Neoadjuvant Chemotherapy and Whole Ventricular Irradiation for Pure Intracranial Germinoma: A Comparison of Three Brain-Sparing Techniques

Objective To quantitate and compare the dosimetric properties of three brain-sparing radiation therapy techniques for pure intracranial germinomas with dose-volume analysis of target and normal brain structures. Methods We identified 18 patients with central nervous system (CNS) germinoma who had achieved local control and had excellent neurocognitive outcomes. Four patients who were treated with a simultaneous integrated boost (SIB) plan of 22.5Gy to whole ventricle (WV) and 30Gy to primary were re-planned with 24Gy to WV-only and the Children’s Oncology Group (COG) protocol of 18Gy to WV with a sequential boost to 30Gy. Organ-at-risk (OAR) doses for hippocampi, temporal lobes, whole brain, whole brain minus whole ventricles planning target volume (WB-WVPTV), WVPTV, and boost volume were comparatively studied. Results For patients treated with the SIB plan, an excellent neurocognitive function has previously been shown to be well preserved. Three-year event-free survival (EFS) and overall survival (OS) for this group have also previously been demonstrated (89.5% and 100%, respectively). Mean and integral OAR doses were comparable between SIB and WV-only plans but were lower for COG plans. Whole brain, whole brain minus WVPTV, and temporal lobe V20, V18, and V12, as well as hippocampi V20, V25, and V30, were comparable between SIB and WV-only plans but were lower for the COG plans. Conclusion Compared to the WV-only method, the SIB plan permits more dose to the primary site by 6 Gy without compromising neurocognitive control. While maintaining the 30Gy boost, the COG protocol reduces the WVPTV dose to 18Gy. It remains to be seen whether WV dose reduction risks reducing local control.