Cargando…
The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations
Single brain enhancing lesions (SEL) are the most common presentation of neurocysticercosis (NCC) observed on neuroimaging in people presenting with epileptic seizures not only on the Indian sub-continent and in travelers returning from cysticercosis-endemic regions, but are also present in other pa...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Public Library of Science
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8057605/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33788843 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009193 |
_version_ | 1783680870458064896 |
---|---|
author | Abraham, Annette Bustos, Javier A. Carabin, Hélène de Meijere, Robert Sahu, Priyadarshi S. Rajshekhar, Vedantam Singh, Gagandeep White, A. Clinton Chiodini, Peter L. Gabriël, Sarah Homeida, Mamoun Nash, Theodore Ngowi, Bernard Zhou, Xiao Nong Coyle, Christina Garcia, Hector H. Winkler, Andrea S. |
author_facet | Abraham, Annette Bustos, Javier A. Carabin, Hélène de Meijere, Robert Sahu, Priyadarshi S. Rajshekhar, Vedantam Singh, Gagandeep White, A. Clinton Chiodini, Peter L. Gabriël, Sarah Homeida, Mamoun Nash, Theodore Ngowi, Bernard Zhou, Xiao Nong Coyle, Christina Garcia, Hector H. Winkler, Andrea S. |
author_sort | Abraham, Annette |
collection | PubMed |
description | Single brain enhancing lesions (SEL) are the most common presentation of neurocysticercosis (NCC) observed on neuroimaging in people presenting with epileptic seizures not only on the Indian sub-continent and in travelers returning from cysticercosis-endemic regions, but are also present in other parts of the world. The aim of this study, which consisted of a systematic review (CRD42019087665), a meta-analysis and an expert group consultation, was to reach consensus on the best anti-seizure medication and anti-inflammatory treatment for individuals with SEL NCC. Standard literature review methods were used. The Cochrane risk of bias tool was used and random effects model meta-analyses were performed. The quality of the body of evidence was rated using GRADE tables. The expert committee included 12 gender and geographically balanced members and recommendations were reached by applying the GRADE framework for guideline development. The 1–1.5-year cumulative incidence of seizure recurrence, cyst resolution or calcification following anti-seizure medication (ASM) withdrawal was not statistically different between ASM of 6, 12 or 24 months. In contrast, in persons whose cyst calcified post treatment, longer ASM decreased seizure recurrence. The cumulative incidence ratio (CIR) 1–1.5 years after stopping ASM was 1.79 95% CI: (1.00, 3.20) for patients given 6 versus 24 months treatment. Anti-inflammatory treatment with corticosteroids in patients treated with ASM compared to patients treated with ASM only showed a statistically significant beneficial effect on seizure reduction (CIR 0.44, 95% CI 0.23, 0.85) and cyst resolution (CIR 1.37, 95%CI: 1.07, 1.75). Our results indicate that ASM in patients with SEL NCC whose cysts resolved can be withdrawn, while patients whose cysts calcified seem to benefit from prolonged anti-seizure medication. Additional corticosteroid treatment was found to have a beneficial effect both on seizure reduction and cyst resolution. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8057605 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Public Library of Science |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-80576052021-05-04 The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations Abraham, Annette Bustos, Javier A. Carabin, Hélène de Meijere, Robert Sahu, Priyadarshi S. Rajshekhar, Vedantam Singh, Gagandeep White, A. Clinton Chiodini, Peter L. Gabriël, Sarah Homeida, Mamoun Nash, Theodore Ngowi, Bernard Zhou, Xiao Nong Coyle, Christina Garcia, Hector H. Winkler, Andrea S. PLoS Negl Trop Dis Research Article Single brain enhancing lesions (SEL) are the most common presentation of neurocysticercosis (NCC) observed on neuroimaging in people presenting with epileptic seizures not only on the Indian sub-continent and in travelers returning from cysticercosis-endemic regions, but are also present in other parts of the world. The aim of this study, which consisted of a systematic review (CRD42019087665), a meta-analysis and an expert group consultation, was to reach consensus on the best anti-seizure medication and anti-inflammatory treatment for individuals with SEL NCC. Standard literature review methods were used. The Cochrane risk of bias tool was used and random effects model meta-analyses were performed. The quality of the body of evidence was rated using GRADE tables. The expert committee included 12 gender and geographically balanced members and recommendations were reached by applying the GRADE framework for guideline development. The 1–1.5-year cumulative incidence of seizure recurrence, cyst resolution or calcification following anti-seizure medication (ASM) withdrawal was not statistically different between ASM of 6, 12 or 24 months. In contrast, in persons whose cyst calcified post treatment, longer ASM decreased seizure recurrence. The cumulative incidence ratio (CIR) 1–1.5 years after stopping ASM was 1.79 95% CI: (1.00, 3.20) for patients given 6 versus 24 months treatment. Anti-inflammatory treatment with corticosteroids in patients treated with ASM compared to patients treated with ASM only showed a statistically significant beneficial effect on seizure reduction (CIR 0.44, 95% CI 0.23, 0.85) and cyst resolution (CIR 1.37, 95%CI: 1.07, 1.75). Our results indicate that ASM in patients with SEL NCC whose cysts resolved can be withdrawn, while patients whose cysts calcified seem to benefit from prolonged anti-seizure medication. Additional corticosteroid treatment was found to have a beneficial effect both on seizure reduction and cyst resolution. Public Library of Science 2021-03-31 /pmc/articles/PMC8057605/ /pubmed/33788843 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009193 Text en © 2021 Abraham et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. |
spellingShingle | Research Article Abraham, Annette Bustos, Javier A. Carabin, Hélène de Meijere, Robert Sahu, Priyadarshi S. Rajshekhar, Vedantam Singh, Gagandeep White, A. Clinton Chiodini, Peter L. Gabriël, Sarah Homeida, Mamoun Nash, Theodore Ngowi, Bernard Zhou, Xiao Nong Coyle, Christina Garcia, Hector H. Winkler, Andrea S. The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title | The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title_full | The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title_fullStr | The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title_full_unstemmed | The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title_short | The effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: A meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
title_sort | effectiveness of anti-inflammatory and anti-seizure medication for individuals with single enhancing lesion neurocysticercosis: a meta-analysis and expert group-based consensus recommendations |
topic | Research Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8057605/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33788843 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pntd.0009193 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT abrahamannette theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT bustosjaviera theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT carabinhelene theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT demeijererobert theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT sahupriyadarshis theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT rajshekharvedantam theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT singhgagandeep theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT whiteaclinton theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT chiodinipeterl theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT gabrielsarah theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT homeidamamoun theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT nashtheodore theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT ngowibernard theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT zhouxiaonong theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT coylechristina theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT garciahectorh theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT winklerandreas theeffectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT abrahamannette effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT bustosjaviera effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT carabinhelene effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT demeijererobert effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT sahupriyadarshis effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT rajshekharvedantam effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT singhgagandeep effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT whiteaclinton effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT chiodinipeterl effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT gabrielsarah effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT homeidamamoun effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT nashtheodore effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT ngowibernard effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT zhouxiaonong effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT coylechristina effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT garciahectorh effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations AT winklerandreas effectivenessofantiinflammatoryandantiseizuremedicationforindividualswithsingleenhancinglesionneurocysticercosisametaanalysisandexpertgroupbasedconsensusrecommendations |