How arginine derivatives alter the stability of lipid membranes: dissecting the roles of side chains, backbone and termini

Arginine (R)-rich peptides constitute the most relevant class of cell-penetrating peptides and other membrane-active peptides that can translocate across the cell membrane or generate defects in lipid bilayers such as water-filled pores. The mode of action of R-rich peptides remains a topic of controversy, mainly because a quantitative and energetic understanding of arginine effects on membrane stability is lacking. Here, we explore the ability of several oligo-arginines R[Formula: see text] and of an arginine side chain mimic R[Formula: see text] to induce pore formation in lipid bilayers employing MD simulations, free-energy calculations, breakthrough force spectroscopy and leakage assays. Our experiments reveal that R[Formula: see text] but not R[Formula: see text] reduces the line tension of a membrane with anionic lipids. While R[Formula: see text] peptides form a layer on top of a partly negatively charged lipid bilayer, R[Formula: see text] leads to its disintegration. Complementary, our simulations show R[Formula: see text] causes membrane thinning and area per lipid increase beside lowering the pore nucleation free energy. Model polyarginine R[Formula: see text] similarly promoted pore formation in simulations, but without overall bilayer destabilization. We conclude that while the guanidine moiety is intrinsically membrane-disruptive, poly-arginines favor pore formation in negatively charged membranes via a different mechanism. Pore formation by R-rich peptides seems to be counteracted by lipids with PC headgroups. We found that long R[Formula: see text] and R[Formula: see text] but not short R[Formula: see text] reduce the free energy of nucleating a pore. In short R[Formula: see text] , the substantial effect of the charged termini prevent their membrane activity, rationalizing why only longer [Formula: see text] are membrane-active. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s00249-021-01503-x.