Cargando…

The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements

BACKGROUND: Stringent complete response (sCR) is used as a deeper response category than complete response (CR) in multiple myeloma (MM) but may be of limited value in the era of minimal residual disease (MRD) testing. METHODS: Here, we used 4-colour multiparametric flow cytometry (MFC) or next-gene...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Cedena, Maria-Teresa, Martin-Clavero, Estela, Wong, Sandy, Shah, Nina, Bahri, Natasha, Alonso, Rafael, Barcenas, Carmen, Valeri, Antonio, Salazar Tabares, Johny, Sanchez-Pina, Jose, Cuellar, Clara, Martin, Thomas, Wolf, Jeffrey, Lahuerta, Juan-Jose, Martinez-Lopez, Joaquin
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7458342/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32866200
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237155
_version_ 1783576177471913984
author Cedena, Maria-Teresa
Martin-Clavero, Estela
Wong, Sandy
Shah, Nina
Bahri, Natasha
Alonso, Rafael
Barcenas, Carmen
Valeri, Antonio
Salazar Tabares, Johny
Sanchez-Pina, Jose
Cuellar, Clara
Martin, Thomas
Wolf, Jeffrey
Lahuerta, Juan-Jose
Martinez-Lopez, Joaquin
author_facet Cedena, Maria-Teresa
Martin-Clavero, Estela
Wong, Sandy
Shah, Nina
Bahri, Natasha
Alonso, Rafael
Barcenas, Carmen
Valeri, Antonio
Salazar Tabares, Johny
Sanchez-Pina, Jose
Cuellar, Clara
Martin, Thomas
Wolf, Jeffrey
Lahuerta, Juan-Jose
Martinez-Lopez, Joaquin
author_sort Cedena, Maria-Teresa
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Stringent complete response (sCR) is used as a deeper response category than complete response (CR) in multiple myeloma (MM) but may be of limited value in the era of minimal residual disease (MRD) testing. METHODS: Here, we used 4-colour multiparametric flow cytometry (MFC) or next-generation sequencing (NGS) of immunoglobulin genes to analyse and compare the prognostic impact of sCR and MRD monitoring. We included 193 treated patients in two institutions achieving CR, for which both bone marrow aspirates and biopsies were available. RESULTS: We found that neither the serum free light chain ratio, clonality by immunohistochemistry (IHC) nor plasma cell bone marrow infiltration identified CR patients at distinct risk. Patients with sCR had slightly longer progression-free survival. Nevertheless, persistent clonal bone marrow disease was detectable using MFC or NGS and was associated with significantly inferior outcomes compared with MRD-negative cases. CONCLUSION: Our results confirm that sCR does not predict a different outcome and indicate that more sensitive techniques are able to identify patients with differing prognoses. We suggest that MRD categories should be implemented over sCR for the future classification of MM responses.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7458342
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-74583422020-09-04 The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements Cedena, Maria-Teresa Martin-Clavero, Estela Wong, Sandy Shah, Nina Bahri, Natasha Alonso, Rafael Barcenas, Carmen Valeri, Antonio Salazar Tabares, Johny Sanchez-Pina, Jose Cuellar, Clara Martin, Thomas Wolf, Jeffrey Lahuerta, Juan-Jose Martinez-Lopez, Joaquin PLoS One Research Article BACKGROUND: Stringent complete response (sCR) is used as a deeper response category than complete response (CR) in multiple myeloma (MM) but may be of limited value in the era of minimal residual disease (MRD) testing. METHODS: Here, we used 4-colour multiparametric flow cytometry (MFC) or next-generation sequencing (NGS) of immunoglobulin genes to analyse and compare the prognostic impact of sCR and MRD monitoring. We included 193 treated patients in two institutions achieving CR, for which both bone marrow aspirates and biopsies were available. RESULTS: We found that neither the serum free light chain ratio, clonality by immunohistochemistry (IHC) nor plasma cell bone marrow infiltration identified CR patients at distinct risk. Patients with sCR had slightly longer progression-free survival. Nevertheless, persistent clonal bone marrow disease was detectable using MFC or NGS and was associated with significantly inferior outcomes compared with MRD-negative cases. CONCLUSION: Our results confirm that sCR does not predict a different outcome and indicate that more sensitive techniques are able to identify patients with differing prognoses. We suggest that MRD categories should be implemented over sCR for the future classification of MM responses. Public Library of Science 2020-08-31 /pmc/articles/PMC7458342/ /pubmed/32866200 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237155 Text en © 2020 Cedena et al http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Cedena, Maria-Teresa
Martin-Clavero, Estela
Wong, Sandy
Shah, Nina
Bahri, Natasha
Alonso, Rafael
Barcenas, Carmen
Valeri, Antonio
Salazar Tabares, Johny
Sanchez-Pina, Jose
Cuellar, Clara
Martin, Thomas
Wolf, Jeffrey
Lahuerta, Juan-Jose
Martinez-Lopez, Joaquin
The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title_full The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title_fullStr The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title_full_unstemmed The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title_short The clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
title_sort clinical significance of stringent complete response in multiple myeloma is surpassed by minimal residual disease measurements
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7458342/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32866200
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0237155
work_keys_str_mv AT cedenamariateresa theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinclaveroestela theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT wongsandy theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT shahnina theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT bahrinatasha theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT alonsorafael theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT barcenascarmen theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT valeriantonio theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT salazartabaresjohny theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT sanchezpinajose theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT cuellarclara theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinthomas theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT wolfjeffrey theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT lahuertajuanjose theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinezlopezjoaquin theclinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT cedenamariateresa clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinclaveroestela clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT wongsandy clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT shahnina clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT bahrinatasha clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT alonsorafael clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT barcenascarmen clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT valeriantonio clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT salazartabaresjohny clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT sanchezpinajose clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT cuellarclara clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinthomas clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT wolfjeffrey clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT lahuertajuanjose clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements
AT martinezlopezjoaquin clinicalsignificanceofstringentcompleteresponseinmultiplemyelomaissurpassedbyminimalresidualdiseasemeasurements