Cargando…

Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories

INTRODUCTION: Clinical Relationship (CR) is a more comprehensive term than doctor-patient relationship and is currently used to describe the health team’s contact with the patient and their families, as well as the team’s interaction with each other. To establish satisfactory interpersonal relations...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes, de Campos Velho, Maria Teresa Aquino, Gonçalves, Kelly Carvalho Silveira, Beschoren, Nagele Fatica
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: 2019
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8087288/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33935306
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1981-52712015v43n4rb20190098
_version_ 1783686637903937536
author Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes
de Campos Velho, Maria Teresa Aquino
Gonçalves, Kelly Carvalho Silveira
Beschoren, Nagele Fatica
author_facet Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes
de Campos Velho, Maria Teresa Aquino
Gonçalves, Kelly Carvalho Silveira
Beschoren, Nagele Fatica
author_sort Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Clinical Relationship (CR) is a more comprehensive term than doctor-patient relationship and is currently used to describe the health team’s contact with the patient and their families, as well as the team’s interaction with each other. To establish satisfactory interpersonal relationships, it is important to bring together communication and empathy skills that play a key role in building the CR. However, such topics are given little attention during medical training, with a more focused study on diseases and treatments. Rigid protocols and guidelines have accounted for a large proportion of undergraduate medical curricula, leaving less time for discussion of more abstract subjects related to the humanities and the subjectivity of patients, a view that is part of people’s reality. OBJECTIVES: To provide spaces and theoretical references for the discussion of topics less addressed in the medical curriculum and to encourage the importance of communication and empathy in health/disease processes. METHODS: In view of the importance of providing medical students with humanizing experiences, we have proposed theoretical-practical workshops and conducted a qualitative research in order to evaluate the students’ views on learning about CR themes. In total, 33 second-year medical students participated in the project, by voluntary adhesion in response to an invitation distributed via electronic mail. Six theoretical-practical workshops were offered and executed in small groups and addressing topics such as: empathy, mourning, palliative care, end of life and communication of difficult news. The data collection methods were two focus groups conducted at the end of the six meetings encounters and participant observation, the notes from which were taken in a field diary. RESULTS: Content analysis (Bardin, 2011) was the method chosen to study the results, following transcription and analysis of the speech of the groups. At the end of the analysis, four main categories (and five subcategories) emerged, of which two are highlighted in this article: “Art, cinema and literature evoke feelings: seeking humanism” and “Difficult news in the view of patients – the living experiences”. To this end, we used active methodologies such as small group work, use of videos and excerpts from films, music, reports, reading texts and conversation wheels. CONCLUSION: The participants’ statements showed satisfaction with the proposed theme and methodologies. We therefore evaluated the use of such techniques to sensitize students, leading them to reflect on the importance of empathy and communication in the work of physicians and health staff, developing interpersonal skills.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8087288
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2019
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-80872882021-04-30 Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes de Campos Velho, Maria Teresa Aquino Gonçalves, Kelly Carvalho Silveira Beschoren, Nagele Fatica Rev Bras Educ Med Article INTRODUCTION: Clinical Relationship (CR) is a more comprehensive term than doctor-patient relationship and is currently used to describe the health team’s contact with the patient and their families, as well as the team’s interaction with each other. To establish satisfactory interpersonal relationships, it is important to bring together communication and empathy skills that play a key role in building the CR. However, such topics are given little attention during medical training, with a more focused study on diseases and treatments. Rigid protocols and guidelines have accounted for a large proportion of undergraduate medical curricula, leaving less time for discussion of more abstract subjects related to the humanities and the subjectivity of patients, a view that is part of people’s reality. OBJECTIVES: To provide spaces and theoretical references for the discussion of topics less addressed in the medical curriculum and to encourage the importance of communication and empathy in health/disease processes. METHODS: In view of the importance of providing medical students with humanizing experiences, we have proposed theoretical-practical workshops and conducted a qualitative research in order to evaluate the students’ views on learning about CR themes. In total, 33 second-year medical students participated in the project, by voluntary adhesion in response to an invitation distributed via electronic mail. Six theoretical-practical workshops were offered and executed in small groups and addressing topics such as: empathy, mourning, palliative care, end of life and communication of difficult news. The data collection methods were two focus groups conducted at the end of the six meetings encounters and participant observation, the notes from which were taken in a field diary. RESULTS: Content analysis (Bardin, 2011) was the method chosen to study the results, following transcription and analysis of the speech of the groups. At the end of the analysis, four main categories (and five subcategories) emerged, of which two are highlighted in this article: “Art, cinema and literature evoke feelings: seeking humanism” and “Difficult news in the view of patients – the living experiences”. To this end, we used active methodologies such as small group work, use of videos and excerpts from films, music, reports, reading texts and conversation wheels. CONCLUSION: The participants’ statements showed satisfaction with the proposed theme and methodologies. We therefore evaluated the use of such techniques to sensitize students, leading them to reflect on the importance of empathy and communication in the work of physicians and health staff, developing interpersonal skills. 2019-10-14 2019 /pmc/articles/PMC8087288/ /pubmed/33935306 http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1981-52712015v43n4rb20190098 Text en https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited.
spellingShingle Article
Gularte, Natiele Dutra Gomes
de Campos Velho, Maria Teresa Aquino
Gonçalves, Kelly Carvalho Silveira
Beschoren, Nagele Fatica
Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title_full Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title_fullStr Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title_full_unstemmed Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title_short Abordando a Relação Clínica e a Comunicação de Notícias Difíceis com o Auxílio das Artes e dos Relatos Vivos: Addressing the Clinical Relationship and Communicating Difficult News with the Aid of the Arts and Living Stories
title_sort abordando a relação clínica e a comunicação de notícias difíceis com o auxílio das artes e dos relatos vivos: addressing the clinical relationship and communicating difficult news with the aid of the arts and living stories
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8087288/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33935306
http://dx.doi.org/10.1590/1981-52712015v43n4rb20190098
work_keys_str_mv AT gulartenatieledutragomes abordandoarelacaoclinicaeacomunicacaodenoticiasdificeiscomoauxiliodasartesedosrelatosvivosaddressingtheclinicalrelationshipandcommunicatingdifficultnewswiththeaidoftheartsandlivingstories
AT decamposvelhomariateresaaquino abordandoarelacaoclinicaeacomunicacaodenoticiasdificeiscomoauxiliodasartesedosrelatosvivosaddressingtheclinicalrelationshipandcommunicatingdifficultnewswiththeaidoftheartsandlivingstories
AT goncalveskellycarvalhosilveira abordandoarelacaoclinicaeacomunicacaodenoticiasdificeiscomoauxiliodasartesedosrelatosvivosaddressingtheclinicalrelationshipandcommunicatingdifficultnewswiththeaidoftheartsandlivingstories
AT beschorennagelefatica abordandoarelacaoclinicaeacomunicacaodenoticiasdificeiscomoauxiliodasartesedosrelatosvivosaddressingtheclinicalrelationshipandcommunicatingdifficultnewswiththeaidoftheartsandlivingstories