Cargando…

Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy

This study examined the factors that inhibit the therapeutic effects of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and clarify the adaptation judgment criteria of CBT. We included patients with chronic low back pain and allocated them to the adaptation (with visual analog scale [VAS] improvement) or non-ada...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Shimizu, Keisuke, Inage, Kazuhide, Orita, Sumihisa, Eguchi, Yawara, Shiga, Yasuhiro, Koda, Masao, Aoki, Yasuchika, Kotani, Toshiaki, Akazawa, Tsutomu, Furuya, Takeo, Nakamura, Junichi, Takahashi, Hiroshi, Suzuki-Narita, Miyako, Maki, Satoshi, Hagiwara, Shigeo, Inoue, Masahiro, Norimoto, Masaki, Kinoshita, Hideyuki, Sato, Takashi, Sato, Masashi, Enomoto, Keigo, Takaoka, Hiromitsu, Mizuki, Norichika, Hozumi, Takashi, Tsuchiya, Ryuto, Kim, Geundong, Otagiri, Takuma, Mukaihata, Tomohito, Hishiya, Takahisa, Ohtori, Seiji
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nature Publishing Group UK 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8050286/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33859240
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-87239-2
_version_ 1783679569399644160
author Shimizu, Keisuke
Inage, Kazuhide
Orita, Sumihisa
Eguchi, Yawara
Shiga, Yasuhiro
Koda, Masao
Aoki, Yasuchika
Kotani, Toshiaki
Akazawa, Tsutomu
Furuya, Takeo
Nakamura, Junichi
Takahashi, Hiroshi
Suzuki-Narita, Miyako
Maki, Satoshi
Hagiwara, Shigeo
Inoue, Masahiro
Norimoto, Masaki
Kinoshita, Hideyuki
Sato, Takashi
Sato, Masashi
Enomoto, Keigo
Takaoka, Hiromitsu
Mizuki, Norichika
Hozumi, Takashi
Tsuchiya, Ryuto
Kim, Geundong
Otagiri, Takuma
Mukaihata, Tomohito
Hishiya, Takahisa
Ohtori, Seiji
author_facet Shimizu, Keisuke
Inage, Kazuhide
Orita, Sumihisa
Eguchi, Yawara
Shiga, Yasuhiro
Koda, Masao
Aoki, Yasuchika
Kotani, Toshiaki
Akazawa, Tsutomu
Furuya, Takeo
Nakamura, Junichi
Takahashi, Hiroshi
Suzuki-Narita, Miyako
Maki, Satoshi
Hagiwara, Shigeo
Inoue, Masahiro
Norimoto, Masaki
Kinoshita, Hideyuki
Sato, Takashi
Sato, Masashi
Enomoto, Keigo
Takaoka, Hiromitsu
Mizuki, Norichika
Hozumi, Takashi
Tsuchiya, Ryuto
Kim, Geundong
Otagiri, Takuma
Mukaihata, Tomohito
Hishiya, Takahisa
Ohtori, Seiji
author_sort Shimizu, Keisuke
collection PubMed
description This study examined the factors that inhibit the therapeutic effects of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and clarify the adaptation judgment criteria of CBT. We included patients with chronic low back pain and allocated them to the adaptation (with visual analog scale [VAS] improvement) or non-adaptation group (without VAS improvement). The patients were analyzed using various psychological tests. CBT improved depressive symptoms and catastrophic thinking; however, they were not correlated with the VAS and did not directly affect low back pain improvement. The non-adaptation group showed an unexplainable/vague sense of anxiety; an excessive focus on searching for pain; a strong intimacy desire; a strong tendency of medical dependency; and fantasy or distortion of the actual experience, especially self-image. Moreover, the patients showed a low ability to objectively express or attribute meaning to pain due to poor language skills, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, and emotional value judgment. Individuals with the aforementioned characteristics of pre-CBT psychological tests should select a different treatment approach given the high poor-adaption possibility. Even patients with depressive or anxious symptoms are not necessarily adaptable for CBT. Therefore, pre-CBT tests for treatment suitability are necessary. Future studies should establish a protocol for psychotherapy suitable for the non-adaptation group.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8050286
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Nature Publishing Group UK
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-80502862021-04-16 Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy Shimizu, Keisuke Inage, Kazuhide Orita, Sumihisa Eguchi, Yawara Shiga, Yasuhiro Koda, Masao Aoki, Yasuchika Kotani, Toshiaki Akazawa, Tsutomu Furuya, Takeo Nakamura, Junichi Takahashi, Hiroshi Suzuki-Narita, Miyako Maki, Satoshi Hagiwara, Shigeo Inoue, Masahiro Norimoto, Masaki Kinoshita, Hideyuki Sato, Takashi Sato, Masashi Enomoto, Keigo Takaoka, Hiromitsu Mizuki, Norichika Hozumi, Takashi Tsuchiya, Ryuto Kim, Geundong Otagiri, Takuma Mukaihata, Tomohito Hishiya, Takahisa Ohtori, Seiji Sci Rep Article This study examined the factors that inhibit the therapeutic effects of cognitive behavioral therapy (CBT) and clarify the adaptation judgment criteria of CBT. We included patients with chronic low back pain and allocated them to the adaptation (with visual analog scale [VAS] improvement) or non-adaptation group (without VAS improvement). The patients were analyzed using various psychological tests. CBT improved depressive symptoms and catastrophic thinking; however, they were not correlated with the VAS and did not directly affect low back pain improvement. The non-adaptation group showed an unexplainable/vague sense of anxiety; an excessive focus on searching for pain; a strong intimacy desire; a strong tendency of medical dependency; and fantasy or distortion of the actual experience, especially self-image. Moreover, the patients showed a low ability to objectively express or attribute meaning to pain due to poor language skills, attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder, and emotional value judgment. Individuals with the aforementioned characteristics of pre-CBT psychological tests should select a different treatment approach given the high poor-adaption possibility. Even patients with depressive or anxious symptoms are not necessarily adaptable for CBT. Therefore, pre-CBT tests for treatment suitability are necessary. Future studies should establish a protocol for psychotherapy suitable for the non-adaptation group. Nature Publishing Group UK 2021-04-15 /pmc/articles/PMC8050286/ /pubmed/33859240 http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-87239-2 Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open Access This article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) .
spellingShingle Article
Shimizu, Keisuke
Inage, Kazuhide
Orita, Sumihisa
Eguchi, Yawara
Shiga, Yasuhiro
Koda, Masao
Aoki, Yasuchika
Kotani, Toshiaki
Akazawa, Tsutomu
Furuya, Takeo
Nakamura, Junichi
Takahashi, Hiroshi
Suzuki-Narita, Miyako
Maki, Satoshi
Hagiwara, Shigeo
Inoue, Masahiro
Norimoto, Masaki
Kinoshita, Hideyuki
Sato, Takashi
Sato, Masashi
Enomoto, Keigo
Takaoka, Hiromitsu
Mizuki, Norichika
Hozumi, Takashi
Tsuchiya, Ryuto
Kim, Geundong
Otagiri, Takuma
Mukaihata, Tomohito
Hishiya, Takahisa
Ohtori, Seiji
Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title_full Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title_fullStr Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title_full_unstemmed Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title_short Background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
title_sort background factors for chronic low back pain resistant to cognitive behavioral therapy
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8050286/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33859240
http://dx.doi.org/10.1038/s41598-021-87239-2
work_keys_str_mv AT shimizukeisuke backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT inagekazuhide backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT oritasumihisa backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT eguchiyawara backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT shigayasuhiro backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT kodamasao backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT aokiyasuchika backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT kotanitoshiaki backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT akazawatsutomu backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT furuyatakeo backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT nakamurajunichi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT takahashihiroshi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT suzukinaritamiyako backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT makisatoshi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT hagiwarashigeo backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT inouemasahiro backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT norimotomasaki backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT kinoshitahideyuki backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT satotakashi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT satomasashi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT enomotokeigo backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT takaokahiromitsu backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT mizukinorichika backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT hozumitakashi backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT tsuchiyaryuto backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT kimgeundong backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT otagiritakuma backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT mukaihatatomohito backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT hishiyatakahisa backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy
AT ohtoriseiji backgroundfactorsforchroniclowbackpainresistanttocognitivebehavioraltherapy