Cargando…

Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium

One of the challenges that restricts the evolving extracellular vesicle (EV) research field is the lack of a consensus method for EV separation. This may also explain the diversity of the experimental results, as co‐separated soluble proteins and lipoproteins may impede the interpretation of experim...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Dong, Liang, Zieren, Richard C., Horie, Kengo, Kim, Chi‐Ju, Mallick, Emily, Jing, Yuezhou, Feng, Mingxiao, Kuczler, Morgan D., Green, Jordan, Amend, Sarah R., Witwer, Kenneth W., de Reijke, Theo M., Cho, Yoon‐Kyoung, Pienta, Kenneth J., Xue, Wei
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7810129/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33489012
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jev2.12044
_version_ 1783637261573685248
author Dong, Liang
Zieren, Richard C.
Horie, Kengo
Kim, Chi‐Ju
Mallick, Emily
Jing, Yuezhou
Feng, Mingxiao
Kuczler, Morgan D.
Green, Jordan
Amend, Sarah R.
Witwer, Kenneth W.
de Reijke, Theo M.
Cho, Yoon‐Kyoung
Pienta, Kenneth J.
Xue, Wei
author_facet Dong, Liang
Zieren, Richard C.
Horie, Kengo
Kim, Chi‐Ju
Mallick, Emily
Jing, Yuezhou
Feng, Mingxiao
Kuczler, Morgan D.
Green, Jordan
Amend, Sarah R.
Witwer, Kenneth W.
de Reijke, Theo M.
Cho, Yoon‐Kyoung
Pienta, Kenneth J.
Xue, Wei
author_sort Dong, Liang
collection PubMed
description One of the challenges that restricts the evolving extracellular vesicle (EV) research field is the lack of a consensus method for EV separation. This may also explain the diversity of the experimental results, as co‐separated soluble proteins and lipoproteins may impede the interpretation of experimental findings. In this study, we comprehensively evaluated the EV yields and sample purities of three most popular EV separation methods, ultracentrifugation, precipitation and size exclusion chromatography combined with ultrafiltration, along with a microfluidic tangential flow filtration device, Exodisc, in three commonly used biological samples, cell culture medium, human urine and plasma. Single EV phenotyping and density‐gradient ultracentrifugation were used to understand the proportion of true EVs in particle separations. Our findings suggest Exodisc has the best EV yield though it may co‐separate contaminants when the non‐EV particle levels are high in input materials. We found no 100% pure EV preparations due to the overlap of their size and density with many non‐EV particles in biofluids. Precipitation has the lowest sample purity, regardless of sample type. The purities of the other techniques may vary in different sample types and are largely dependent on their working principles and the intrinsic composition of the input sample. Researchers should choose the proper separation method according to the sample type, downstream analysis and their working scenarios.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7810129
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-78101292021-01-22 Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium Dong, Liang Zieren, Richard C. Horie, Kengo Kim, Chi‐Ju Mallick, Emily Jing, Yuezhou Feng, Mingxiao Kuczler, Morgan D. Green, Jordan Amend, Sarah R. Witwer, Kenneth W. de Reijke, Theo M. Cho, Yoon‐Kyoung Pienta, Kenneth J. Xue, Wei J Extracell Vesicles Research Articles One of the challenges that restricts the evolving extracellular vesicle (EV) research field is the lack of a consensus method for EV separation. This may also explain the diversity of the experimental results, as co‐separated soluble proteins and lipoproteins may impede the interpretation of experimental findings. In this study, we comprehensively evaluated the EV yields and sample purities of three most popular EV separation methods, ultracentrifugation, precipitation and size exclusion chromatography combined with ultrafiltration, along with a microfluidic tangential flow filtration device, Exodisc, in three commonly used biological samples, cell culture medium, human urine and plasma. Single EV phenotyping and density‐gradient ultracentrifugation were used to understand the proportion of true EVs in particle separations. Our findings suggest Exodisc has the best EV yield though it may co‐separate contaminants when the non‐EV particle levels are high in input materials. We found no 100% pure EV preparations due to the overlap of their size and density with many non‐EV particles in biofluids. Precipitation has the lowest sample purity, regardless of sample type. The purities of the other techniques may vary in different sample types and are largely dependent on their working principles and the intrinsic composition of the input sample. Researchers should choose the proper separation method according to the sample type, downstream analysis and their working scenarios. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2021-01-15 2020-12 /pmc/articles/PMC7810129/ /pubmed/33489012 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jev2.12044 Text en © 2020 The Authors. Journal of Extracellular Vesicles published by Wiley Periodicals, LLC on behalf of the International Society for Extracellular Vesicles This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Research Articles
Dong, Liang
Zieren, Richard C.
Horie, Kengo
Kim, Chi‐Ju
Mallick, Emily
Jing, Yuezhou
Feng, Mingxiao
Kuczler, Morgan D.
Green, Jordan
Amend, Sarah R.
Witwer, Kenneth W.
de Reijke, Theo M.
Cho, Yoon‐Kyoung
Pienta, Kenneth J.
Xue, Wei
Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title_full Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title_fullStr Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title_full_unstemmed Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title_short Comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
title_sort comprehensive evaluation of methods for small extracellular vesicles separation from human plasma, urine and cell culture medium
topic Research Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7810129/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33489012
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/jev2.12044
work_keys_str_mv AT dongliang comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT zierenrichardc comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT horiekengo comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT kimchiju comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT mallickemily comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT jingyuezhou comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT fengmingxiao comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT kuczlermorgand comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT greenjordan comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT amendsarahr comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT witwerkennethw comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT dereijketheom comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT choyoonkyoung comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT pientakennethj comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium
AT xuewei comprehensiveevaluationofmethodsforsmallextracellularvesiclesseparationfromhumanplasmaurineandcellculturemedium