Cargando…

Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer

PURPOSE: Multidimensional molecular analysis of tumor tissue intensively over space and time can provide insight into how cancers evolve and escape treatment. Attitudes of participants in such trials have not been assessed. We explored patient views regarding an intensive study incorporating multipl...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Kuderer, Nicole M., Burton, Kimberly A., Blau, Sibel, Senecal, Francis, Gadi, Vijayakrishna K., Parker, Stephanie, Mahen, Elisabeth, Veenstra, David, Carlson, Josh J., Lyman, Gary H., Blau, C. Anthony
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: American Society of Clinical Oncology 2017
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7446457/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32913975
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/PO.17.00076
_version_ 1783574148306436096
author Kuderer, Nicole M.
Burton, Kimberly A.
Blau, Sibel
Senecal, Francis
Gadi, Vijayakrishna K.
Parker, Stephanie
Mahen, Elisabeth
Veenstra, David
Carlson, Josh J.
Lyman, Gary H.
Blau, C. Anthony
author_facet Kuderer, Nicole M.
Burton, Kimberly A.
Blau, Sibel
Senecal, Francis
Gadi, Vijayakrishna K.
Parker, Stephanie
Mahen, Elisabeth
Veenstra, David
Carlson, Josh J.
Lyman, Gary H.
Blau, C. Anthony
author_sort Kuderer, Nicole M.
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: Multidimensional molecular analysis of tumor tissue intensively over space and time can provide insight into how cancers evolve and escape treatment. Attitudes of participants in such trials have not been assessed. We explored patient views regarding an intensive study incorporating multiple biopsies, multidimensional molecular testing, and drug response predictions that are reported to the oncologist and patient. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A structured, self-administered survey was conducted among the first 15 patients enrolled in ITOMIC-001 (Intensive Trial of Omics in Cancer). Patients with metastatic triple-negative breast cancer were accrued at two sites in Washington state. Surveys containing 17 items were administered at enrollment and after the return of results. Surveys explored perceptions regarding risks, personal benefits, benefits to others, uncertainties associated with interpreting complex molecular results, concerns regarding multiple biopsies, and potential loss of confidentiality. At follow-up, three additional unique items explored patient coping. RESULTS: All participants expressed a strong desire for their experiences to benefit others, and all perceived a higher likelihood of deriving benefit than described during detailed consent discussions. Loss of confidentiality ranked lowest among patient concerns. Despite acknowledging uncertainties and risks inherent in complex molecular testing for clinical reporting, participants wanted access to findings in evaluating treatment choices, even if the best available evidence was weak. Follow-up surveys demonstrated relatively little change in attitudes, although concern about study biopsies generally declined. Study participation helped several patients cope better with their disease. CONCLUSION: In advanced breast cancer, these findings demonstrate the feasibility of engaging motivated patients in trials that navigate the uncertainties associated with intensive spatial and longitudinal multidimensional molecular testing for the purpose of advancing precision medicine.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7446457
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2017
publisher American Society of Clinical Oncology
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-74464572020-09-09 Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer Kuderer, Nicole M. Burton, Kimberly A. Blau, Sibel Senecal, Francis Gadi, Vijayakrishna K. Parker, Stephanie Mahen, Elisabeth Veenstra, David Carlson, Josh J. Lyman, Gary H. Blau, C. Anthony JCO Precis Oncol Original Reports PURPOSE: Multidimensional molecular analysis of tumor tissue intensively over space and time can provide insight into how cancers evolve and escape treatment. Attitudes of participants in such trials have not been assessed. We explored patient views regarding an intensive study incorporating multiple biopsies, multidimensional molecular testing, and drug response predictions that are reported to the oncologist and patient. PATIENTS AND METHODS: A structured, self-administered survey was conducted among the first 15 patients enrolled in ITOMIC-001 (Intensive Trial of Omics in Cancer). Patients with metastatic triple-negative breast cancer were accrued at two sites in Washington state. Surveys containing 17 items were administered at enrollment and after the return of results. Surveys explored perceptions regarding risks, personal benefits, benefits to others, uncertainties associated with interpreting complex molecular results, concerns regarding multiple biopsies, and potential loss of confidentiality. At follow-up, three additional unique items explored patient coping. RESULTS: All participants expressed a strong desire for their experiences to benefit others, and all perceived a higher likelihood of deriving benefit than described during detailed consent discussions. Loss of confidentiality ranked lowest among patient concerns. Despite acknowledging uncertainties and risks inherent in complex molecular testing for clinical reporting, participants wanted access to findings in evaluating treatment choices, even if the best available evidence was weak. Follow-up surveys demonstrated relatively little change in attitudes, although concern about study biopsies generally declined. Study participation helped several patients cope better with their disease. CONCLUSION: In advanced breast cancer, these findings demonstrate the feasibility of engaging motivated patients in trials that navigate the uncertainties associated with intensive spatial and longitudinal multidimensional molecular testing for the purpose of advancing precision medicine. American Society of Clinical Oncology 2017-08-16 /pmc/articles/PMC7446457/ /pubmed/32913975 http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/PO.17.00076 Text en © 2017 by American Society of Clinical Oncology http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ Licensed under the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License: http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
spellingShingle Original Reports
Kuderer, Nicole M.
Burton, Kimberly A.
Blau, Sibel
Senecal, Francis
Gadi, Vijayakrishna K.
Parker, Stephanie
Mahen, Elisabeth
Veenstra, David
Carlson, Josh J.
Lyman, Gary H.
Blau, C. Anthony
Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title_full Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title_fullStr Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title_full_unstemmed Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title_short Participant Attitudes Toward an Intensive Trial of Multiple Biopsies, Multidimensional Molecular Analysis, and Reporting of Results in Metastatic Triple-Negative Breast Cancer
title_sort participant attitudes toward an intensive trial of multiple biopsies, multidimensional molecular analysis, and reporting of results in metastatic triple-negative breast cancer
topic Original Reports
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7446457/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32913975
http://dx.doi.org/10.1200/PO.17.00076
work_keys_str_mv AT kuderernicolem participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT burtonkimberlya participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT blausibel participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT senecalfrancis participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT gadivijayakrishnak participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT parkerstephanie participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT mahenelisabeth participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT veenstradavid participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT carlsonjoshj participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT lymangaryh participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer
AT blaucanthony participantattitudestowardanintensivetrialofmultiplebiopsiesmultidimensionalmolecularanalysisandreportingofresultsinmetastatictriplenegativebreastcancer