Cargando…

A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum

OBJECTIVE: There are many uncertainties surrounding the aetiology, treatment and sequelae of hyperemesis gravidarum (HG). Prioritising research questions could reduce research waste, helping researchers and funders direct attention to those questions which most urgently need addressing. The HG prior...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Dean, Caitlin R, Bierma, Hyke, Clarke, Ria, Cleary, Brian, Ellis, Patricia, Gadsby, Roger, Gauw, Norah, Lodge, Karen, MacGibbon, Kimber, McBride, Marian, Munro, Deirdre, Nelson-Piercy, Catherine, O'Hara, Margaret, Penny, Helen, Shorter, Katherine, Spijker, René, Trovik, Jone, Watford, Emma, Painter, Rebecca C
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: BMJ Publishing Group 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7813320/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33452191
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041254
_version_ 1783637831958134784
author Dean, Caitlin R
Bierma, Hyke
Clarke, Ria
Cleary, Brian
Ellis, Patricia
Gadsby, Roger
Gauw, Norah
Lodge, Karen
MacGibbon, Kimber
McBride, Marian
Munro, Deirdre
Nelson-Piercy, Catherine
O'Hara, Margaret
Penny, Helen
Shorter, Katherine
Spijker, René
Trovik, Jone
Watford, Emma
Painter, Rebecca C
author_facet Dean, Caitlin R
Bierma, Hyke
Clarke, Ria
Cleary, Brian
Ellis, Patricia
Gadsby, Roger
Gauw, Norah
Lodge, Karen
MacGibbon, Kimber
McBride, Marian
Munro, Deirdre
Nelson-Piercy, Catherine
O'Hara, Margaret
Penny, Helen
Shorter, Katherine
Spijker, René
Trovik, Jone
Watford, Emma
Painter, Rebecca C
author_sort Dean, Caitlin R
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVE: There are many uncertainties surrounding the aetiology, treatment and sequelae of hyperemesis gravidarum (HG). Prioritising research questions could reduce research waste, helping researchers and funders direct attention to those questions which most urgently need addressing. The HG priority setting partnership (PSP) was established to identify and rank the top 25 priority research questions important to both patients and clinicians. METHODS: Following the James Lind Alliance (JLA) methodology, an HG PSP steering group was established. Stakeholders representing patients, carers and multidisciplinary professionals completed an online survey to gather uncertainties. Eligible uncertainties related to HG. Uncertainties on nausea and vomiting of pregnancy and those on complementary treatments were not eligible. Questions were verified against the evidence. Two rounds of prioritisation included an online ranking survey and a 1-hour consensus workshop. RESULTS: 1009 participants (938 patients/carers, 118 professionals with overlap between categories) submitted 2899 questions. Questions originated from participants in 26 different countries, and people from 32 countries took part in the first prioritisation stage. 66 unique questions emerged, which were evidence checked according to the agreed protocol. 65 true uncertainties were narrowed via an online ranking survey to 26 unranked uncertainties. The consensus workshop was attended by 19 international patients and clinicians who reached consensus on the top 10 questions for international researchers to address. More patients than professionals took part in the surveys but were equally distributed during the consensus workshop. Participants from low-income and middle-income countries noted that the priorities may be different in their settings. CONCLUSIONS: By following the JLA method, a prioritised list of uncertainties relevant to both HG patients and their clinicians has been identified which can inform the international HG research agenda, funders and policy-makers. While it is possible to conduct an international PSP, results from developed countries may not be as relevant in low-income and middle-income countries.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7813320
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher BMJ Publishing Group
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-78133202021-01-25 A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum Dean, Caitlin R Bierma, Hyke Clarke, Ria Cleary, Brian Ellis, Patricia Gadsby, Roger Gauw, Norah Lodge, Karen MacGibbon, Kimber McBride, Marian Munro, Deirdre Nelson-Piercy, Catherine O'Hara, Margaret Penny, Helen Shorter, Katherine Spijker, René Trovik, Jone Watford, Emma Painter, Rebecca C BMJ Open Obstetrics and Gynaecology OBJECTIVE: There are many uncertainties surrounding the aetiology, treatment and sequelae of hyperemesis gravidarum (HG). Prioritising research questions could reduce research waste, helping researchers and funders direct attention to those questions which most urgently need addressing. The HG priority setting partnership (PSP) was established to identify and rank the top 25 priority research questions important to both patients and clinicians. METHODS: Following the James Lind Alliance (JLA) methodology, an HG PSP steering group was established. Stakeholders representing patients, carers and multidisciplinary professionals completed an online survey to gather uncertainties. Eligible uncertainties related to HG. Uncertainties on nausea and vomiting of pregnancy and those on complementary treatments were not eligible. Questions were verified against the evidence. Two rounds of prioritisation included an online ranking survey and a 1-hour consensus workshop. RESULTS: 1009 participants (938 patients/carers, 118 professionals with overlap between categories) submitted 2899 questions. Questions originated from participants in 26 different countries, and people from 32 countries took part in the first prioritisation stage. 66 unique questions emerged, which were evidence checked according to the agreed protocol. 65 true uncertainties were narrowed via an online ranking survey to 26 unranked uncertainties. The consensus workshop was attended by 19 international patients and clinicians who reached consensus on the top 10 questions for international researchers to address. More patients than professionals took part in the surveys but were equally distributed during the consensus workshop. Participants from low-income and middle-income countries noted that the priorities may be different in their settings. CONCLUSIONS: By following the JLA method, a prioritised list of uncertainties relevant to both HG patients and their clinicians has been identified which can inform the international HG research agenda, funders and policy-makers. While it is possible to conduct an international PSP, results from developed countries may not be as relevant in low-income and middle-income countries. BMJ Publishing Group 2021-01-15 /pmc/articles/PMC7813320/ /pubmed/33452191 http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041254 Text en © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2021. Re-use permitted under CC BY. Published by BMJ. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed in accordance with the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 Unported (CC BY 4.0) license, which permits others to copy, redistribute, remix, transform and build upon this work for any purpose, provided the original work is properly cited, a link to the licence is given, and indication of whether changes were made. See: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/.
spellingShingle Obstetrics and Gynaecology
Dean, Caitlin R
Bierma, Hyke
Clarke, Ria
Cleary, Brian
Ellis, Patricia
Gadsby, Roger
Gauw, Norah
Lodge, Karen
MacGibbon, Kimber
McBride, Marian
Munro, Deirdre
Nelson-Piercy, Catherine
O'Hara, Margaret
Penny, Helen
Shorter, Katherine
Spijker, René
Trovik, Jone
Watford, Emma
Painter, Rebecca C
A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title_full A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title_fullStr A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title_full_unstemmed A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title_short A patient–clinician James Lind Alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
title_sort patient–clinician james lind alliance partnership to identify research priorities for hyperemesis gravidarum
topic Obstetrics and Gynaecology
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7813320/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33452191
http://dx.doi.org/10.1136/bmjopen-2020-041254
work_keys_str_mv AT deancaitlinr apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT biermahyke apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT clarkeria apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT clearybrian apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT ellispatricia apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT gadsbyroger apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT gauwnorah apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT lodgekaren apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT macgibbonkimber apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT mcbridemarian apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT munrodeirdre apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT nelsonpiercycatherine apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT oharamargaret apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT pennyhelen apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT shorterkatherine apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT spijkerrene apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT trovikjone apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT watfordemma apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT painterrebeccac apatientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT deancaitlinr patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT biermahyke patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT clarkeria patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT clearybrian patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT ellispatricia patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT gadsbyroger patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT gauwnorah patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT lodgekaren patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT macgibbonkimber patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT mcbridemarian patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT munrodeirdre patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT nelsonpiercycatherine patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT oharamargaret patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT pennyhelen patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT shorterkatherine patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT spijkerrene patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT trovikjone patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT watfordemma patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum
AT painterrebeccac patientclinicianjameslindalliancepartnershiptoidentifyresearchprioritiesforhyperemesisgravidarum