Cargando…

Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study

BACKGROUND: Informal carers have a crucial role in the care of older people, but they are at risk of social isolation and psychological exhaustion. Web-based services like apps and websites are increasingly used to support informal carers in addressing some of their needs and tasks, such as health m...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Papa, Roberta, Efthymiou, Areti, Lamura, Giovanni, Piccinini, Flavia, Onorati, Giulia, Papastavrou, Evridiki, Tsitsi, Theologia, Casu, Giulia, Boccaletti, Licia, Manattini, Alessandra, Seneca, Rita, Vaz de Carvalho, Carlos, Durão, Rita, Barbabella, Francesco, Andréasson, Frida, Magnusson, Lennart, Hanson, Elizabeth
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JMIR Publications 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7330736/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32554378
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/14618
_version_ 1783553184062504960
author Papa, Roberta
Efthymiou, Areti
Lamura, Giovanni
Piccinini, Flavia
Onorati, Giulia
Papastavrou, Evridiki
Tsitsi, Theologia
Casu, Giulia
Boccaletti, Licia
Manattini, Alessandra
Seneca, Rita
Vaz de Carvalho, Carlos
Durão, Rita
Barbabella, Francesco
Andréasson, Frida
Magnusson, Lennart
Hanson, Elizabeth
author_facet Papa, Roberta
Efthymiou, Areti
Lamura, Giovanni
Piccinini, Flavia
Onorati, Giulia
Papastavrou, Evridiki
Tsitsi, Theologia
Casu, Giulia
Boccaletti, Licia
Manattini, Alessandra
Seneca, Rita
Vaz de Carvalho, Carlos
Durão, Rita
Barbabella, Francesco
Andréasson, Frida
Magnusson, Lennart
Hanson, Elizabeth
author_sort Papa, Roberta
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Informal carers have a crucial role in the care of older people, but they are at risk of social isolation and psychological exhaustion. Web-based services like apps and websites are increasingly used to support informal carers in addressing some of their needs and tasks, such as health monitoring of their loved ones, information and communication, and stress management. Despite the growing number of available solutions, the lack of knowledge or skills of carers about the solutions often prevent their usage. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to review and select apps and websites offering functionalities useful for informal carers of frail adults or older people in 5 European countries (Cyprus, Greece, Italy, Portugal, and Sweden). METHODS: A systematic online search was conducted from January 2017 to mid-March 2017 using selected keywords, followed by an assessment based on a set of commonly agreed criteria and standardized tools. Selected resources were rated and classified in terms of scope. Focus groups with informal carers were conducted to validate the list and the classification of resources. The activities were conducted in parallel in the participating countries using common protocols and guidelines, a standardization process, and scheduled group discussions. RESULTS: From a total of 406 eligible resources retrieved, 138 apps and 86 websites met the inclusion criteria. Half of the selected resources (109/224, 48.7%) were disease-specific, and the remaining resources included information and utilities on a variety of themes. Only 38 resources (38/224, 17.0%) were devoted specifically to carers, addressing the management of health disturbances and diseases of the care recipient and focusing primarily on neurodegenerative diseases. Focus groups with the carers showed that almost all participants had no previous knowledge of any resource specifically targeting carers, even if interest was expressed towards carer-focused resources. The main barriers for using the resources were low digital skills of the carers and reliability of health-related apps and websites. Results of the focus groups led to a new taxonomy of the resources, comprising 4 categories: carer’s wellbeing, managing health and diseases of the care recipient, useful contacts, and technologies for eldercare. CONCLUSIONS: The review process allowed the identification of online resources of good quality. However, these resources are still scarce due to a lack of reliability and usability that prevent users from properly benefiting from most of the resources. The involvement of end users provided added value to the resource classification and highlighted the gap between the potential benefits from using information and communication technologies and the real use of online resources by carers.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7330736
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher JMIR Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-73307362020-07-06 Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study Papa, Roberta Efthymiou, Areti Lamura, Giovanni Piccinini, Flavia Onorati, Giulia Papastavrou, Evridiki Tsitsi, Theologia Casu, Giulia Boccaletti, Licia Manattini, Alessandra Seneca, Rita Vaz de Carvalho, Carlos Durão, Rita Barbabella, Francesco Andréasson, Frida Magnusson, Lennart Hanson, Elizabeth JMIR Mhealth Uhealth Original Paper BACKGROUND: Informal carers have a crucial role in the care of older people, but they are at risk of social isolation and psychological exhaustion. Web-based services like apps and websites are increasingly used to support informal carers in addressing some of their needs and tasks, such as health monitoring of their loved ones, information and communication, and stress management. Despite the growing number of available solutions, the lack of knowledge or skills of carers about the solutions often prevent their usage. OBJECTIVE: This study aimed to review and select apps and websites offering functionalities useful for informal carers of frail adults or older people in 5 European countries (Cyprus, Greece, Italy, Portugal, and Sweden). METHODS: A systematic online search was conducted from January 2017 to mid-March 2017 using selected keywords, followed by an assessment based on a set of commonly agreed criteria and standardized tools. Selected resources were rated and classified in terms of scope. Focus groups with informal carers were conducted to validate the list and the classification of resources. The activities were conducted in parallel in the participating countries using common protocols and guidelines, a standardization process, and scheduled group discussions. RESULTS: From a total of 406 eligible resources retrieved, 138 apps and 86 websites met the inclusion criteria. Half of the selected resources (109/224, 48.7%) were disease-specific, and the remaining resources included information and utilities on a variety of themes. Only 38 resources (38/224, 17.0%) were devoted specifically to carers, addressing the management of health disturbances and diseases of the care recipient and focusing primarily on neurodegenerative diseases. Focus groups with the carers showed that almost all participants had no previous knowledge of any resource specifically targeting carers, even if interest was expressed towards carer-focused resources. The main barriers for using the resources were low digital skills of the carers and reliability of health-related apps and websites. Results of the focus groups led to a new taxonomy of the resources, comprising 4 categories: carer’s wellbeing, managing health and diseases of the care recipient, useful contacts, and technologies for eldercare. CONCLUSIONS: The review process allowed the identification of online resources of good quality. However, these resources are still scarce due to a lack of reliability and usability that prevent users from properly benefiting from most of the resources. The involvement of end users provided added value to the resource classification and highlighted the gap between the potential benefits from using information and communication technologies and the real use of online resources by carers. JMIR Publications 2020-06-17 /pmc/articles/PMC7330736/ /pubmed/32554378 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/14618 Text en ©Roberta Papa, Areti Efthymiou, Giovanni Lamura, Flavia Piccinini, Giulia Onorati, Evridiki Papastavrou, Theologia Tsitsi, Giulia Casu, Licia Boccaletti, Alessandra Manattini, Rita Seneca, Carlos Vaz de Carvalho, Rita Durão, Francesco Barbabella, Frida Andréasson, Lennart Magnusson, Elizabeth Hanson. Originally published in JMIR mHealth and uHealth (http://mhealth.jmir.org), 17.06.2020. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR mHealth and uHealth, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on http://mhealth.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included.
spellingShingle Original Paper
Papa, Roberta
Efthymiou, Areti
Lamura, Giovanni
Piccinini, Flavia
Onorati, Giulia
Papastavrou, Evridiki
Tsitsi, Theologia
Casu, Giulia
Boccaletti, Licia
Manattini, Alessandra
Seneca, Rita
Vaz de Carvalho, Carlos
Durão, Rita
Barbabella, Francesco
Andréasson, Frida
Magnusson, Lennart
Hanson, Elizabeth
Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title_full Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title_fullStr Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title_full_unstemmed Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title_short Review and Selection of Online Resources for Carers of Frail Adults or Older People in Five European Countries: Mixed-Methods Study
title_sort review and selection of online resources for carers of frail adults or older people in five european countries: mixed-methods study
topic Original Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7330736/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32554378
http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/14618
work_keys_str_mv AT paparoberta reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT efthymiouareti reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT lamuragiovanni reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT piccininiflavia reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT onoratigiulia reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT papastavrouevridiki reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT tsitsitheologia reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT casugiulia reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT boccalettilicia reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT manattinialessandra reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT senecarita reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT vazdecarvalhocarlos reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT duraorita reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT barbabellafrancesco reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT andreassonfrida reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT magnussonlennart reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy
AT hansonelizabeth reviewandselectionofonlineresourcesforcarersoffrailadultsorolderpeopleinfiveeuropeancountriesmixedmethodsstudy