Cargando…

Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.

BACKGROUND: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is currently the main public health problem worldwide. The administration of neutral electrolyzed saline, a solution that contains reactive species of chlorine and oxygen (ROS), may be an effective therapeutic alternative due to its immunomodulating charact...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Delgado-Enciso, Ivan, Paz-Garcia, Juan, Barajas-Saucedo, Carlos E, Mokay-Ramírez, Karen A, Meza-Robles, Carmen, Lopez-Flores, Rodrigo, Delgado-Machuca, Marina, Murillo-Zamora, Efren, Toscano-Velazquez, Jose A., Delgado-Enciso, Josuel, Melnikov, Valery, Walle-Guillen, Mireya, Galvan-Salazar, Hector R., Delgado-Enciso, Osiris G., Cabrera-Licona, Ariana, Guzman-Esquivel, José, Montes-Galindo, Daniel A., Hemandez-Rangel, Alejandra E., Montes-Diaz, Patricia, Rodriguez-Sanchez, Iram P, Martinez-Fierro, Margarita L, Garza-Veloz, Idalia, Tiburcio-Jimenez, Daniel, Zaizar-Fregoso, Sergio A, Ramirez-Flores, Mario, Gaytan-Sandoval, Gustavo, Martinez-Perez, Carlos R., Espinoza-Gómez, Francisco, Rojas-Larios, Fabián, Hirsch-Meillon, Michael J., Barrios-Navarro, Enrique, Oviedo-Rodriguez, Vladimir, Baltazar Rodriguez, Luz M., Paz-Michel, Brenda A.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: American Journal Experts 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7491578/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32935090
http://dx.doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-68403/v1
_version_ 1783582244999266304
author Delgado-Enciso, Ivan
Paz-Garcia, Juan
Barajas-Saucedo, Carlos E
Mokay-Ramírez, Karen A
Meza-Robles, Carmen
Lopez-Flores, Rodrigo
Delgado-Machuca, Marina
Murillo-Zamora, Efren
Toscano-Velazquez, Jose A.
Delgado-Enciso, Josuel
Melnikov, Valery
Walle-Guillen, Mireya
Galvan-Salazar, Hector R.
Delgado-Enciso, Osiris G.
Cabrera-Licona, Ariana
Guzman-Esquivel, José
Montes-Galindo, Daniel A.
Hemandez-Rangel, Alejandra E.
Montes-Diaz, Patricia
Rodriguez-Sanchez, Iram P
Martinez-Fierro, Margarita L
Garza-Veloz, Idalia
Tiburcio-Jimenez, Daniel
Zaizar-Fregoso, Sergio A
Ramirez-Flores, Mario
Gaytan-Sandoval, Gustavo
Martinez-Perez, Carlos R.
Espinoza-Gómez, Francisco
Rojas-Larios, Fabián
Hirsch-Meillon, Michael J.
Barrios-Navarro, Enrique
Oviedo-Rodriguez, Vladimir
Baltazar Rodriguez, Luz M.
Paz-Michel, Brenda A.
author_facet Delgado-Enciso, Ivan
Paz-Garcia, Juan
Barajas-Saucedo, Carlos E
Mokay-Ramírez, Karen A
Meza-Robles, Carmen
Lopez-Flores, Rodrigo
Delgado-Machuca, Marina
Murillo-Zamora, Efren
Toscano-Velazquez, Jose A.
Delgado-Enciso, Josuel
Melnikov, Valery
Walle-Guillen, Mireya
Galvan-Salazar, Hector R.
Delgado-Enciso, Osiris G.
Cabrera-Licona, Ariana
Guzman-Esquivel, José
Montes-Galindo, Daniel A.
Hemandez-Rangel, Alejandra E.
Montes-Diaz, Patricia
Rodriguez-Sanchez, Iram P
Martinez-Fierro, Margarita L
Garza-Veloz, Idalia
Tiburcio-Jimenez, Daniel
Zaizar-Fregoso, Sergio A
Ramirez-Flores, Mario
Gaytan-Sandoval, Gustavo
Martinez-Perez, Carlos R.
Espinoza-Gómez, Francisco
Rojas-Larios, Fabián
Hirsch-Meillon, Michael J.
Barrios-Navarro, Enrique
Oviedo-Rodriguez, Vladimir
Baltazar Rodriguez, Luz M.
Paz-Michel, Brenda A.
author_sort Delgado-Enciso, Ivan
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is currently the main public health problem worldwide. The administration of neutral electrolyzed saline, a solution that contains reactive species of chlorine and oxygen (ROS), may be an effective therapeutic alternative due to its immunomodulating characteristics, in systemic inflammation control, as well as in immune response improvement, promoting control of the viral infection. The present study evaluated the efficacy of treatment with intravenous and/or nebulized neutral electrolyzed saline combined with usual medical care versus usual medical care alone, in ambulatory patients with COVID-19. METHODS: A prospective, 2-arm, parallel group, randomized, open-label, phase I-II clinical trial included 39 patients in the control group (usual medical care alone) and 45 patients in the experimental group (usual medical care + intravenous and/or nebulized electrolyzed saline, with dose escalation). Two aspects were evaluated during the twenty-day follow-up: i) the number of patients with disease progression (hospitalization or death); and ii) the Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PASS), a single-question outcome that determines patient well-being thresholds for pain and function. Biochemical and hematologic parameters, as well as adverse effects, were evaluated in the experimental group. RESULTS: The experimental treatment decreased the risk for hospitalization by 92% (adjusted RR=0.08, 95% CI: 0.01–0.50, P=0.007), with a 43-fold increase in the probability of achieving an acceptable symptom state on day 5 (adjusted RR= 42.96, 95% CI: 9.22–200.0, P<0.001). Intravenous + nebulized administration was better than nebulized administration alone, but nebulized administration was better than usual medical care alone. Clinical improvement correlated with a decrease in C-reactive protein, and aberrant monocytes and an increase of lymphocytes, and platelets. Cortisol and testosterone levels were also evaluated, observing a decrease in cortisol levels and an increment of testosterone-cortisol ratio, on days 2 and 4. CONCLUSIONS: The experimental treatment produced no serious adverse effects. In conclusion, intravenous and/or nebulized neutral electrolyzed saline importantly reduced the symptomatology and risk of progression (hospitalization and death), in ambulatory patients with COVID-19. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Cuban Public Registry of Clinical Trials (RPCEC) Database RPCEC00000309. Registered: 05. May 2020. https://rpcec.sld.cu/en/trials/RPCEC00000309-En
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7491578
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher American Journal Experts
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-74915782020-09-16 Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial. Delgado-Enciso, Ivan Paz-Garcia, Juan Barajas-Saucedo, Carlos E Mokay-Ramírez, Karen A Meza-Robles, Carmen Lopez-Flores, Rodrigo Delgado-Machuca, Marina Murillo-Zamora, Efren Toscano-Velazquez, Jose A. Delgado-Enciso, Josuel Melnikov, Valery Walle-Guillen, Mireya Galvan-Salazar, Hector R. Delgado-Enciso, Osiris G. Cabrera-Licona, Ariana Guzman-Esquivel, José Montes-Galindo, Daniel A. Hemandez-Rangel, Alejandra E. Montes-Diaz, Patricia Rodriguez-Sanchez, Iram P Martinez-Fierro, Margarita L Garza-Veloz, Idalia Tiburcio-Jimenez, Daniel Zaizar-Fregoso, Sergio A Ramirez-Flores, Mario Gaytan-Sandoval, Gustavo Martinez-Perez, Carlos R. Espinoza-Gómez, Francisco Rojas-Larios, Fabián Hirsch-Meillon, Michael J. Barrios-Navarro, Enrique Oviedo-Rodriguez, Vladimir Baltazar Rodriguez, Luz M. Paz-Michel, Brenda A. Res Sq Article BACKGROUND: Coronavirus disease (COVID-19) is currently the main public health problem worldwide. The administration of neutral electrolyzed saline, a solution that contains reactive species of chlorine and oxygen (ROS), may be an effective therapeutic alternative due to its immunomodulating characteristics, in systemic inflammation control, as well as in immune response improvement, promoting control of the viral infection. The present study evaluated the efficacy of treatment with intravenous and/or nebulized neutral electrolyzed saline combined with usual medical care versus usual medical care alone, in ambulatory patients with COVID-19. METHODS: A prospective, 2-arm, parallel group, randomized, open-label, phase I-II clinical trial included 39 patients in the control group (usual medical care alone) and 45 patients in the experimental group (usual medical care + intravenous and/or nebulized electrolyzed saline, with dose escalation). Two aspects were evaluated during the twenty-day follow-up: i) the number of patients with disease progression (hospitalization or death); and ii) the Patient Acceptable Symptom State (PASS), a single-question outcome that determines patient well-being thresholds for pain and function. Biochemical and hematologic parameters, as well as adverse effects, were evaluated in the experimental group. RESULTS: The experimental treatment decreased the risk for hospitalization by 92% (adjusted RR=0.08, 95% CI: 0.01–0.50, P=0.007), with a 43-fold increase in the probability of achieving an acceptable symptom state on day 5 (adjusted RR= 42.96, 95% CI: 9.22–200.0, P<0.001). Intravenous + nebulized administration was better than nebulized administration alone, but nebulized administration was better than usual medical care alone. Clinical improvement correlated with a decrease in C-reactive protein, and aberrant monocytes and an increase of lymphocytes, and platelets. Cortisol and testosterone levels were also evaluated, observing a decrease in cortisol levels and an increment of testosterone-cortisol ratio, on days 2 and 4. CONCLUSIONS: The experimental treatment produced no serious adverse effects. In conclusion, intravenous and/or nebulized neutral electrolyzed saline importantly reduced the symptomatology and risk of progression (hospitalization and death), in ambulatory patients with COVID-19. TRIAL REGISTRATION: Cuban Public Registry of Clinical Trials (RPCEC) Database RPCEC00000309. Registered: 05. May 2020. https://rpcec.sld.cu/en/trials/RPCEC00000309-En American Journal Experts 2020-09-10 /pmc/articles/PMC7491578/ /pubmed/32935090 http://dx.doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-68403/v1 Text en https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which allows reusers to distribute, remix, adapt, and build upon the material in any medium or format, so long as attribution is given to the creator. The license allows for commercial use.
spellingShingle Article
Delgado-Enciso, Ivan
Paz-Garcia, Juan
Barajas-Saucedo, Carlos E
Mokay-Ramírez, Karen A
Meza-Robles, Carmen
Lopez-Flores, Rodrigo
Delgado-Machuca, Marina
Murillo-Zamora, Efren
Toscano-Velazquez, Jose A.
Delgado-Enciso, Josuel
Melnikov, Valery
Walle-Guillen, Mireya
Galvan-Salazar, Hector R.
Delgado-Enciso, Osiris G.
Cabrera-Licona, Ariana
Guzman-Esquivel, José
Montes-Galindo, Daniel A.
Hemandez-Rangel, Alejandra E.
Montes-Diaz, Patricia
Rodriguez-Sanchez, Iram P
Martinez-Fierro, Margarita L
Garza-Veloz, Idalia
Tiburcio-Jimenez, Daniel
Zaizar-Fregoso, Sergio A
Ramirez-Flores, Mario
Gaytan-Sandoval, Gustavo
Martinez-Perez, Carlos R.
Espinoza-Gómez, Francisco
Rojas-Larios, Fabián
Hirsch-Meillon, Michael J.
Barrios-Navarro, Enrique
Oviedo-Rodriguez, Vladimir
Baltazar Rodriguez, Luz M.
Paz-Michel, Brenda A.
Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title_full Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title_fullStr Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title_full_unstemmed Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title_short Patient-Reported Health Outcomes After Treatment of COVID-19 with Nebulized and/or Intravenous Neutral Electrolyzed Saline Combined with Usual Medical Care Versus Usual Medical care alone: A Randomized, Open-Label, Controlled Trial.
title_sort patient-reported health outcomes after treatment of covid-19 with nebulized and/or intravenous neutral electrolyzed saline combined with usual medical care versus usual medical care alone: a randomized, open-label, controlled trial.
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7491578/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32935090
http://dx.doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-68403/v1
work_keys_str_mv AT delgadoencisoivan patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT pazgarciajuan patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT barajassaucedocarlose patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT mokayramirezkarena patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT mezaroblescarmen patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT lopezfloresrodrigo patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT delgadomachucamarina patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT murillozamoraefren patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT toscanovelazquezjosea patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT delgadoencisojosuel patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT melnikovvalery patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT walleguillenmireya patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT galvansalazarhectorr patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT delgadoencisoosirisg patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT cabreraliconaariana patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT guzmanesquiveljose patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT montesgalindodaniela patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT hemandezrangelalejandrae patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT montesdiazpatricia patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT rodriguezsancheziramp patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT martinezfierromargarital patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT garzavelozidalia patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT tiburciojimenezdaniel patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT zaizarfregososergioa patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT ramirezfloresmario patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT gaytansandovalgustavo patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT martinezperezcarlosr patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT espinozagomezfrancisco patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT rojaslariosfabian patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT hirschmeillonmichaelj patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT barriosnavarroenrique patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT oviedorodriguezvladimir patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT baltazarrodriguezluzm patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial
AT pazmichelbrendaa patientreportedhealthoutcomesaftertreatmentofcovid19withnebulizedandorintravenousneutralelectrolyzedsalinecombinedwithusualmedicalcareversususualmedicalcarealonearandomizedopenlabelcontrolledtrial