Visual rating versus volumetry of regional brain atrophy and longitudinal changes over a 5‐year period in an elderly population

INTRODUCTION: The purpose of our study was to compare visual rating and volumetry of brain atrophy in an elderly population over a 5‐year period and compare findings with cognitive test results. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Two hundred and one subjects were examined with magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) of the brain. Visual rating and volumetry were performed in all subjects at ages 75 and 80. Cognitive function at both time points was assessed with the Mini‐Mental State Examination (MMSE) and Trail Making Tests A and B (TMT‐A and TMT‐B). Changes in visual rating and volumetry were compared with changes in cognitive test. RESULTS: A correlation was found between visual rating of medial temporal lobe atrophy (MTA) and hippocampal volumetry at both time points (rs = −.42 and rs = −.49, p < .001, respectively). The correlation between visual rating of posterior atrophy (PA); frontal atrophy (F‐GCA) and volumetry of these brain regions was significant only at age 80 (rs = −.16, p = .02 for PA and rpb = .19, p = .006 for F‐GCA). Visual rating showed only a minimal progression of regional atrophy at age 80, whereas volumetry showed 2%–5% decrease in volume depending on brain region. Performance in the MMSE, TMT‐A, and TMT‐B was virtually unchanged between ages 75 and 80. CONCLUSION: We found a mild age‐associated decrease in regional brain volumes in this healthy cohort with well‐preserved cognitive functions. Visual assessment may not be sufficient for detecting mild progression of brain atrophy due to normal aging, whereas volumetry is more sensitive to capture these subtle changes.