Methyl Benzoate Is Superior to Other Natural Fumigants for Controlling the Indian Meal Moth (Plodia interpunctella)

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Globally, the Indian meal moth is an insect pest of stored goods and manufactured foodstuffs. Synthetic fumigants, such as phosphine and methyl bromide, are widely used agents to control this species. However, due to the development of resistance and increasing concern about the potential adverse effects of synthetic fumigants, it is now necessary to identify environmentally friendly alternatives. Naturally occurring compounds, such as essential oils (EOs), are perhaps the most promising alternative sources; many have been successfully used as active ingredients in contact-based control products, repellents, and fumigants. Methyl benzoate (MBe) is an environmentally friendly, food-safe, natural insecticide that offers a possible alternative to synthetic equivalents. Here, we evaluated the fumigant toxicity of MBe against adults of the Indian meal moth and found that it had great potential for the control of these insect pests in stored products. ABSTRACT: The Indian meal moth, Plodia interpunctella (Hübner) (Lepidoptera: Pyralidae), is an insect pest that commonly affects stored and postharvest agricultural products. For the control of insect pests and mites, methyl benzoate (MBe) is lethal as a fumigant and also causes contact toxicity; although it has already been established as a food-safe natural product, the fumigation toxicity of MBe has yet to be demonstrated in P. interpunctella. Herein, we evaluated MBe as a potential fumigant for controlling adults of P. interpunctella in two bioassays. Compared to the monoterpenes examined under laboratory conditions, MBe demonstrated high fumigant activity using a 1-L glass bottle at 1 μL/L air within 4 h of exposure. The median lethal concentration (LC(50)) of MBe was 0.1 μL/L air; the median lethal time (LT(50)) of MBe at 0.1, 0.3, 0.5, and 1 μL/L air was 3.8, 3.3, 2.8, and 2.0 h, respectively. Compared with commercially available monoterpene compounds used in pest control, MBe showed the highest fumigant toxicity (toxicity order as follows): MBe > citronellal > linalool > 1,8 cineole > limonene. Moreover, in a larger space assay, MBe caused 100% mortality of P. interpunctella at 0.01 μL/cm(3) of air after 24 h of exposure. Therefore, MBe can be recommended for use in food security programs as an ecofriendly alternative fumigant. Specifically, it provides another management tool for curtailing the loss of stored food commodities due to P. interpunctella infestation.