Cargando…
Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy
BACKGROUND: In the absence of rapid on‐side pathological evaluation, endoscopy staff generally “smears” endoscopic ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration (EUS‐FNA) specimens on a glass slide. As this technique is vulnerable to preparation artifacts, we assessed if its quality could be improved thr...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
2020
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7820998/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33098625 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/dc.24645 |
_version_ | 1783639330053423104 |
---|---|
author | van Riet, Priscilla A. Quispel, Rutger Cahen, Djuna L. Erler, Nicole S. Snijders‐Kruisbergen, Mieke C. Van Loenen, Petri Poley, Jan‐Werner van Driel, Lydi M.J.W. Mulder, Sanna A. Veldt, Bart J. Leeuwenburgh, Ivonne Anten, Marie‐Paule G.F. Honkoop, Pieter Thijssen, Annemieke Y. Hol, Lieke Hadithi, Mohammed Fitzpatrick, Claire E. Schot, Ingrid Bergmann, Jilling F. Bhalla, Abha Bruno, Marco J. Biermann, Katharina |
author_facet | van Riet, Priscilla A. Quispel, Rutger Cahen, Djuna L. Erler, Nicole S. Snijders‐Kruisbergen, Mieke C. Van Loenen, Petri Poley, Jan‐Werner van Driel, Lydi M.J.W. Mulder, Sanna A. Veldt, Bart J. Leeuwenburgh, Ivonne Anten, Marie‐Paule G.F. Honkoop, Pieter Thijssen, Annemieke Y. Hol, Lieke Hadithi, Mohammed Fitzpatrick, Claire E. Schot, Ingrid Bergmann, Jilling F. Bhalla, Abha Bruno, Marco J. Biermann, Katharina |
author_sort | van Riet, Priscilla A. |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: In the absence of rapid on‐side pathological evaluation, endoscopy staff generally “smears” endoscopic ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration (EUS‐FNA) specimens on a glass slide. As this technique is vulnerable to preparation artifacts, we assessed if its quality could be improved through a smear‐preparation‐training for endoscopy staff. METHODS: In this prospective pilot study, 10 endosonographers and 12 endoscopy nurses from seven regional EUS‐centers in the Netherlands were invited to participate in a EUS‐FNA smear‐preparation‐training. Subsequently, post training slides derived from solid pancreatic lesions were compared to pre‐training “control” slides. Primary outcome was to assess if the training positively affects smear quality and, consequently, diagnostic accuracy of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions. RESULTS: Participants collected and prepared 71 cases, mostly pancreatic head lesions (48%). Sixty‐eight controls were selected from the pretraining period. The presence of artifacts was comparable for smears performed before and after training (76% vs 82%, P = .36). Likewise, smear cellularity (≥50% target cells) before and after training did not differ (44% (30/68) vs 49% (35/71), P = .48). Similar, no difference in diagnostic accuracy for malignancy was detected (P = .10). CONCLUSION: In this pilot EUS‐FNA smear‐preparation‐training for endoscopy personnel, smear quality and diagnostic accuracy were not improved after the training. Based on these results, we plan to further study other training programs and possibilities. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7820998 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2020 |
publisher | John Wiley & Sons, Inc. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-78209982021-01-26 Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy van Riet, Priscilla A. Quispel, Rutger Cahen, Djuna L. Erler, Nicole S. Snijders‐Kruisbergen, Mieke C. Van Loenen, Petri Poley, Jan‐Werner van Driel, Lydi M.J.W. Mulder, Sanna A. Veldt, Bart J. Leeuwenburgh, Ivonne Anten, Marie‐Paule G.F. Honkoop, Pieter Thijssen, Annemieke Y. Hol, Lieke Hadithi, Mohammed Fitzpatrick, Claire E. Schot, Ingrid Bergmann, Jilling F. Bhalla, Abha Bruno, Marco J. Biermann, Katharina Diagn Cytopathol Original Articles BACKGROUND: In the absence of rapid on‐side pathological evaluation, endoscopy staff generally “smears” endoscopic ultrasound guided fine needle aspiration (EUS‐FNA) specimens on a glass slide. As this technique is vulnerable to preparation artifacts, we assessed if its quality could be improved through a smear‐preparation‐training for endoscopy staff. METHODS: In this prospective pilot study, 10 endosonographers and 12 endoscopy nurses from seven regional EUS‐centers in the Netherlands were invited to participate in a EUS‐FNA smear‐preparation‐training. Subsequently, post training slides derived from solid pancreatic lesions were compared to pre‐training “control” slides. Primary outcome was to assess if the training positively affects smear quality and, consequently, diagnostic accuracy of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions. RESULTS: Participants collected and prepared 71 cases, mostly pancreatic head lesions (48%). Sixty‐eight controls were selected from the pretraining period. The presence of artifacts was comparable for smears performed before and after training (76% vs 82%, P = .36). Likewise, smear cellularity (≥50% target cells) before and after training did not differ (44% (30/68) vs 49% (35/71), P = .48). Similar, no difference in diagnostic accuracy for malignancy was detected (P = .10). CONCLUSION: In this pilot EUS‐FNA smear‐preparation‐training for endoscopy personnel, smear quality and diagnostic accuracy were not improved after the training. Based on these results, we plan to further study other training programs and possibilities. John Wiley & Sons, Inc. 2020-10-24 2021-02 /pmc/articles/PMC7820998/ /pubmed/33098625 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/dc.24645 Text en © 2020 The Authors. Diagnostic Cytopathology published by Wiley Periodicals LLC. This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made. |
spellingShingle | Original Articles van Riet, Priscilla A. Quispel, Rutger Cahen, Djuna L. Erler, Nicole S. Snijders‐Kruisbergen, Mieke C. Van Loenen, Petri Poley, Jan‐Werner van Driel, Lydi M.J.W. Mulder, Sanna A. Veldt, Bart J. Leeuwenburgh, Ivonne Anten, Marie‐Paule G.F. Honkoop, Pieter Thijssen, Annemieke Y. Hol, Lieke Hadithi, Mohammed Fitzpatrick, Claire E. Schot, Ingrid Bergmann, Jilling F. Bhalla, Abha Bruno, Marco J. Biermann, Katharina Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title | Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title_full | Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title_fullStr | Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title_full_unstemmed | Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title_short | Optimizing cytological specimens of EUS‐FNA of solid pancreatic lesions: A pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
title_sort | optimizing cytological specimens of eus‐fna of solid pancreatic lesions: a pilot study to the effect of a smear preparation training for endoscopy personnel on sample quality and accuracy |
topic | Original Articles |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7820998/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33098625 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/dc.24645 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT vanrietpriscillaa optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT quispelrutger optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT cahendjunal optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT erlernicoles optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT snijderskruisbergenmiekec optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT vanloenenpetri optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT poleyjanwerner optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT vandriellydimjw optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT muldersannaa optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT veldtbartj optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT leeuwenburghivonne optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT antenmariepaulegf optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT honkooppieter optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT thijssenannemiekey optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT hollieke optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT hadithimohammed optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT fitzpatrickclairee optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT schotingrid optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT bergmannjillingf optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT bhallaabha optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT brunomarcoj optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy AT biermannkatharina optimizingcytologicalspecimensofeusfnaofsolidpancreaticlesionsapilotstudytotheeffectofasmearpreparationtrainingforendoscopypersonnelonsamplequalityandaccuracy |