Antimicrobial effects in oral microenvironments by a novel herbal toothpaste

OBJECTIVE: This clinical study compared the antibacterial effects after brushing with a novel herbal toothpaste incorporating zinc [test] to a control fluoride toothpaste on anaerobic organisms, gram-negative bacteria and malodor bacteria of dental plaque, tongue scrapings and cheek surfaces. METHODS: This double-blind, two-cell study enrolled 44 adults [age range 19–63 years]. Subjects completed a 1-week washout and provided baseline oral samples i.e. dental plaque, tongue and cheek scrapings for microbiological analysis. Diluted samples for microbiological analyses were plated on agar to enumerate anaerobic organisms, gram-negative bacteria and malodor bacteria representing functional groups of organisms. Subjects were randomized to brush their teeth with either the test or control with the first brushing conducted under supervision in the dental clinic. Post-treatment samples were collected 12 h after 21 day hygiene with assigned toothpaste. After providing these samples, subjects brushed in the dental clinic with additional samples collected 4 h after brushing. Statistical analyses were conducted separately for each organism collected from each oral niche by t-test for within-treatment assessments and analysis of covariance (ANCOVA) for between-treatment comparisons. RESULTS: Treatment groups demonstrated no significant differences at baseline for anaerobic organisms, gram-negative bacteria and malodor bacteria in any oral niche (p > 0.05). The test demonstrated reductions between 42 and 68% for anaerobic bacteria in oral niches, 12 h after brushing with reductions increasing to 46–80%, 4 h after brushing. Similarly, the test demonstrated reductions between 49 and 61% for gram-negative bacteria of oral niches that increased to 54–69% at the 4 h post-brushing evaluation. Reductions in malodor organisms of 22–42% were noted 12 h after brushing that increased to 60–72%, 4 h after brushing. CONCLUSIONS: In comparison to control, brushing with a novel herbal toothpaste demonstrated significant reductions in functional bacterial groups from distinct oral niches 12 h after brushing with additional microbial reductions 4 h after brushing.