Cargando…
Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial
High‐throughput molecular profiling of solid tumours using core needle biopsies (CNB) allows the identification of actionable molecular alterations, with around 70% success rate. Although several studies have demonstrated the utility of small biopsy specimens for molecular testing, there remains deb...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley and Sons Inc.
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7782085/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32750212 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12776 |
_version_ | 1783631819646697472 |
---|---|
author | Dupain, Célia Masliah‐Planchon, Julien Gu, Céline Girard, Elodie Gestraud, Pierre Du Rusquec, Pauline Borcoman, Edith Bello, Diana Ricci, Francesco Hescot, Ségolène Sablin, Marie‐Paule Tresca, Patricia de Moura, Alexandre Loirat, Delphine Frelaut, Maxime Vincent‐Salomon, Anne Lecerf, Charlotte Callens, Céline Antonio, Samantha Franck, Coralie Mariani, Odette Bièche, Ivan Kamal, Maud Le Tourneau, Christophe Servois, Vincent |
author_facet | Dupain, Célia Masliah‐Planchon, Julien Gu, Céline Girard, Elodie Gestraud, Pierre Du Rusquec, Pauline Borcoman, Edith Bello, Diana Ricci, Francesco Hescot, Ségolène Sablin, Marie‐Paule Tresca, Patricia de Moura, Alexandre Loirat, Delphine Frelaut, Maxime Vincent‐Salomon, Anne Lecerf, Charlotte Callens, Céline Antonio, Samantha Franck, Coralie Mariani, Odette Bièche, Ivan Kamal, Maud Le Tourneau, Christophe Servois, Vincent |
author_sort | Dupain, Célia |
collection | PubMed |
description | High‐throughput molecular profiling of solid tumours using core needle biopsies (CNB) allows the identification of actionable molecular alterations, with around 70% success rate. Although several studies have demonstrated the utility of small biopsy specimens for molecular testing, there remains debate as to the sensitivity of the less invasive fine‐needle aspiration (FNA) compared to CNB to detect molecular alterations. We aimed to prospectively evaluate the potential of FNA to detect such alterations in various tumour types as compared to CNB in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial. An in‐house amplicon‐based targeted sequencing panel (Illumina TSCA 99.3 kb panel covering 87 genes) was used to identify pathogenic variants and gene copy number variations (CNV) in concomitant CNB and FNA samples obtained from 61 patients enrolled in the SHIVA02 trial (NCT03084757). The main tumour types analysed were breast (38%), colon (15%), pancreas (11%), followed by cervix and stomach (7% each). We report 123 molecular alterations (85 variants, 23 amplifications and 15 homozygous deletions) among which 98 (80%) were concordant between CNB and FNA. The remaining discordances were mainly related to deletions status, yet undetected alterations were not exclusively specific to FNA. Comparative analysis of molecular alterations in CNB and FNA showed high concordance in terms of variants as well as CNVs identified. We conclude FNA could therefore be used in routine diagnostics workflow and clinical trials for tumour molecular profiling with the advantages of being minimally invasive and preserve tissue material needed for diagnostic, prognostic or theranostic purposes. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7782085 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | John Wiley and Sons Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-77820852021-01-08 Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial Dupain, Célia Masliah‐Planchon, Julien Gu, Céline Girard, Elodie Gestraud, Pierre Du Rusquec, Pauline Borcoman, Edith Bello, Diana Ricci, Francesco Hescot, Ségolène Sablin, Marie‐Paule Tresca, Patricia de Moura, Alexandre Loirat, Delphine Frelaut, Maxime Vincent‐Salomon, Anne Lecerf, Charlotte Callens, Céline Antonio, Samantha Franck, Coralie Mariani, Odette Bièche, Ivan Kamal, Maud Le Tourneau, Christophe Servois, Vincent Mol Oncol Research Articles High‐throughput molecular profiling of solid tumours using core needle biopsies (CNB) allows the identification of actionable molecular alterations, with around 70% success rate. Although several studies have demonstrated the utility of small biopsy specimens for molecular testing, there remains debate as to the sensitivity of the less invasive fine‐needle aspiration (FNA) compared to CNB to detect molecular alterations. We aimed to prospectively evaluate the potential of FNA to detect such alterations in various tumour types as compared to CNB in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial. An in‐house amplicon‐based targeted sequencing panel (Illumina TSCA 99.3 kb panel covering 87 genes) was used to identify pathogenic variants and gene copy number variations (CNV) in concomitant CNB and FNA samples obtained from 61 patients enrolled in the SHIVA02 trial (NCT03084757). The main tumour types analysed were breast (38%), colon (15%), pancreas (11%), followed by cervix and stomach (7% each). We report 123 molecular alterations (85 variants, 23 amplifications and 15 homozygous deletions) among which 98 (80%) were concordant between CNB and FNA. The remaining discordances were mainly related to deletions status, yet undetected alterations were not exclusively specific to FNA. Comparative analysis of molecular alterations in CNB and FNA showed high concordance in terms of variants as well as CNVs identified. We conclude FNA could therefore be used in routine diagnostics workflow and clinical trials for tumour molecular profiling with the advantages of being minimally invasive and preserve tissue material needed for diagnostic, prognostic or theranostic purposes. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2020-09-15 2021-01 /pmc/articles/PMC7782085/ /pubmed/32750212 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12776 Text en © 2020 The Authors. Published by FEBS Press and John Wiley & Sons Ltd. This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Research Articles Dupain, Célia Masliah‐Planchon, Julien Gu, Céline Girard, Elodie Gestraud, Pierre Du Rusquec, Pauline Borcoman, Edith Bello, Diana Ricci, Francesco Hescot, Ségolène Sablin, Marie‐Paule Tresca, Patricia de Moura, Alexandre Loirat, Delphine Frelaut, Maxime Vincent‐Salomon, Anne Lecerf, Charlotte Callens, Céline Antonio, Samantha Franck, Coralie Mariani, Odette Bièche, Ivan Kamal, Maud Le Tourneau, Christophe Servois, Vincent Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title | Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title_full | Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title_fullStr | Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title_full_unstemmed | Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title_short | Fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the SHIVA02 trial |
title_sort | fine‐needle aspiration as an alternative to core needle biopsy for tumour molecular profiling in precision oncology: prospective comparative study of next‐generation sequencing in cancer patients included in the shiva02 trial |
topic | Research Articles |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7782085/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32750212 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/1878-0261.12776 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT dupaincelia fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT masliahplanchonjulien fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT guceline fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT girardelodie fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT gestraudpierre fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT durusquecpauline fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT borcomanedith fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT bellodiana fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT riccifrancesco fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT hescotsegolene fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT sablinmariepaule fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT trescapatricia fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT demouraalexandre fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT loiratdelphine fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT frelautmaxime fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT vincentsalomonanne fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT lecerfcharlotte fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT callensceline fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT antoniosamantha fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT franckcoralie fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT marianiodette fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT biecheivan fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT kamalmaud fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT letourneauchristophe fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial AT servoisvincent fineneedleaspirationasanalternativetocoreneedlebiopsyfortumourmolecularprofilinginprecisiononcologyprospectivecomparativestudyofnextgenerationsequencingincancerpatientsincludedintheshiva02trial |