Comparison of gross tumor volumes of pulmonary metastasis defined by CT and MRI in 0.345 T MRI-guided radiotherapy

OBJECTIVE: To assess the difference in gross tumor volumes (GTVs) defined by CT (GTV-CT) and by low magnetic field strength (0.345 T) MRI (GTV-MRI) in patients simulated for MRI-guided radiotherapy forlung metastasis. METHODS: 28 patients (148 lesions) who underwent CT and MRI simulation with the tri-60Co MRI-guided radiotherapy system (MRIdian, ViewRay) were included in this study. GTV-CT and GTV-MRI were compared using the paired t-test. The equivalence of variance between GTV-CT and GTV-MRI of small lesions (GTV-CT <1 ml) and large ones (GTV-CT >= 1 ml) was evaluated using F-test. The correlation between GTV-CT and GTV-MRI was evaluated by the correlation coefficient. RESULTS: GTV-MRI was 120% larger than GTV-CT (p < 0.001) for small lesions, whereas GTV-MRI was 40% larger than GTV-CT (p < 0.001) for large lesions. In small lesions, the variation in GTV-MRI was significantly larger than that of GTV-CT (p < 0.001). There was no significant difference in the variation of GTV-MRI and GTV-CT in large lesions (p = 0.121). The correlation coefficient for small lesions was 0.93, whereas that for large lesions was 0.99, with large lesions having better correlation. CONCLUSIONS: GTV-MRI was larger than GTV-CT and the correlation between GTV-MRI and GTV-CT was better in large lesions. If the tumor volume is 1 ml or larger, the lesion can be accurately monitored even with a low magnetic field strength MRI. ADVANCES IN KNOWLEDGE: This study is the first clinical report to evaluate the tolerability of MRI images in 0.345 T MRI-guided radiotherapy for lung metastasis. GTV contoured by MRI was larger than GTV by CT, and this tendency was more pronounced in small tumors of less than 1 ml.