Viral Vectors as Gene Therapy Agents for Treatment of Glioblastoma

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Glioblastoma is the most malignant cancer of the brain and current therapeutic strategies are clearly inadequate. In addition to surgical intervention, conventional drugs and ratio-therapy, scientists are looking at approaches based on gene therapy with genetically modified viruses. In this review we give a snapshot of the current state of play in this field of research and the available information about the clinical trials. We make some suggestions as to what opportunities could be explored further and hope that this review will stimulate discussion and conception of new life saving strategies. ABSTRACT: In this review, we scrutinize the idea of using viral vectors either as cytotoxic agents or gene delivery tools for treatment of glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) in light of the experience that our laboratory has accumulated over ~20 years when using similar vectors in experimental neuroscience. We review molecular strategies and current clinical trials and argue that approaches which are based on targeting a specific biochemical pathway or a characteristic mutation are inherently prone to failure because of the high genomic instability and clonal selection characteristics of GBM. For the same reasons, attempts to develop a viral system which selectively transduces only GBM cells are also unlikely to be universally successful. One of the common gene therapy approaches is to use cytotoxic viruses which replicate and cause preferential lysis of the GBM cells. This strategy, in addition to its reliance on the specific biochemical makeup of the GBM cells, bears a risk of necrotic cell death accompanied by release of large quantities of pro-inflammatory molecules. On the other hand, engaging the immune system in the anti-GBM response seems to be a potential avenue to explore further. We suggest that a plausible strategy is to focus on viral vectors which efficiently transduce brain cells via a non-selective, ubiquitous mechanism and which target (ideally irreversibly) processes that are critical only for dividing tumor cells and are dispensable for quiescent brain cells.