-Rezola, Elisabeth, Ruiz-Coello, Maria del Mar Martínez, Navarro, Raimundo Andrés, García-Fernández, Alfredo, Marchan-López, Álvaro
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Springer Berlin Heidelberg 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7312102/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32583183
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00405-020-06131-3
_version_ 1783549657307152384
author Calvo-Henriquez, Christian
Maldonado-Alvarado, Byron
Chiesa-Estomba, Carlos
Rivero-Fernández, Irene
Sanz-Rodriguez, Marta
Villarreal, Ithzel María
Rodriguez-Iglesias, Miguel
Mariño-Sánchez, Franklin
Rivero-de-Aguilar, Alejandro
Lechien, Jerome R.
Martínez-Capoccioni, Gabriel
Saussez, Sven
Capasso, Robson
Karkos, Petros D.
Schriever, Valentin
Martin-Martin, Carlos
Alobid, Isam
Santamaría-Gadea, Alfonso
Fragola, Claudio
Mayo-Yáñez, Miguel
Pérez-Freixo, Hugo
Ninchritz-Becerra, Elisabeth
Soriano-Reixach, María
Mondragon-Rezola, Elisabeth
Ruiz-Coello, Maria del Mar Martínez
Navarro, Raimundo Andrés
García-Fernández, Alfredo
Marchan-López, Álvaro
author_facet Calvo-Henriquez, Christian
Maldonado-Alvarado, Byron
Chiesa-Estomba, Carlos
Rivero-Fernández, Irene
Sanz-Rodriguez, Marta
Villarreal, Ithzel María
Rodriguez-Iglesias, Miguel
Mariño-Sánchez, Franklin
Rivero-de-Aguilar, Alejandro
Lechien, Jerome R.
Martínez-Capoccioni, Gabriel
Saussez, Sven
Capasso, Robson
Karkos, Petros D.
Schriever, Valentin
Martin-Martin, Carlos
Alobid, Isam
Santamaría-Gadea, Alfonso
Fragola, Claudio
Mayo-Yáñez, Miguel
Pérez-Freixo, Hugo
Ninchritz-Becerra, Elisabeth
Soriano-Reixach, María
Mondragon-Rezola, Elisabeth
Ruiz-Coello, Maria del Mar Martínez
Navarro, Raimundo Andrés
García-Fernández, Alfredo
Marchan-López, Álvaro
author_sort Calvo-Henriquez, Christian
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVE: COVID-19 patients may present mild symptoms. The identification of paucisymptomatic patients is paramount in order to interrupt the transmission chain of the virus. Olfactory loss could be one of those early symptoms which might help in the diagnosis of COVID-19 patients. In this study, we aim to develop and validate a fast, inexpensive, reliable and easy-to-perform olfactory test for the screening of suspected COVID-19 patients. STUDY DESIGN: Phase I was a case–control study and Phase II a transversal descriptive study. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Olfaction was assessed with the ethyl alcohol threshold test and symptoms with visual analogue scales. The study was designed in two phases: In Phase I, we compared confirmed COVID-19 patients and healthy controls. In Phase II, patients with suspected COVID-19 infection referred for testing were studied. RESULTS: 275 participants were included in Phase I, 135 in Phase II. The ROC curve showed an AUC of 0.749 in Phase I, 0.737 in Phase II. The cutoff value which offered the highest amount of correctly classified patients was ≥ 2 (10% alcohol) for all age intervals. The odds ratio was 8.19 in Phase I, 6.56 in Phase II with a 75% sensitivity. When cases report normal sense of smell (VAS < 4), it misdiagnoses 57.89% of patients detected by the alcohol threshold test. CONCLUSION: The olfactory loss assessed with the alcohol threshold test has shown high sensitivity and odds ratio in both patients with confirmed COVID-19 illness and participants with suspected SARS-CoV-2 infection.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7312102
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Springer Berlin Heidelberg
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-73121022020-06-24 Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients Calvo-Henriquez, Christian Maldonado-Alvarado, Byron Chiesa-Estomba, Carlos Rivero-Fernández, Irene Sanz-Rodriguez, Marta Villarreal, Ithzel María Rodriguez-Iglesias, Miguel Mariño-Sánchez, Franklin Rivero-de-Aguilar, Alejandro Lechien, Jerome R. Martínez-Capoccioni, Gabriel Saussez, Sven Capasso, Robson Karkos, Petros D. Schriever, Valentin Martin-Martin, Carlos Alobid, Isam Santamaría-Gadea, Alfonso Fragola, Claudio Mayo-Yáñez, Miguel Pérez-Freixo, Hugo Ninchritz-Becerra, Elisabeth Soriano-Reixach, María Mondragon-Rezola, Elisabeth Ruiz-Coello, Maria del Mar Martínez Navarro, Raimundo Andrés García-Fernández, Alfredo Marchan-López, Álvaro Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol Rhinology OBJECTIVE: COVID-19 patients may present mild symptoms. The identification of paucisymptomatic patients is paramount in order to interrupt the transmission chain of the virus. Olfactory loss could be one of those early symptoms which might help in the diagnosis of COVID-19 patients. In this study, we aim to develop and validate a fast, inexpensive, reliable and easy-to-perform olfactory test for the screening of suspected COVID-19 patients. STUDY DESIGN: Phase I was a case–control study and Phase II a transversal descriptive study. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Olfaction was assessed with the ethyl alcohol threshold test and symptoms with visual analogue scales. The study was designed in two phases: In Phase I, we compared confirmed COVID-19 patients and healthy controls. In Phase II, patients with suspected COVID-19 infection referred for testing were studied. RESULTS: 275 participants were included in Phase I, 135 in Phase II. The ROC curve showed an AUC of 0.749 in Phase I, 0.737 in Phase II. The cutoff value which offered the highest amount of correctly classified patients was ≥ 2 (10% alcohol) for all age intervals. The odds ratio was 8.19 in Phase I, 6.56 in Phase II with a 75% sensitivity. When cases report normal sense of smell (VAS < 4), it misdiagnoses 57.89% of patients detected by the alcohol threshold test. CONCLUSION: The olfactory loss assessed with the alcohol threshold test has shown high sensitivity and odds ratio in both patients with confirmed COVID-19 illness and participants with suspected SARS-CoV-2 infection. Springer Berlin Heidelberg 2020-06-24 2020 /pmc/articles/PMC7312102/ /pubmed/32583183 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00405-020-06131-3 Text en © Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature 2020 This article is made available via the PMC Open Access Subset for unrestricted research re-use and secondary analysis in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for the duration of the World Health Organization (WHO) declaration of COVID-19 as a global pandemic.
spellingShingle Rhinology
Calvo-Henriquez, Christian
Maldonado-Alvarado, Byron
Chiesa-Estomba, Carlos
Rivero-Fernández, Irene
Sanz-Rodriguez, Marta
Villarreal, Ithzel María
Rodriguez-Iglesias, Miguel
Mariño-Sánchez, Franklin
Rivero-de-Aguilar, Alejandro
Lechien, Jerome R.
Martínez-Capoccioni, Gabriel
Saussez, Sven
Capasso, Robson
Karkos, Petros D.
Schriever, Valentin
Martin-Martin, Carlos
Alobid, Isam
Santamaría-Gadea, Alfonso
Fragola, Claudio
Mayo-Yáñez, Miguel
Pérez-Freixo, Hugo
Ninchritz-Becerra, Elisabeth
Soriano-Reixach, María
Mondragon-Rezola, Elisabeth
Ruiz-Coello, Maria del Mar Martínez
Navarro, Raimundo Andrés
García-Fernández, Alfredo
Marchan-López, Álvaro
Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title_full Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title_fullStr Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title_full_unstemmed Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title_short Ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory Assessment tool for COVID-19 patients
title_sort ethyl alcohol threshold test: a fast, reliable and affordable olfactory assessment tool for covid-19 patients
topic Rhinology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7312102/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32583183
http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00405-020-06131-3
work_keys_str_mv AT calvohenriquezchristian ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT maldonadoalvaradobyron ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT chiesaestombacarlos ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT riverofernandezirene ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT sanzrodriguezmarta ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT villarrealithzelmaria ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT rodrigueziglesiasmiguel ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT marinosanchezfranklin ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT riverodeaguilaralejandro ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT lechienjeromer ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT martinezcapoccionigabriel ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT saussezsven ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT capassorobson ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT karkospetrosd ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT schrievervalentin ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT martinmartincarlos ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT alobidisam ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT santamariagadeaalfonso ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT fragolaclaudio ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT mayoyanezmiguel ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT perezfreixohugo ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT ninchritzbecerraelisabeth ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT sorianoreixachmaria ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT mondragonrezolaelisabeth ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT ruizcoellomariadelmarmartinez ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT navarroraimundoandres ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT garciafernandezalfredo ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients
AT marchanlopezalvaro ethylalcoholthresholdtestafastreliableandaffordableolfactoryassessmenttoolforcovid19patients