Influence of Inter- and Intra-Batch Variability on the Sample Size Required for Demonstration of Equivalent Microstructure of Semisolid Dosage Forms

Inter- and intra-batch variability of the quality attributes contribute to the uncertainty for demonstrating equivalent microstructure of post-approval changes and generic/hybrids of semisolid topical products. Selecting a representative sample size to describe accurately the in vitro properties of semisolids and to reach enough statistical power to demonstrate similarity between two semisolid topical products is currently challenging. The objective of this work is to establish the number of batches and units per batch to be compared based on different inter-batch and intra-batch variability to demonstrate equivalence in the physical characteristics of the products that ensure a similar microstructure of the semisolid. This investigation shows that the minimum number of batches to be compared of each product is 3 and the minimum number of units per batch could be 6 in the case of low intra- and inter-batch variability. If the products are not identical, i.e., 2.5–5% differences that are expected due to differences in the manufacturing process or the suppliers of excipients, 12 units and 6 batches are needed. If intra- or inter-batch variability is larger than 10%, the number of batches and/or the number of units needs to be increased. As the interplay between inter- and intra-batch variability is complex, the sample size required for each combination of inter- and intra-batch variability and expected difference between products can be obtained in the attached tables.