Evaluation of the Electromyographic Amplitude-to-Work Ratio in the Infraspinatus Muscle During External Shoulder Rotation Exercises: A Comparison of Concentric Isotonic and Isokinetic Exercises

BACKGROUND: Isotonic exercise is commonly adopted for shoulder rehabilitation, but the efficacy of isokinetic exercise for rehabilitation has not been evaluated. PURPOSE: To evaluate the efficacy of isotonic and isokinetic external shoulder rotation exercises. STUDY DESIGN: Controlled laboratory study. METHODS: Using surface electromyography (EMG) and the Biodex system, we investigated the EMG amplitude of the infraspinatus (IS), total work (tWK), and EMG(IS)/tWK ratio and examined the relative IS and posterior deltoid (PD) contributions to all exercises. A total of 24 healthy participants without musculoskeletal injuries were included. Participants performed isotonic external shoulder rotation at 10%, 20%, 30%, 40%, and 50% of the maximum voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) as well as isokinetic external shoulder rotation at angular velocities of 60, 120, 180, 240, and 300 deg/s. Levels of intensity were classified from 1 to 5: level 1 corresponded to 10% of the MVIC and a 300-deg/s angular velocity; level 2 corresponded to 20% MVIC and 240 deg/s; level 3 corresponded to 30% MVIC and 180 deg/s; level 4 corresponded to 40% MVIC and 120 deg/s; and level 5 corresponded to 50% MVIC and 60 deg/s. Normalized IS and tWK amplitudes were calculated for each exercise. RESULTS: During isotonic exercise, the EMG(IS)/tWK ratio significantly decreased from level 5 to 3, 2, and 1; from level 4 to 2 and 1; and from level 3 to 1. During isokinetic exercise, the EMG(IS)/tWK ratio at level 3 was greater than that at all other levels except level 1. Statistical differences were found between isotonic and isokinetic modes at levels 1, 2, and 3. The IS/PD activation ratios were not significantly different between exercise modes at any level. CONCLUSION: Isokinetic resistance may provide more effective stimulation of the IS muscle compared with isotonic resistance. CLINICAL RELEVANCE: Isokinetic exercise needs to be considered as a method of rehabilitation that effectively increases infraspinatus muscle activity.