Cargando…

A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Attacks by Iberian wolves on farm animals routinely cause conflicts with humans and threaten their economic interests related to livestock. However, wolf predation can sometimes be confused with that caused by other carnivores like dogs. Some studies have tried to identify or differe...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Toledo González, Víctor, Ortega Ojeda, Fernando, Fonseca, Gabriel M., García-Ruiz, Carmen, Navarro Cáceres, Pablo, Pérez-Lloret, Pilar, Marín García, María del Pilar
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7341320/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32503347
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060975
_version_ 1783555213362200576
author Toledo González, Víctor
Ortega Ojeda, Fernando
Fonseca, Gabriel M.
García-Ruiz, Carmen
Navarro Cáceres, Pablo
Pérez-Lloret, Pilar
Marín García, María del Pilar
author_facet Toledo González, Víctor
Ortega Ojeda, Fernando
Fonseca, Gabriel M.
García-Ruiz, Carmen
Navarro Cáceres, Pablo
Pérez-Lloret, Pilar
Marín García, María del Pilar
author_sort Toledo González, Víctor
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Attacks by Iberian wolves on farm animals routinely cause conflicts with humans and threaten their economic interests related to livestock. However, wolf predation can sometimes be confused with that caused by other carnivores like dogs. Some studies have tried to identify or differentiate canids as the predators responsible for such attacks by analysing their tooth/bite marks on bone remains. Nevertheless, most of those studies have only considered a few dental measurements, and they were carried out in a palaeoecological and zooarchaeological context. As there is still limited information on Iberian wolf‘s dental anatomy that can be used in forensic cases, this study aimed to describe the morphology of the Iberian wolf‘s teeth and to provide new morphometric characteristics, as complete as possible, to collaborate in the correct interpretation of a wolf‘s bite marks at crime scenes. Based on the morphometric dental analysis, it was possible to differentiate female and male wolves. Moreover, the dental morphometric characteristics described can be used, at least as a reference, to identify the Iberian wolf‘s tooth/bite marks or to rule out other potential aggressors. ABSTRACT: Depredation by the Iberian wolf (Canis lupus signatus) is currently thought to be a problem in some areas of Spain. However, there are few technically validated forensic tools available to determine the veracity of claims with a high degree of scientific confidence, which is important given that such attacks may lead to compensation. The analysis of bite marks on attacked animals could provide scientific evidence to help identify the offender. Thus, the aim of this study was to assess the morphological and morphometric characteristics of Iberian wolf dentition. This data collection would serve as a base-point for a more accurate identification of the wolves thorough their bite marks. For the first time, 36 dental variables have been studied in wolves’ skulls, employing univariate and multivariate analyses. The general morphological dental characteristics of wolves are very similar in terms of their dental formula and tooth structure to other canids, like domestic dogs. Sex differentiation was evident, principally in terms of the maxillary distance between the palatal surfaces of the canine teeth (UbC) and the width of the left mandibular canine teeth (LlCWd). New morphometric reference information was obtained that can aid the forensic identification of bite marks caused by the Iberian wolf with greater confidence.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7341320
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-73413202020-07-14 A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus) Toledo González, Víctor Ortega Ojeda, Fernando Fonseca, Gabriel M. García-Ruiz, Carmen Navarro Cáceres, Pablo Pérez-Lloret, Pilar Marín García, María del Pilar Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Attacks by Iberian wolves on farm animals routinely cause conflicts with humans and threaten their economic interests related to livestock. However, wolf predation can sometimes be confused with that caused by other carnivores like dogs. Some studies have tried to identify or differentiate canids as the predators responsible for such attacks by analysing their tooth/bite marks on bone remains. Nevertheless, most of those studies have only considered a few dental measurements, and they were carried out in a palaeoecological and zooarchaeological context. As there is still limited information on Iberian wolf‘s dental anatomy that can be used in forensic cases, this study aimed to describe the morphology of the Iberian wolf‘s teeth and to provide new morphometric characteristics, as complete as possible, to collaborate in the correct interpretation of a wolf‘s bite marks at crime scenes. Based on the morphometric dental analysis, it was possible to differentiate female and male wolves. Moreover, the dental morphometric characteristics described can be used, at least as a reference, to identify the Iberian wolf‘s tooth/bite marks or to rule out other potential aggressors. ABSTRACT: Depredation by the Iberian wolf (Canis lupus signatus) is currently thought to be a problem in some areas of Spain. However, there are few technically validated forensic tools available to determine the veracity of claims with a high degree of scientific confidence, which is important given that such attacks may lead to compensation. The analysis of bite marks on attacked animals could provide scientific evidence to help identify the offender. Thus, the aim of this study was to assess the morphological and morphometric characteristics of Iberian wolf dentition. This data collection would serve as a base-point for a more accurate identification of the wolves thorough their bite marks. For the first time, 36 dental variables have been studied in wolves’ skulls, employing univariate and multivariate analyses. The general morphological dental characteristics of wolves are very similar in terms of their dental formula and tooth structure to other canids, like domestic dogs. Sex differentiation was evident, principally in terms of the maxillary distance between the palatal surfaces of the canine teeth (UbC) and the width of the left mandibular canine teeth (LlCWd). New morphometric reference information was obtained that can aid the forensic identification of bite marks caused by the Iberian wolf with greater confidence. MDPI 2020-06-03 /pmc/articles/PMC7341320/ /pubmed/32503347 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060975 Text en © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Toledo González, Víctor
Ortega Ojeda, Fernando
Fonseca, Gabriel M.
García-Ruiz, Carmen
Navarro Cáceres, Pablo
Pérez-Lloret, Pilar
Marín García, María del Pilar
A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title_full A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title_fullStr A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title_full_unstemmed A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title_short A Morphological and Morphometric Dental Analysis as a Forensic Tool to Identify the Iberian Wolf (Canis Lupus Signatus)
title_sort morphological and morphometric dental analysis as a forensic tool to identify the iberian wolf (canis lupus signatus)
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7341320/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32503347
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060975
work_keys_str_mv AT toledogonzalezvictor amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT ortegaojedafernando amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT fonsecagabrielm amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT garciaruizcarmen amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT navarrocacerespablo amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT perezlloretpilar amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT maringarciamariadelpilar amorphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT toledogonzalezvictor morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT ortegaojedafernando morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT fonsecagabrielm morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT garciaruizcarmen morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT navarrocacerespablo morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT perezlloretpilar morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus
AT maringarciamariadelpilar morphologicalandmorphometricdentalanalysisasaforensictooltoidentifytheiberianwolfcanislupussignatus