How to choose a point‐of‐care testing for troponin

BACKGROUND: Point‐of‐care (POC) cTn assays are needed when the central laboratory is unable to provide timely results to the emergency department. Many POC devices are available. The prospect of choosing them is daunting. In order to provide a quick decision‐making reference for POC cTn device selection comparing them to the central laboratory, seven POC devices commonly employed by emergency department were evaluated. METHODS: Firstly, we reviewed all devices package inserts. Secondly, we evaluated several POC cTn assays for imprecision, linearity, and correlation with central laboratory assays according to CLSI EP protocols. The linear regression analyses were performed only for the detectable concentrations. Five cTnI devices (Alere Triage, BioMerieux Vidas, Mitsubishi Pathfast, ReLIA TZ‐301, and Radiometer AQT90) were evaluated against a contemporary cTnI assay (Beckman Access II Accu TnI). Two cTnT assays (Radiometer AQT90 and Roche Cobas h232) were compared to a high‐sensitivity (hs) cTnT method (Roche Cobas e601). RESULTS: For cTn levels around the 99th percentile upper reference limits (URLs) of the comparator assays, imprecision could not be assessed for the Alere, BioMerieux, and Cobas h232 as they gave undetectable readings due to a lack of assay sensitivity. Imprecision (CV) was unacceptably high for the ReLIA (33.3%). On account of this precision metric, these four assays were deemed unsuitable. Regression analyses showed acceptable linearity for all the POC devices. The correlation coefficients for ReLIA, BioMerieux, Cobas h232, and Radiometer cTnT were >0.95. Unlike the cTnT devices, the cTnI assays employ different capture and detection antibodies leading to non‐commutable results. The POC cTn results were concordant with their comparator—Radiometer cTnT 90%, Pathfast cTnI 85%, and Radiometer cTnI 75%. CONCLUSION: Our study provides the procedure and essential data to guide selection of a POC cTn device. Of the point‐of‐care devices, methods evaluated Radiometer AQT90 (cTnI and cTnT) and Pathfast might be considered.