Species Separation within, and Preliminary Phylogeny for, the Leafhopper Genus Anoscopus with Particular Reference to the Putative British Endemic Anoscopus duffieldi (Hemiptera: Cicadellidae)

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Anoscopus leafhoppers are a group of plant-feeding bugs that can be found in a range of grassland habitats. There are seven recognized species in the UK, some of which are difficult to tell apart. One species, Anoscopus duffieldi, has only been found at a single site, an RSPB (Royal Society for the Protection of Birds) reserve at Dungeness in Kent. As Anoscopus leafhoppers can be quite variable in colour and pattern, and in the structure of their genitalia, our aim was to establish, using DNA, whether this ‘species’ is unique or whether it is simply a variant of one of the other species. If it is unique, found nowhere else, it should be afforded special protection. Samples of all UK species, as well as another from the Czech Republic, were collected from the field, and two genes were examined. The DNA sequences showed that three species, A. duffieldi, Anoscopus albifrons and Anoscopus limicola were so closely related that they should probably be considered a single species. However, A. duffieldi are distinctive in that they live only in one area of vegetated shingle. We suggest that, until other evidence is forthcoming, A. duffieldi could be considered a locally adapted subspecies of scientific interest. ABSTRACT: The subfamily Aphrodinae (Hemiptera: Cicadellidae) contains ~33 species in Europe within four genera. Species in two genera in particular, Aphrodes and Anoscopus, have proved to be difficult to distinguish morphologically. Our aim was to determine the status of the putative species Anoscopus duffieldi, found only on the RSPB Nature Reserve at Dungeness, Kent, a possible rare UK endemic. DNA from samples of all seven UK Anoscopus species (plus Anoscopus alpinus from the Czech Republic) were sequenced using parts of the mitochondrial cytochrome oxidase I and 16S rRNA genes. Bayesian inference phylogenies were created. Specimens of each species clustered into monophyletic groups, except for Anoscopus albifrons, A. duffieldi and Anoscopus limicola. Two A. albifrons specimens grouped with A. duffieldi repeatedly with strong support, and the remaining A. albifrons clustered within A. limicola. Genetic distances suggest that A. albifrons and A. limicola are a single interbreeding population (0% divergence), while A. albifrons and A. duffieldi diverged by only 0.28%. Shared haplotypes between A. albifrons, A. limicola and A. duffieldi strongly suggest interbreeding, although misidentification may also explain these topologies. However, all A. duffieldi clustered together in the trees. A conservative approach might be to treat A. duffieldi, until other evidence is forthcoming, as a possible endemic subspecies.