Cargando…
A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System
PURPOSE: Frequency of conventional kV-image guidance is sometimes sacrificed to reduce concomitant risk, leaving deviations of unguided fractions unknown. MV-imaging and treatment dose can be collectively optimized on Halcyon, where fractional MVCBCT provides complete anatomic records for course-wid...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Frontiers Media S.A.
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7871016/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33575205 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.543147 |
_version_ | 1783648928997048320 |
---|---|
author | Wang, Haiyang Huang, Yuliang Hu, Qiaoqiao Li, Chenguang Liu, Hongjia Wang, Xuejuan Li, Weibo Ma, Wenjun Pu, Yichen Du, Yixiao Wu, Hao Zhang, Yibao |
author_facet | Wang, Haiyang Huang, Yuliang Hu, Qiaoqiao Li, Chenguang Liu, Hongjia Wang, Xuejuan Li, Weibo Ma, Wenjun Pu, Yichen Du, Yixiao Wu, Hao Zhang, Yibao |
author_sort | Wang, Haiyang |
collection | PubMed |
description | PURPOSE: Frequency of conventional kV-image guidance is sometimes sacrificed to reduce concomitant risk, leaving deviations of unguided fractions unknown. MV-imaging and treatment dose can be collectively optimized on Halcyon, where fractional MVCBCT provides complete anatomic records for course-wide dose reconstruction. By retrospective dose accumulation, this work simulated the impact of imaging frequency on patient treatment dose on the platform of Halcyon. METHODS: Four hundred and sixteen MVCBCT image sets from 16 patients of various tumor sites treated with radiotherapy on Halcyon were retrospectively selected. After applying the image-guided couch shifts of the clinical records, deformable image registration was performed using Velocity software, to deform the planning CTs to the corresponding MVCBCTs, generating pseudo CTs representing the actual anatomies on the treatment day. Fractional treatment dose was reconstructed on pseudo CTs for accumulation, representing the actual patient dose (D(daily)). To simulate weekly image guidance, fractional dose was reconstructed and accumulated by incorporating 1 CBCT-guided corrections and 4 laser-guided setups of each week (D(weekly)). Limited by partially imaged volumes and different organs-at-risk of various sites, only target dose-volume parameters were evaluated across all patients. RESULTS: GTV_D98%, CTV_D98%, PTV_D90%, PTV_D95%, PGTV_D90%, and PGTV_D95% were evaluated, where Dx% means the minimal dose received by x% volume. Pairwise comparisons were made between plan dose and D(daily), D(daily) and D(weekly) respectively. PGTV_D(95%) of accumulated D(weekly) were significantly lower than those of accumulated D(daily) by up to 32.90% of prescription dose, suggesting that weekly-guidance may result in unacceptable under dose to the target. The broad distribution of fractional differences between D(daily) and D(weekly) suggested unreliable patient positioning based on aligning surface markers to laser beams, as a popular approach broadly used on conventional Linac systems. Slight target under-dose was observed on daily reconstructed results compared with planned dose, which provided quantitative data to guide clinical decisions such as the necessity of adaptive radiotherapy. CONCLUSION: Fractional image guided radiotherapy on Halcyon provides more reliable treatment accuracy than using sacrificed imaging frequency, which also provides complete anatomic records for deformable dose reconstruction supporting more informed clinical decisions. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-7871016 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Frontiers Media S.A. |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-78710162021-02-10 A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System Wang, Haiyang Huang, Yuliang Hu, Qiaoqiao Li, Chenguang Liu, Hongjia Wang, Xuejuan Li, Weibo Ma, Wenjun Pu, Yichen Du, Yixiao Wu, Hao Zhang, Yibao Front Oncol Oncology PURPOSE: Frequency of conventional kV-image guidance is sometimes sacrificed to reduce concomitant risk, leaving deviations of unguided fractions unknown. MV-imaging and treatment dose can be collectively optimized on Halcyon, where fractional MVCBCT provides complete anatomic records for course-wide dose reconstruction. By retrospective dose accumulation, this work simulated the impact of imaging frequency on patient treatment dose on the platform of Halcyon. METHODS: Four hundred and sixteen MVCBCT image sets from 16 patients of various tumor sites treated with radiotherapy on Halcyon were retrospectively selected. After applying the image-guided couch shifts of the clinical records, deformable image registration was performed using Velocity software, to deform the planning CTs to the corresponding MVCBCTs, generating pseudo CTs representing the actual anatomies on the treatment day. Fractional treatment dose was reconstructed on pseudo CTs for accumulation, representing the actual patient dose (D(daily)). To simulate weekly image guidance, fractional dose was reconstructed and accumulated by incorporating 1 CBCT-guided corrections and 4 laser-guided setups of each week (D(weekly)). Limited by partially imaged volumes and different organs-at-risk of various sites, only target dose-volume parameters were evaluated across all patients. RESULTS: GTV_D98%, CTV_D98%, PTV_D90%, PTV_D95%, PGTV_D90%, and PGTV_D95% were evaluated, where Dx% means the minimal dose received by x% volume. Pairwise comparisons were made between plan dose and D(daily), D(daily) and D(weekly) respectively. PGTV_D(95%) of accumulated D(weekly) were significantly lower than those of accumulated D(daily) by up to 32.90% of prescription dose, suggesting that weekly-guidance may result in unacceptable under dose to the target. The broad distribution of fractional differences between D(daily) and D(weekly) suggested unreliable patient positioning based on aligning surface markers to laser beams, as a popular approach broadly used on conventional Linac systems. Slight target under-dose was observed on daily reconstructed results compared with planned dose, which provided quantitative data to guide clinical decisions such as the necessity of adaptive radiotherapy. CONCLUSION: Fractional image guided radiotherapy on Halcyon provides more reliable treatment accuracy than using sacrificed imaging frequency, which also provides complete anatomic records for deformable dose reconstruction supporting more informed clinical decisions. Frontiers Media S.A. 2021-01-25 /pmc/articles/PMC7871016/ /pubmed/33575205 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.543147 Text en Copyright © 2021 Wang, Huang, Hu, Li, Liu, Wang, Li, Ma, Pu, Du, Wu and Zhang http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (CC BY). The use, distribution or reproduction in other forums is permitted, provided the original author(s) and the copyright owner(s) are credited and that the original publication in this journal is cited, in accordance with accepted academic practice. No use, distribution or reproduction is permitted which does not comply with these terms. |
spellingShingle | Oncology Wang, Haiyang Huang, Yuliang Hu, Qiaoqiao Li, Chenguang Liu, Hongjia Wang, Xuejuan Li, Weibo Ma, Wenjun Pu, Yichen Du, Yixiao Wu, Hao Zhang, Yibao A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title | A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title_full | A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title_fullStr | A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title_full_unstemmed | A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title_short | A Simulated Dosimetric Study of Contribution to Radiotherapy Accuracy by Fractional Image Guidance Protocol of Halcyon System |
title_sort | simulated dosimetric study of contribution to radiotherapy accuracy by fractional image guidance protocol of halcyon system |
topic | Oncology |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7871016/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33575205 http://dx.doi.org/10.3389/fonc.2020.543147 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT wanghaiyang asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT huangyuliang asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT huqiaoqiao asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT lichenguang asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT liuhongjia asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT wangxuejuan asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT liweibo asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT mawenjun asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT puyichen asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT duyixiao asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT wuhao asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT zhangyibao asimulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT wanghaiyang simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT huangyuliang simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT huqiaoqiao simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT lichenguang simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT liuhongjia simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT wangxuejuan simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT liweibo simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT mawenjun simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT puyichen simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT duyixiao simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT wuhao simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem AT zhangyibao simulateddosimetricstudyofcontributiontoradiotherapyaccuracybyfractionalimageguidanceprotocolofhalcyonsystem |