Pine Looper Bupalus piniaria (L.) Outbreaks Reconstruction: A Case Study for Southern Siberia

SIMPLE SUMMARY: The pine looper damages Scots pine forests over vast areas. However, the study of its population fluctuations is hampered by the lack of long-term observation series. The dendrochronological reconstruction is often used to study the history of its outbreaks. In some cases, such reconstructions require methods that work without comparison with other tree species. We have proposed such a technique based on the analysis of the early- and latewood growth. The technique makes it possible to separate the effect of defoliation on tree rings from weather influence. Besides, it is more sensitive than previously developed methods when reconstructing outbreaks of the pine looper. The history of outbreaks reconstructed by the technique for the West Siberian Plain’s forest-steppe includes 11 defoliation events from 1914 to 2017. The results obtained using the developed method are useful to better understand the patterns of population dynamics of the pine looper and other phyllophagous pests. ABSTRACT: The pine looper Bupalus piniaria is one of the most widespread phyllophagous insect species across Northern Eurasia, defoliating Scots pine forests over vast territories. Since there are not enough long-term documented observations on a series of outbreaks, there is a need for methods allowing them to be reconstructed to study their dynamics patterns. Previously, dendrochronological methods were successfully used to solve such issues. However, the most common approach is not applicable for the Western Siberian forest-steppe since it requires comparison with a non-damaged tree species close to pine in terms of longevity and resistance to rot. In the pine forests of the steppe and forest-steppe zones of Western Siberia, there are no species that are not damaged by the pine looper that meets these requirements. Methods allowing not using control species are also not free from disadvantages (e.g., weak specificity). Therefore, we have developed a new method based on the analysis, not of the tree-ring width but the early- and latewood width to reconstruct past defoliation events. The past defoliation by the pine looper is indicated by the presence of a negative pointer year for latewood, followed by a negative pointer year for earlywood in a subsequent year among the majority of individuals. Linear modeling showed a difference between the climate impact on radial growth and the defoliation one. The obtained reconstruction was compared with the results of other methods (mowing window, OUTBREAK, independent component analysis), literature, and Forest Service data. The developed new method (pointer year method; PYM) showed high efficiency confirmed by results of the tree-ring series analysis (11 revealed outbreaks in the past). Compared with other reconstruction techniques under the given conditions (a favorable combination of heat and humidity; probably low-intense and short defoliation), the proposed method provided more precise results than those proposed earlier. Due to high accuracy, the PYM can be useful for detecting late-summer and autumn past defoliations of tree species with clear difference between early- and latewood even though the damage was weak.