Cargando…
The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes
This trial represents the final stage of the CARESSES project which aimed to develop and evaluate a culturally competent artificial intelligent system embedded into social robots to support older adult wellbeing. A parallel group, single-blind randomised controlled trial was conducted across older a...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Springer Netherlands
2021
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8062829/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33907589 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12369-021-00781-x |
_version_ | 1783681844161544192 |
---|---|
author | Papadopoulos, Chris Castro, Nina Nigath, Abiha Davidson, Rosemary Faulkes, Nicholas Menicatti, Roberto Khaliq, Ali Abdul Recchiuto, Carmine Battistuzzi, Linda Randhawa, Gurch Merton, Len Kanoria, Sanjeev Chong, Nak-Young Kamide, Hiroko Hewson, David Sgorbissa, Antonio |
author_facet | Papadopoulos, Chris Castro, Nina Nigath, Abiha Davidson, Rosemary Faulkes, Nicholas Menicatti, Roberto Khaliq, Ali Abdul Recchiuto, Carmine Battistuzzi, Linda Randhawa, Gurch Merton, Len Kanoria, Sanjeev Chong, Nak-Young Kamide, Hiroko Hewson, David Sgorbissa, Antonio |
author_sort | Papadopoulos, Chris |
collection | PubMed |
description | This trial represents the final stage of the CARESSES project which aimed to develop and evaluate a culturally competent artificial intelligent system embedded into social robots to support older adult wellbeing. A parallel group, single-blind randomised controlled trial was conducted across older adult care homes in England and Japan. Participants randomly allocated to the Experimental Group or Control Group 1 received a Pepper robot for up 18 h across 2 weeks. Two versions of the CARESSES artificial intelligence were tested: a fully culturally competent system (Experimental Group) and a more limited version (Control Group 1). Control Group 2 (Care As Usual) participants did not receive a robot. Quantitative outcomes of interest reported in the current paper were health-related quality of life (SF-36), loneliness (ULS-8), and perceptions of robotic cultural competence (CCATool-Robotics). Thirty-three residents completed all procedures. The difference in SF-36 Emotional Wellbeing scores between Experimental Group and Care As Usual participants over time was significant (F[1] = 6.614, sig = .019, η(p)(2) = .258), as was the comparison between Any Robot used and Care As Usual (F[1] = 5.128, sig = .031, η(p)(2) = .146). There were no significant changes in SF-36 physical health subscales. ULS-8 loneliness scores slightly improved among Experimental and Control Group 1 participants compared to Care As Usual participants, but this was not significant. This study brings new evidence which cautiously supports the value of culturally competent socially assistive robots in improving the psychological wellbeing of older adults residing in care settings. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-8062829 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2021 |
publisher | Springer Netherlands |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-80628292021-04-23 The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes Papadopoulos, Chris Castro, Nina Nigath, Abiha Davidson, Rosemary Faulkes, Nicholas Menicatti, Roberto Khaliq, Ali Abdul Recchiuto, Carmine Battistuzzi, Linda Randhawa, Gurch Merton, Len Kanoria, Sanjeev Chong, Nak-Young Kamide, Hiroko Hewson, David Sgorbissa, Antonio Int J Soc Robot Article This trial represents the final stage of the CARESSES project which aimed to develop and evaluate a culturally competent artificial intelligent system embedded into social robots to support older adult wellbeing. A parallel group, single-blind randomised controlled trial was conducted across older adult care homes in England and Japan. Participants randomly allocated to the Experimental Group or Control Group 1 received a Pepper robot for up 18 h across 2 weeks. Two versions of the CARESSES artificial intelligence were tested: a fully culturally competent system (Experimental Group) and a more limited version (Control Group 1). Control Group 2 (Care As Usual) participants did not receive a robot. Quantitative outcomes of interest reported in the current paper were health-related quality of life (SF-36), loneliness (ULS-8), and perceptions of robotic cultural competence (CCATool-Robotics). Thirty-three residents completed all procedures. The difference in SF-36 Emotional Wellbeing scores between Experimental Group and Care As Usual participants over time was significant (F[1] = 6.614, sig = .019, η(p)(2) = .258), as was the comparison between Any Robot used and Care As Usual (F[1] = 5.128, sig = .031, η(p)(2) = .146). There were no significant changes in SF-36 physical health subscales. ULS-8 loneliness scores slightly improved among Experimental and Control Group 1 participants compared to Care As Usual participants, but this was not significant. This study brings new evidence which cautiously supports the value of culturally competent socially assistive robots in improving the psychological wellbeing of older adults residing in care settings. Springer Netherlands 2021-04-23 2022 /pmc/articles/PMC8062829/ /pubmed/33907589 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12369-021-00781-x Text en © The Author(s) 2021 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Open AccessThis article is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License, which permits use, sharing, adaptation, distribution and reproduction in any medium or format, as long as you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons licence, and indicate if changes were made. The images or other third party material in this article are included in the article's Creative Commons licence, unless indicated otherwise in a credit line to the material. If material is not included in the article's Creative Commons licence and your intended use is not permitted by statutory regulation or exceeds the permitted use, you will need to obtain permission directly from the copyright holder. To view a copy of this licence, visit http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) . |
spellingShingle | Article Papadopoulos, Chris Castro, Nina Nigath, Abiha Davidson, Rosemary Faulkes, Nicholas Menicatti, Roberto Khaliq, Ali Abdul Recchiuto, Carmine Battistuzzi, Linda Randhawa, Gurch Merton, Len Kanoria, Sanjeev Chong, Nak-Young Kamide, Hiroko Hewson, David Sgorbissa, Antonio The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title | The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title_full | The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title_fullStr | The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title_full_unstemmed | The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title_short | The CARESSES Randomised Controlled Trial: Exploring the Health-Related Impact of Culturally Competent Artificial Intelligence Embedded Into Socially Assistive Robots and Tested in Older Adult Care Homes |
title_sort | caresses randomised controlled trial: exploring the health-related impact of culturally competent artificial intelligence embedded into socially assistive robots and tested in older adult care homes |
topic | Article |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8062829/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33907589 http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s12369-021-00781-x |
work_keys_str_mv | AT papadopouloschris thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT castronina thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT nigathabiha thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT davidsonrosemary thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT faulkesnicholas thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT menicattiroberto thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT khaliqaliabdul thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT recchiutocarmine thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT battistuzzilinda thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT randhawagurch thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT mertonlen thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT kanoriasanjeev thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT chongnakyoung thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT kamidehiroko thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT hewsondavid thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT sgorbissaantonio thecaressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT papadopouloschris caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT castronina caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT nigathabiha caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT davidsonrosemary caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT faulkesnicholas caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT menicattiroberto caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT khaliqaliabdul caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT recchiutocarmine caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT battistuzzilinda caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT randhawagurch caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT mertonlen caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT kanoriasanjeev caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT chongnakyoung caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT kamidehiroko caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT hewsondavid caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes AT sgorbissaantonio caressesrandomisedcontrolledtrialexploringthehealthrelatedimpactofculturallycompetentartificialintelligenceembeddedintosociallyassistiverobotsandtestedinolderadultcarehomes |