Cargando…

Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate

National-level population size estimates (PSEs) for hidden populations are required for HIV programming and modelling. Various estimation methods are available at the site-level, but it remains unclear which are optimal and how best to obtain national-level estimates. SETTING: Zimbabwe. METHODS: Usi...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Fearon, Elizabeth, Chabata, Sungai T., Magutshwa, Sitholubuhle, Ndori-Mharadze, Tendayi, Musemburi, Sithembile, Chidawanyika, Henry, Masendeke, Absolom, Napierala, Sue, Gonese, Elizabeth, Herman Roloff, Amy, Tippett Barr, Beth A., Kilmarx, Peter H., Wong-Gruenwald, Ramona, Chidiya, Samson, Mhangara, Mutsa, Hanisch, Dagmar, Edwards, Jessie K., Rice, Brian, Taramusi, Isaac, Mbengeranwa, Tendai, Manangazira, Portia, Mugurungi, Owen, Hargreaves, James R., Cowan, Frances M.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7417013/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32379082
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/QAI.0000000000002393
_version_ 1783569404755181568
author Fearon, Elizabeth
Chabata, Sungai T.
Magutshwa, Sitholubuhle
Ndori-Mharadze, Tendayi
Musemburi, Sithembile
Chidawanyika, Henry
Masendeke, Absolom
Napierala, Sue
Gonese, Elizabeth
Herman Roloff, Amy
Tippett Barr, Beth A.
Kilmarx, Peter H.
Wong-Gruenwald, Ramona
Chidiya, Samson
Mhangara, Mutsa
Hanisch, Dagmar
Edwards, Jessie K.
Rice, Brian
Taramusi, Isaac
Mbengeranwa, Tendai
Manangazira, Portia
Mugurungi, Owen
Hargreaves, James R.
Cowan, Frances M.
author_facet Fearon, Elizabeth
Chabata, Sungai T.
Magutshwa, Sitholubuhle
Ndori-Mharadze, Tendayi
Musemburi, Sithembile
Chidawanyika, Henry
Masendeke, Absolom
Napierala, Sue
Gonese, Elizabeth
Herman Roloff, Amy
Tippett Barr, Beth A.
Kilmarx, Peter H.
Wong-Gruenwald, Ramona
Chidiya, Samson
Mhangara, Mutsa
Hanisch, Dagmar
Edwards, Jessie K.
Rice, Brian
Taramusi, Isaac
Mbengeranwa, Tendai
Manangazira, Portia
Mugurungi, Owen
Hargreaves, James R.
Cowan, Frances M.
author_sort Fearon, Elizabeth
collection PubMed
description National-level population size estimates (PSEs) for hidden populations are required for HIV programming and modelling. Various estimation methods are available at the site-level, but it remains unclear which are optimal and how best to obtain national-level estimates. SETTING: Zimbabwe. METHODS: Using 2015–2017 data from respondent-driven sampling (RDS) surveys among female sex workers (FSW) aged 18+ years, mappings, and program records, we calculated PSEs for each of the 20 sites across Zimbabwe, using up to 3 methods per site (service and unique object multipliers, census, and capture-recapture). We compared estimates from different methods, and calculated site medians. We estimated prevalence of sex work at each site using census data available on the number of 15–49-year-old women, generated a list of all “hotspot” sites for sex work nationally, and matched sites into strata in which the prevalence of sex work from sites with PSEs was applied to those without. Directly and indirectly estimated PSEs for all hotspot sites were summed to provide a national-level PSE, incorporating an adjustment accounting for sex work outside hotspots. RESULTS: Median site PSEs ranged from 12,863 in Harare to 247 in a rural growth-point. Multiplier methods produced the highest PSEs. We identified 55 hotspots estimated to include 95% of all FSW. FSW nationally were estimated to number 40,491, 1.23% of women aged 15–49 years, (plausibility bounds 28,177–58,797, 0.86–1.79%, those under 18 considered sexually exploited minors). CONCLUSION: There are large numbers of FSW estimated in Zimbabwe. Uncertainty in population size estimation should be reflected in policy-making.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7417013
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-74170132020-08-19 Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate Fearon, Elizabeth Chabata, Sungai T. Magutshwa, Sitholubuhle Ndori-Mharadze, Tendayi Musemburi, Sithembile Chidawanyika, Henry Masendeke, Absolom Napierala, Sue Gonese, Elizabeth Herman Roloff, Amy Tippett Barr, Beth A. Kilmarx, Peter H. Wong-Gruenwald, Ramona Chidiya, Samson Mhangara, Mutsa Hanisch, Dagmar Edwards, Jessie K. Rice, Brian Taramusi, Isaac Mbengeranwa, Tendai Manangazira, Portia Mugurungi, Owen Hargreaves, James R. Cowan, Frances M. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr Epidemiology National-level population size estimates (PSEs) for hidden populations are required for HIV programming and modelling. Various estimation methods are available at the site-level, but it remains unclear which are optimal and how best to obtain national-level estimates. SETTING: Zimbabwe. METHODS: Using 2015–2017 data from respondent-driven sampling (RDS) surveys among female sex workers (FSW) aged 18+ years, mappings, and program records, we calculated PSEs for each of the 20 sites across Zimbabwe, using up to 3 methods per site (service and unique object multipliers, census, and capture-recapture). We compared estimates from different methods, and calculated site medians. We estimated prevalence of sex work at each site using census data available on the number of 15–49-year-old women, generated a list of all “hotspot” sites for sex work nationally, and matched sites into strata in which the prevalence of sex work from sites with PSEs was applied to those without. Directly and indirectly estimated PSEs for all hotspot sites were summed to provide a national-level PSE, incorporating an adjustment accounting for sex work outside hotspots. RESULTS: Median site PSEs ranged from 12,863 in Harare to 247 in a rural growth-point. Multiplier methods produced the highest PSEs. We identified 55 hotspots estimated to include 95% of all FSW. FSW nationally were estimated to number 40,491, 1.23% of women aged 15–49 years, (plausibility bounds 28,177–58,797, 0.86–1.79%, those under 18 considered sexually exploited minors). CONCLUSION: There are large numbers of FSW estimated in Zimbabwe. Uncertainty in population size estimation should be reflected in policy-making. JAIDS Journal of Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndromes 2020-09-01 2020-05-05 /pmc/articles/PMC7417013/ /pubmed/32379082 http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/QAI.0000000000002393 Text en Copyright © 2020 The Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc. This is an open access article distributed under the Creative Commons Attribution License 4.0 (CCBY) (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Epidemiology
Fearon, Elizabeth
Chabata, Sungai T.
Magutshwa, Sitholubuhle
Ndori-Mharadze, Tendayi
Musemburi, Sithembile
Chidawanyika, Henry
Masendeke, Absolom
Napierala, Sue
Gonese, Elizabeth
Herman Roloff, Amy
Tippett Barr, Beth A.
Kilmarx, Peter H.
Wong-Gruenwald, Ramona
Chidiya, Samson
Mhangara, Mutsa
Hanisch, Dagmar
Edwards, Jessie K.
Rice, Brian
Taramusi, Isaac
Mbengeranwa, Tendai
Manangazira, Portia
Mugurungi, Owen
Hargreaves, James R.
Cowan, Frances M.
Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title_full Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title_fullStr Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title_full_unstemmed Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title_short Estimating the Population Size of Female Sex Workers in Zimbabwe: Comparison of Estimates Obtained Using Different Methods in Twenty Sites and Development of a National-Level Estimate
title_sort estimating the population size of female sex workers in zimbabwe: comparison of estimates obtained using different methods in twenty sites and development of a national-level estimate
topic Epidemiology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7417013/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32379082
http://dx.doi.org/10.1097/QAI.0000000000002393
work_keys_str_mv AT fearonelizabeth estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT chabatasungait estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT magutshwasitholubuhle estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT ndorimharadzetendayi estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT musemburisithembile estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT chidawanyikahenry estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT masendekeabsolom estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT napieralasue estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT goneseelizabeth estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT hermanroloffamy estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT tippettbarrbetha estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT kilmarxpeterh estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT wonggruenwaldramona estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT chidiyasamson estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT mhangaramutsa estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT hanischdagmar estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT edwardsjessiek estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT ricebrian estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT taramusiisaac estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT mbengeranwatendai estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT manangaziraportia estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT mugurungiowen estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT hargreavesjamesr estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate
AT cowanfrancesm estimatingthepopulationsizeoffemalesexworkersinzimbabwecomparisonofestimatesobtainedusingdifferentmethodsintwentysitesanddevelopmentofanationallevelestimate