Cargando…

The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems

AIMS: This study aimed to analyse community management of patients during the symptomatic period prior to admission with acute decompensated heart failure (ADHF). METHODS AND RESULTS: We conducted a prospective, two‐centre, two‐country observational study evaluating care pathways and patient experie...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: McCambridge, Joseph, Keane, Ciara, Walshe, Myra, Campbell, Patricia, Heyes, James, Kalra, Paul R., Cowie, Martin R., Riley, Jillian P., O'Hanlon, Rory, Ledwidge, Mark, Gallagher, Joseph, McDonald, Kenneth
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8006706/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33369196
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ehf2.13089
_version_ 1783672360638873600
author McCambridge, Joseph
Keane, Ciara
Walshe, Myra
Campbell, Patricia
Heyes, James
Kalra, Paul R.
Cowie, Martin R.
Riley, Jillian P.
O'Hanlon, Rory
Ledwidge, Mark
Gallagher, Joseph
McDonald, Kenneth
author_facet McCambridge, Joseph
Keane, Ciara
Walshe, Myra
Campbell, Patricia
Heyes, James
Kalra, Paul R.
Cowie, Martin R.
Riley, Jillian P.
O'Hanlon, Rory
Ledwidge, Mark
Gallagher, Joseph
McDonald, Kenneth
author_sort McCambridge, Joseph
collection PubMed
description AIMS: This study aimed to analyse community management of patients during the symptomatic period prior to admission with acute decompensated heart failure (ADHF). METHODS AND RESULTS: We conducted a prospective, two‐centre, two‐country observational study evaluating care pathways and patient experience in patients admitted to hospital with ADHF. Quantitative and qualitative data were gathered from patients, carers, and general practitioners (GPs). From the Irish centre, 114 patients enrolled, and from the English centre, 50 patients. Symptom duration longer than 72 h prior to hospitalization was noted among 70.4% (76) Irish and 80% (40) English patients, with no significant difference between those with a new diagnosis of HF [de novo HF (dnHF)] and those with known HF [established HF (eHF)] in either cohort. For the majority, dyspnoea was the dominant symptom; however, 63.3% (31) of these Irish patients and 47.2% (17) of these English patients did not recognize this as an HF symptom, with no significant difference between dnHF and eHF patients. Of the 46.5% (53) of Irish and 38% (19) of English patients reviewed exclusively by GPs before hospitalization, numbers prescribed diuretics were low (11.3%, six; and 15.8%, three, respectively); eHF patients were no more likely to receive diuretics than dnHF patients. Barriers to care highlighted by GPs included inadequate access to basic diagnostics, specialist support and up‐to‐date patient information, and lack of GP comfort in managing HF. CONCLUSION: The aforementioned findings, consistent across both health care jurisdictions, show a clear potential to intervene earlier and more effectively in ADHF or to prevent the need for hospitalization.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8006706
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher John Wiley and Sons Inc.
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-80067062021-04-01 The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems McCambridge, Joseph Keane, Ciara Walshe, Myra Campbell, Patricia Heyes, James Kalra, Paul R. Cowie, Martin R. Riley, Jillian P. O'Hanlon, Rory Ledwidge, Mark Gallagher, Joseph McDonald, Kenneth ESC Heart Fail Original Research Articles AIMS: This study aimed to analyse community management of patients during the symptomatic period prior to admission with acute decompensated heart failure (ADHF). METHODS AND RESULTS: We conducted a prospective, two‐centre, two‐country observational study evaluating care pathways and patient experience in patients admitted to hospital with ADHF. Quantitative and qualitative data were gathered from patients, carers, and general practitioners (GPs). From the Irish centre, 114 patients enrolled, and from the English centre, 50 patients. Symptom duration longer than 72 h prior to hospitalization was noted among 70.4% (76) Irish and 80% (40) English patients, with no significant difference between those with a new diagnosis of HF [de novo HF (dnHF)] and those with known HF [established HF (eHF)] in either cohort. For the majority, dyspnoea was the dominant symptom; however, 63.3% (31) of these Irish patients and 47.2% (17) of these English patients did not recognize this as an HF symptom, with no significant difference between dnHF and eHF patients. Of the 46.5% (53) of Irish and 38% (19) of English patients reviewed exclusively by GPs before hospitalization, numbers prescribed diuretics were low (11.3%, six; and 15.8%, three, respectively); eHF patients were no more likely to receive diuretics than dnHF patients. Barriers to care highlighted by GPs included inadequate access to basic diagnostics, specialist support and up‐to‐date patient information, and lack of GP comfort in managing HF. CONCLUSION: The aforementioned findings, consistent across both health care jurisdictions, show a clear potential to intervene earlier and more effectively in ADHF or to prevent the need for hospitalization. John Wiley and Sons Inc. 2020-12-24 /pmc/articles/PMC8006706/ /pubmed/33369196 http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ehf2.13089 Text en © 2020 The Authors. ESC Heart Failure published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of European Society of Cardiology This is an open access article under the terms of the http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/4.0/ License, which permits use and distribution in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited, the use is non‐commercial and no modifications or adaptations are made.
spellingShingle Original Research Articles
McCambridge, Joseph
Keane, Ciara
Walshe, Myra
Campbell, Patricia
Heyes, James
Kalra, Paul R.
Cowie, Martin R.
Riley, Jillian P.
O'Hanlon, Rory
Ledwidge, Mark
Gallagher, Joseph
McDonald, Kenneth
The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title_full The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title_fullStr The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title_full_unstemmed The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title_short The prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
title_sort prehospital patient pathway and experience of care with acute heart failure: a comparison of two health care systems
topic Original Research Articles
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8006706/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33369196
http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/ehf2.13089
work_keys_str_mv AT mccambridgejoseph theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT keaneciara theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT walshemyra theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT campbellpatricia theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT heyesjames theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT kalrapaulr theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT cowiemartinr theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT rileyjillianp theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT ohanlonrory theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT ledwidgemark theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT gallagherjoseph theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT mcdonaldkenneth theprehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT mccambridgejoseph prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT keaneciara prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT walshemyra prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT campbellpatricia prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT heyesjames prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT kalrapaulr prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT cowiemartinr prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT rileyjillianp prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT ohanlonrory prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT ledwidgemark prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT gallagherjoseph prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems
AT mcdonaldkenneth prehospitalpatientpathwayandexperienceofcarewithacuteheartfailureacomparisonoftwohealthcaresystems