Cargando…

Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results

BACKGROUND: The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted global healthcare systems and this may affect stroke care and outcomes. This study examines the changes in stroke epidemiology and care during the COVID-19 pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. METHODS: This study is part of...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Ghoreishi, Abdoreza, Arsang-Jang, Shahram, Sabaa-Ayoun, Ziad, Yassi, Nawaf, Sylaja, P.N., Akbari, Yama, Divani, Afshin A., Biller, Jose, Phan, Thanh, Steinwender, Sandy, Silver, Brian, Zand, Ramin, Basri, Hamidon Bin, Iqbal, Omer M., Ranta, Annemarei, Ruland, Sean, Macri, Elizabeth, Ma, Henry, Nguyen, Thanh N., Abootalebi, Shahram, Gupta, Animesh, Alet, Matias, Lattanzi, Simona, Desai, Masoom, Gagliardi, Rubens J., Girotra, Tarun, Inoue, Manabu, Yoshimoto, Takeshi, Isaac, Cristian Flavo, Mayer, Stephan A., Morovatdar, Negar, Nilanont, Yongchai, Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S., Saber, Hamidreza, Kamenova, Saltanat, Kondybayeva, Aida, Krupinski, Jerzy, Siegler, James E., Stranges, Saverio, Torbey, Michel T., Yorio, Diana, Zurrú, María Cristina, Rubinos, Clio Aracelli, Shahripour, Reza Bavarsad, Borhani-Haghighi, Afshin, Napoli, Mario Di, Azarpazhooh, M. Reza
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Elsevier Inc. 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7494258/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33069086
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105321
_version_ 1783582710832300032
author Ghoreishi, Abdoreza
Arsang-Jang, Shahram
Sabaa-Ayoun, Ziad
Yassi, Nawaf
Sylaja, P.N.
Akbari, Yama
Divani, Afshin A.
Biller, Jose
Phan, Thanh
Steinwender, Sandy
Silver, Brian
Zand, Ramin
Basri, Hamidon Bin
Iqbal, Omer M.
Ranta, Annemarei
Ruland, Sean
Macri, Elizabeth
Ma, Henry
Nguyen, Thanh N.
Abootalebi, Shahram
Gupta, Animesh
Alet, Matias
Lattanzi, Simona
Desai, Masoom
Gagliardi, Rubens J.
Girotra, Tarun
Inoue, Manabu
Yoshimoto, Takeshi
Isaac, Cristian Flavo
Mayer, Stephan A.
Morovatdar, Negar
Nilanont, Yongchai
Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S.
Saber, Hamidreza
Kamenova, Saltanat
Kondybayeva, Aida
Krupinski, Jerzy
Siegler, James E.
Stranges, Saverio
Torbey, Michel T.
Yorio, Diana
Zurrú, María Cristina
Rubinos, Clio Aracelli
Shahripour, Reza Bavarsad
Borhani-Haghighi, Afshin
Napoli, Mario Di
Azarpazhooh, M. Reza
author_facet Ghoreishi, Abdoreza
Arsang-Jang, Shahram
Sabaa-Ayoun, Ziad
Yassi, Nawaf
Sylaja, P.N.
Akbari, Yama
Divani, Afshin A.
Biller, Jose
Phan, Thanh
Steinwender, Sandy
Silver, Brian
Zand, Ramin
Basri, Hamidon Bin
Iqbal, Omer M.
Ranta, Annemarei
Ruland, Sean
Macri, Elizabeth
Ma, Henry
Nguyen, Thanh N.
Abootalebi, Shahram
Gupta, Animesh
Alet, Matias
Lattanzi, Simona
Desai, Masoom
Gagliardi, Rubens J.
Girotra, Tarun
Inoue, Manabu
Yoshimoto, Takeshi
Isaac, Cristian Flavo
Mayer, Stephan A.
Morovatdar, Negar
Nilanont, Yongchai
Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S.
Saber, Hamidreza
Kamenova, Saltanat
Kondybayeva, Aida
Krupinski, Jerzy
Siegler, James E.
Stranges, Saverio
Torbey, Michel T.
Yorio, Diana
Zurrú, María Cristina
Rubinos, Clio Aracelli
Shahripour, Reza Bavarsad
Borhani-Haghighi, Afshin
Napoli, Mario Di
Azarpazhooh, M. Reza
author_sort Ghoreishi, Abdoreza
collection PubMed
description BACKGROUND: The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted global healthcare systems and this may affect stroke care and outcomes. This study examines the changes in stroke epidemiology and care during the COVID-19 pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. METHODS: This study is part of the CASCADE international initiative. From February 18, 2019, to July 18, 2020, we followed ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke hospitalization rates and outcomes in Valiasr Hospital, Zanjan, Iran. We used a Bayesian hierarchical model and an interrupted time series analysis (ITS) to identify changes in stroke hospitalization rate, baseline stroke severity [measured by the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS)], disability [measured by the modified Rankin Scale (mRS)], presentation time (last seen normal to hospital presentation), thrombolytic therapy rate, median door-to-needle time, length of hospital stay, and in-hospital mortality. We compared in-hospital mortality between study periods using Cox-regression model. RESULTS: During the study period, 1,026 stroke patients were hospitalized. Stroke hospitalization rates per 100,000 population decreased from 68.09 before the pandemic to 44.50 during the pandemic, with a significant decline in both Bayesian [Beta: -1.034; Standard Error (SE): 0.22, 95% CrI: -1.48, -0.59] and ITS analysis (estimate: -1.03, SE = 0.24, p < 0.0001). Furthermore, we observed lower admission rates for patients with mild (NIHSS < 5) ischemic stroke (p < 0.0001). Although, the presentation time and door-to-needle time did not change during the pandemic, a lower proportion of patients received thrombolysis (-10.1%; p = 0.004). We did not see significant changes in admission rate to the stroke unit and in-hospital mortality rate; however, disability at discharge increased (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: In Zanjan, Iran, the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted stroke outcomes and altered the delivery of stroke care. Observed lower admission rates for milder stroke may possibly be due to fear of exposure related to COVID-19. The decrease in patients treated with thrombolysis and the increased disability at discharge may indicate changes in the delivery of stroke care and increased pressure on existing stroke acute and subacute services. The results of this research will contribute to a similar analysis of the larger CASCADE dataset in order to confirm findings at a global scale and improve measures to ensure the best quality of care for stroke patients during the COVID-19 pandemic.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7494258
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher Elsevier Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-74942582020-09-17 Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results Ghoreishi, Abdoreza Arsang-Jang, Shahram Sabaa-Ayoun, Ziad Yassi, Nawaf Sylaja, P.N. Akbari, Yama Divani, Afshin A. Biller, Jose Phan, Thanh Steinwender, Sandy Silver, Brian Zand, Ramin Basri, Hamidon Bin Iqbal, Omer M. Ranta, Annemarei Ruland, Sean Macri, Elizabeth Ma, Henry Nguyen, Thanh N. Abootalebi, Shahram Gupta, Animesh Alet, Matias Lattanzi, Simona Desai, Masoom Gagliardi, Rubens J. Girotra, Tarun Inoue, Manabu Yoshimoto, Takeshi Isaac, Cristian Flavo Mayer, Stephan A. Morovatdar, Negar Nilanont, Yongchai Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S. Saber, Hamidreza Kamenova, Saltanat Kondybayeva, Aida Krupinski, Jerzy Siegler, James E. Stranges, Saverio Torbey, Michel T. Yorio, Diana Zurrú, María Cristina Rubinos, Clio Aracelli Shahripour, Reza Bavarsad Borhani-Haghighi, Afshin Napoli, Mario Di Azarpazhooh, M. Reza J Stroke Cerebrovasc Dis Article BACKGROUND: The emergence of the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted global healthcare systems and this may affect stroke care and outcomes. This study examines the changes in stroke epidemiology and care during the COVID-19 pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. METHODS: This study is part of the CASCADE international initiative. From February 18, 2019, to July 18, 2020, we followed ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke hospitalization rates and outcomes in Valiasr Hospital, Zanjan, Iran. We used a Bayesian hierarchical model and an interrupted time series analysis (ITS) to identify changes in stroke hospitalization rate, baseline stroke severity [measured by the National Institutes of Health Stroke Scale (NIHSS)], disability [measured by the modified Rankin Scale (mRS)], presentation time (last seen normal to hospital presentation), thrombolytic therapy rate, median door-to-needle time, length of hospital stay, and in-hospital mortality. We compared in-hospital mortality between study periods using Cox-regression model. RESULTS: During the study period, 1,026 stroke patients were hospitalized. Stroke hospitalization rates per 100,000 population decreased from 68.09 before the pandemic to 44.50 during the pandemic, with a significant decline in both Bayesian [Beta: -1.034; Standard Error (SE): 0.22, 95% CrI: -1.48, -0.59] and ITS analysis (estimate: -1.03, SE = 0.24, p < 0.0001). Furthermore, we observed lower admission rates for patients with mild (NIHSS < 5) ischemic stroke (p < 0.0001). Although, the presentation time and door-to-needle time did not change during the pandemic, a lower proportion of patients received thrombolysis (-10.1%; p = 0.004). We did not see significant changes in admission rate to the stroke unit and in-hospital mortality rate; however, disability at discharge increased (p < 0.0001). CONCLUSION: In Zanjan, Iran, the COVID-19 pandemic has significantly impacted stroke outcomes and altered the delivery of stroke care. Observed lower admission rates for milder stroke may possibly be due to fear of exposure related to COVID-19. The decrease in patients treated with thrombolysis and the increased disability at discharge may indicate changes in the delivery of stroke care and increased pressure on existing stroke acute and subacute services. The results of this research will contribute to a similar analysis of the larger CASCADE dataset in order to confirm findings at a global scale and improve measures to ensure the best quality of care for stroke patients during the COVID-19 pandemic. Elsevier Inc. 2020-12 2020-09-16 /pmc/articles/PMC7494258/ /pubmed/33069086 http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105321 Text en © 2020 Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Since January 2020 Elsevier has created a COVID-19 resource centre with free information in English and Mandarin on the novel coronavirus COVID-19. The COVID-19 resource centre is hosted on Elsevier Connect, the company's public news and information website. Elsevier hereby grants permission to make all its COVID-19-related research that is available on the COVID-19 resource centre - including this research content - immediately available in PubMed Central and other publicly funded repositories, such as the WHO COVID database with rights for unrestricted research re-use and analyses in any form or by any means with acknowledgement of the original source. These permissions are granted for free by Elsevier for as long as the COVID-19 resource centre remains active.
spellingShingle Article
Ghoreishi, Abdoreza
Arsang-Jang, Shahram
Sabaa-Ayoun, Ziad
Yassi, Nawaf
Sylaja, P.N.
Akbari, Yama
Divani, Afshin A.
Biller, Jose
Phan, Thanh
Steinwender, Sandy
Silver, Brian
Zand, Ramin
Basri, Hamidon Bin
Iqbal, Omer M.
Ranta, Annemarei
Ruland, Sean
Macri, Elizabeth
Ma, Henry
Nguyen, Thanh N.
Abootalebi, Shahram
Gupta, Animesh
Alet, Matias
Lattanzi, Simona
Desai, Masoom
Gagliardi, Rubens J.
Girotra, Tarun
Inoue, Manabu
Yoshimoto, Takeshi
Isaac, Cristian Flavo
Mayer, Stephan A.
Morovatdar, Negar
Nilanont, Yongchai
Nobleza, Christa O'Hana S.
Saber, Hamidreza
Kamenova, Saltanat
Kondybayeva, Aida
Krupinski, Jerzy
Siegler, James E.
Stranges, Saverio
Torbey, Michel T.
Yorio, Diana
Zurrú, María Cristina
Rubinos, Clio Aracelli
Shahripour, Reza Bavarsad
Borhani-Haghighi, Afshin
Napoli, Mario Di
Azarpazhooh, M. Reza
Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title_full Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title_fullStr Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title_full_unstemmed Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title_short Stroke Care Trends During COVID-19 Pandemic in Zanjan Province, Iran. From the CASCADE Initiative: Statistical Analysis Plan and Preliminary Results
title_sort stroke care trends during covid-19 pandemic in zanjan province, iran. from the cascade initiative: statistical analysis plan and preliminary results
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7494258/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33069086
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jstrokecerebrovasdis.2020.105321
work_keys_str_mv AT ghoreishiabdoreza strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT arsangjangshahram strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT sabaaayounziad strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT yassinawaf strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT sylajapn strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT akbariyama strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT divaniafshina strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT billerjose strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT phanthanh strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT steinwendersandy strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT silverbrian strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT zandramin strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT basrihamidonbin strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT iqbalomerm strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT rantaannemarei strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT rulandsean strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT macrielizabeth strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT mahenry strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT nguyenthanhn strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT abootalebishahram strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT guptaanimesh strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT aletmatias strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT lattanzisimona strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT desaimasoom strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT gagliardirubensj strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT girotratarun strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT inouemanabu strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT yoshimototakeshi strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT isaaccristianflavo strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT mayerstephana strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT morovatdarnegar strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT nilanontyongchai strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT noblezachristaohanas strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT saberhamidreza strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT kamenovasaltanat strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT kondybayevaaida strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT krupinskijerzy strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT sieglerjamese strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT strangessaverio strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT torbeymichelt strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT yoriodiana strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT zurrumariacristina strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT rubinosclioaracelli strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT shahripourrezabavarsad strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT borhanihaghighiafshin strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT napolimariodi strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults
AT azarpazhoohmreza strokecaretrendsduringcovid19pandemicinzanjanprovinceiranfromthecascadeinitiativestatisticalanalysisplanandpreliminaryresults