Cargando…
A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates
Threats to biodiversity are well documented. However, to effectively conserve species and their habitats, we need to know which conservation interventions do (or do not) work. Evidence-based conservation evaluates interventions within a scientific framework. The Conservation Evidence project has sum...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7498340/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32973409 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biaa082 |
_version_ | 1783583489094844416 |
---|---|
author | Junker, Jessica Petrovan, Silviu O Arroyo-RodrÍguez, Victor Boonratana, Ramesh Byler, Dirck Chapman, Colin A Chetry, Dilip Cheyne, Susan M Cornejo, Fanny M CortÉs-Ortiz, Liliana Cowlishaw, Guy Christie, Alec P Crockford, Catherine Torre, Stella De La De Melo, Fabiano R Fan, P Grueter, Cyril C GuzmÁn-Caro, Diana C Heymann, Eckhard W Herbinger, Ilka Hoang, Minh D Horwich, Robert H Humle, Tatyana Ikemeh, Rachel A Imong, Inaoyom S Jerusalinsky, Leandro Johnson, Steig E Kappeler, Peter M Kierulff, Maria CecÍlia M KonÉ, Inza Kormos, Rebecca Le, Khac Q Li, Baoguo Marshall, Andrew J Meijaard, Erik Mittermeier, Russel A Muroyama, Yasuyuki Neugebauer, Eleonora Orth, Lisa Palacios, Erwin Papworth, Sarah K Plumptre, Andrew J Rawson, Ben M Refisch, Johannes Ratsimbazafy, Jonah Roos, Christian Setchell, Joanna M Smith, Rebecca K Sop, Tene Schwitzer, Christoph Slater, Kathy Strum, Shirley C Sutherland, William J Talebi, MaurÍcio Wallis, Janette Wich, Serge Williamson, Elizabeth A Wittig, Roman M KÜhl, Hjalmar S |
author_facet | Junker, Jessica Petrovan, Silviu O Arroyo-RodrÍguez, Victor Boonratana, Ramesh Byler, Dirck Chapman, Colin A Chetry, Dilip Cheyne, Susan M Cornejo, Fanny M CortÉs-Ortiz, Liliana Cowlishaw, Guy Christie, Alec P Crockford, Catherine Torre, Stella De La De Melo, Fabiano R Fan, P Grueter, Cyril C GuzmÁn-Caro, Diana C Heymann, Eckhard W Herbinger, Ilka Hoang, Minh D Horwich, Robert H Humle, Tatyana Ikemeh, Rachel A Imong, Inaoyom S Jerusalinsky, Leandro Johnson, Steig E Kappeler, Peter M Kierulff, Maria CecÍlia M KonÉ, Inza Kormos, Rebecca Le, Khac Q Li, Baoguo Marshall, Andrew J Meijaard, Erik Mittermeier, Russel A Muroyama, Yasuyuki Neugebauer, Eleonora Orth, Lisa Palacios, Erwin Papworth, Sarah K Plumptre, Andrew J Rawson, Ben M Refisch, Johannes Ratsimbazafy, Jonah Roos, Christian Setchell, Joanna M Smith, Rebecca K Sop, Tene Schwitzer, Christoph Slater, Kathy Strum, Shirley C Sutherland, William J Talebi, MaurÍcio Wallis, Janette Wich, Serge Williamson, Elizabeth A Wittig, Roman M KÜhl, Hjalmar S |
author_sort | Junker, Jessica |
collection | PubMed |
description | Threats to biodiversity are well documented. However, to effectively conserve species and their habitats, we need to know which conservation interventions do (or do not) work. Evidence-based conservation evaluates interventions within a scientific framework. The Conservation Evidence project has summarized thousands of studies testing conservation interventions and compiled these as synopses for various habitats and taxa. In the present article, we analyzed the interventions assessed in the primate synopsis and compared these with other taxa. We found that despite intensive efforts to study primates and the extensive threats they face, less than 1% of primate studies evaluated conservation effectiveness. The studies often lacked quantitative data, failed to undertake postimplementation monitoring of populations or individuals, or implemented several interventions at once. Furthermore, the studies were biased toward specific taxa, geographic regions, and interventions. We describe barriers for testing primate conservation interventions and propose actions to improve the conservation evidence base to protect this endangered and globally important taxon. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7498340 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-74983402020-09-23 A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates Junker, Jessica Petrovan, Silviu O Arroyo-RodrÍguez, Victor Boonratana, Ramesh Byler, Dirck Chapman, Colin A Chetry, Dilip Cheyne, Susan M Cornejo, Fanny M CortÉs-Ortiz, Liliana Cowlishaw, Guy Christie, Alec P Crockford, Catherine Torre, Stella De La De Melo, Fabiano R Fan, P Grueter, Cyril C GuzmÁn-Caro, Diana C Heymann, Eckhard W Herbinger, Ilka Hoang, Minh D Horwich, Robert H Humle, Tatyana Ikemeh, Rachel A Imong, Inaoyom S Jerusalinsky, Leandro Johnson, Steig E Kappeler, Peter M Kierulff, Maria CecÍlia M KonÉ, Inza Kormos, Rebecca Le, Khac Q Li, Baoguo Marshall, Andrew J Meijaard, Erik Mittermeier, Russel A Muroyama, Yasuyuki Neugebauer, Eleonora Orth, Lisa Palacios, Erwin Papworth, Sarah K Plumptre, Andrew J Rawson, Ben M Refisch, Johannes Ratsimbazafy, Jonah Roos, Christian Setchell, Joanna M Smith, Rebecca K Sop, Tene Schwitzer, Christoph Slater, Kathy Strum, Shirley C Sutherland, William J Talebi, MaurÍcio Wallis, Janette Wich, Serge Williamson, Elizabeth A Wittig, Roman M KÜhl, Hjalmar S Bioscience Forum Threats to biodiversity are well documented. However, to effectively conserve species and their habitats, we need to know which conservation interventions do (or do not) work. Evidence-based conservation evaluates interventions within a scientific framework. The Conservation Evidence project has summarized thousands of studies testing conservation interventions and compiled these as synopses for various habitats and taxa. In the present article, we analyzed the interventions assessed in the primate synopsis and compared these with other taxa. We found that despite intensive efforts to study primates and the extensive threats they face, less than 1% of primate studies evaluated conservation effectiveness. The studies often lacked quantitative data, failed to undertake postimplementation monitoring of populations or individuals, or implemented several interventions at once. Furthermore, the studies were biased toward specific taxa, geographic regions, and interventions. We describe barriers for testing primate conservation interventions and propose actions to improve the conservation evidence base to protect this endangered and globally important taxon. Oxford University Press 2020-08-26 /pmc/articles/PMC7498340/ /pubmed/32973409 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biaa082 Text en © The Author(s) 2020. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the American Institute of Biological Sciences. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Forum Junker, Jessica Petrovan, Silviu O Arroyo-RodrÍguez, Victor Boonratana, Ramesh Byler, Dirck Chapman, Colin A Chetry, Dilip Cheyne, Susan M Cornejo, Fanny M CortÉs-Ortiz, Liliana Cowlishaw, Guy Christie, Alec P Crockford, Catherine Torre, Stella De La De Melo, Fabiano R Fan, P Grueter, Cyril C GuzmÁn-Caro, Diana C Heymann, Eckhard W Herbinger, Ilka Hoang, Minh D Horwich, Robert H Humle, Tatyana Ikemeh, Rachel A Imong, Inaoyom S Jerusalinsky, Leandro Johnson, Steig E Kappeler, Peter M Kierulff, Maria CecÍlia M KonÉ, Inza Kormos, Rebecca Le, Khac Q Li, Baoguo Marshall, Andrew J Meijaard, Erik Mittermeier, Russel A Muroyama, Yasuyuki Neugebauer, Eleonora Orth, Lisa Palacios, Erwin Papworth, Sarah K Plumptre, Andrew J Rawson, Ben M Refisch, Johannes Ratsimbazafy, Jonah Roos, Christian Setchell, Joanna M Smith, Rebecca K Sop, Tene Schwitzer, Christoph Slater, Kathy Strum, Shirley C Sutherland, William J Talebi, MaurÍcio Wallis, Janette Wich, Serge Williamson, Elizabeth A Wittig, Roman M KÜhl, Hjalmar S A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title | A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title_full | A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title_fullStr | A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title_full_unstemmed | A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title_short | A Severe Lack of Evidence Limits Effective Conservation of the World's Primates |
title_sort | severe lack of evidence limits effective conservation of the world's primates |
topic | Forum |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7498340/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32973409 http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/biosci/biaa082 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT junkerjessica aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT petrovansilviuo aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT arroyorodriguezvictor aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT boonratanaramesh aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT bylerdirck aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT chapmancolina aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT chetrydilip aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cheynesusanm aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cornejofannym aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cortesortizliliana aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cowlishawguy aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT christiealecp aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT crockfordcatherine aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT torrestelladela aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT demelofabianor aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT fanp aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT gruetercyrilc aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT guzmancarodianac aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT heymanneckhardw aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT herbingerilka aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT hoangminhd aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT horwichroberth aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT humletatyana aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT ikemehrachela aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT imonginaoyoms aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT jerusalinskyleandro aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT johnsonsteige aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kappelerpeterm aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kierulffmariaceciliam aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT koneinza aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kormosrebecca aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT lekhacq aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT libaoguo aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT marshallandrewj aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT meijaarderik aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT mittermeierrussela aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT muroyamayasuyuki aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT neugebauereleonora aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT orthlisa aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT palacioserwin aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT papworthsarahk aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT plumptreandrewj aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT rawsonbenm aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT refischjohannes aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT ratsimbazafyjonah aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT rooschristian aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT setchelljoannam aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT smithrebeccak aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT soptene aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT schwitzerchristoph aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT slaterkathy aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT strumshirleyc aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT sutherlandwilliamj aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT talebimauricio aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wallisjanette aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wichserge aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT williamsonelizabetha aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wittigromanm aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kuhlhjalmars aseverelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT junkerjessica severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT petrovansilviuo severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT arroyorodriguezvictor severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT boonratanaramesh severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT bylerdirck severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT chapmancolina severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT chetrydilip severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cheynesusanm severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cornejofannym severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cortesortizliliana severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT cowlishawguy severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT christiealecp severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT crockfordcatherine severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT torrestelladela severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT demelofabianor severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT fanp severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT gruetercyrilc severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT guzmancarodianac severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT heymanneckhardw severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT herbingerilka severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT hoangminhd severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT horwichroberth severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT humletatyana severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT ikemehrachela severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT imonginaoyoms severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT jerusalinskyleandro severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT johnsonsteige severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kappelerpeterm severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kierulffmariaceciliam severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT koneinza severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kormosrebecca severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT lekhacq severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT libaoguo severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT marshallandrewj severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT meijaarderik severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT mittermeierrussela severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT muroyamayasuyuki severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT neugebauereleonora severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT orthlisa severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT palacioserwin severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT papworthsarahk severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT plumptreandrewj severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT rawsonbenm severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT refischjohannes severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT ratsimbazafyjonah severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT rooschristian severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT setchelljoannam severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT smithrebeccak severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT soptene severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT schwitzerchristoph severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT slaterkathy severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT strumshirleyc severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT sutherlandwilliamj severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT talebimauricio severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wallisjanette severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wichserge severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT williamsonelizabetha severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT wittigromanm severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates AT kuhlhjalmars severelackofevidencelimitseffectiveconservationoftheworldsprimates |