Cargando…

Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Cervical cancer prevention is presently undergoing a thorough reformation due to introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV)-testing and vaccines in primary prevention. The screening program, however, is more than a single test or preventive intervention—the possible lesion has to be...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sabrina, Forsell, Ilkka, Kalliala, Mervi, Halttunen-Nieminen, Charles, Redman, Simon, Leeson, Ameli, Tropé, Esther, Moss, Maria, Kyrgiou, Eeva, Pyörälä, Pekka, Nieminen
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7692698/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33143157
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers12113201
_version_ 1783614572993708032
author Sabrina, Forsell
Ilkka, Kalliala
Mervi, Halttunen-Nieminen
Charles, Redman
Simon, Leeson
Ameli, Tropé
Esther, Moss
Maria, Kyrgiou
Eeva, Pyörälä
Pekka, Nieminen
author_facet Sabrina, Forsell
Ilkka, Kalliala
Mervi, Halttunen-Nieminen
Charles, Redman
Simon, Leeson
Ameli, Tropé
Esther, Moss
Maria, Kyrgiou
Eeva, Pyörälä
Pekka, Nieminen
author_sort Sabrina, Forsell
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Cervical cancer prevention is presently undergoing a thorough reformation due to introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV)-testing and vaccines in primary prevention. The screening program, however, is more than a single test or preventive intervention—the possible lesion has to be found, located and treated. Colposcopy plays a major role in this management. Literature dealing with training and learning, especially with colposcopy, is extremely scarce. The aim of the European Federation of Colposcopy, EFC, is to improve the education and training in colposcopy, e.g., by organizing colposcopy courses. The aim of our prospective interventional study was to pilot this intensive participant activating EFC Basic Colposcopy Course on the short- and long-term learning of colposcopy-related knowledge, image recognition and the diagnostic confidence. ABSTRACT: High-quality colposcopy is essential in cervical cancer prevention. We performed a multicentre prospective interventional pilot-study, evaluating the effect of a six-hour case-based colposcopy course on short- and long-term learning of colposcopy-related knowledge, diagnostic accuracy levels and confidence. We recruited 213 colposcopists participating in three European Federation of Colposcopy (EFC) basic colposcopy courses (Finland, Norway, UK). The study consisted of three tests with identical content performed before, after and 2 months after the course, including ten colposcopic images, ten patient cases and scales for marking confidence in the answers. Outcome measures where mean scores in correct case-management, diagnosis (including high-grade lesion recognition), transformation-zone recognition and confidence in answers. Results were compared between the three tests and stratified according to experience. Mean test scores improved after the course for all participants. The increase was highest for beginners. Confidence in answers improved and the number of colposcopists showing high confidence with low scores decreased. A structured case-based course improves skills and confidence especially for inexperienced colposcopists; however, trainers should be aware of the risk of overconfidence. To complement theoretical training, further hands-on training including high-quality feedback is recommended. Conclusions drawn from long-term learning are limited due to the low participation in the follow-up test.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7692698
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-76926982020-11-28 Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK Sabrina, Forsell Ilkka, Kalliala Mervi, Halttunen-Nieminen Charles, Redman Simon, Leeson Ameli, Tropé Esther, Moss Maria, Kyrgiou Eeva, Pyörälä Pekka, Nieminen Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Cervical cancer prevention is presently undergoing a thorough reformation due to introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV)-testing and vaccines in primary prevention. The screening program, however, is more than a single test or preventive intervention—the possible lesion has to be found, located and treated. Colposcopy plays a major role in this management. Literature dealing with training and learning, especially with colposcopy, is extremely scarce. The aim of the European Federation of Colposcopy, EFC, is to improve the education and training in colposcopy, e.g., by organizing colposcopy courses. The aim of our prospective interventional study was to pilot this intensive participant activating EFC Basic Colposcopy Course on the short- and long-term learning of colposcopy-related knowledge, image recognition and the diagnostic confidence. ABSTRACT: High-quality colposcopy is essential in cervical cancer prevention. We performed a multicentre prospective interventional pilot-study, evaluating the effect of a six-hour case-based colposcopy course on short- and long-term learning of colposcopy-related knowledge, diagnostic accuracy levels and confidence. We recruited 213 colposcopists participating in three European Federation of Colposcopy (EFC) basic colposcopy courses (Finland, Norway, UK). The study consisted of three tests with identical content performed before, after and 2 months after the course, including ten colposcopic images, ten patient cases and scales for marking confidence in the answers. Outcome measures where mean scores in correct case-management, diagnosis (including high-grade lesion recognition), transformation-zone recognition and confidence in answers. Results were compared between the three tests and stratified according to experience. Mean test scores improved after the course for all participants. The increase was highest for beginners. Confidence in answers improved and the number of colposcopists showing high confidence with low scores decreased. A structured case-based course improves skills and confidence especially for inexperienced colposcopists; however, trainers should be aware of the risk of overconfidence. To complement theoretical training, further hands-on training including high-quality feedback is recommended. Conclusions drawn from long-term learning are limited due to the low participation in the follow-up test. MDPI 2020-10-30 /pmc/articles/PMC7692698/ /pubmed/33143157 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers12113201 Text en © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Sabrina, Forsell
Ilkka, Kalliala
Mervi, Halttunen-Nieminen
Charles, Redman
Simon, Leeson
Ameli, Tropé
Esther, Moss
Maria, Kyrgiou
Eeva, Pyörälä
Pekka, Nieminen
Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title_full Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title_fullStr Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title_full_unstemmed Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title_short Fostering Prevention of Cervical Cancer by a Correct Diagnosis of Precursors: A Structured Case-Based Colposcopy Course in Finland, Norway and UK
title_sort fostering prevention of cervical cancer by a correct diagnosis of precursors: a structured case-based colposcopy course in finland, norway and uk
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7692698/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33143157
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers12113201
work_keys_str_mv AT sabrinaforsell fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT ilkkakalliala fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT mervihalttunennieminen fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT charlesredman fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT simonleeson fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT amelitrope fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT esthermoss fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT mariakyrgiou fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT eevapyorala fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk
AT pekkanieminen fosteringpreventionofcervicalcancerbyacorrectdiagnosisofprecursorsastructuredcasebasedcolposcopycourseinfinlandnorwayanduk