Cross-Method Comparison of Serum Androstenedione Measurement Using Three Different Assays: The Siemens Immulite Immunoassay, the Roche Elecsys Immunoassay, and an LC/MS-MS Assay

Introduction: Androstenedione is a common precursor of male and female sex hormones produced by the adrenal glands and gonads. Serum androstenedione is a helpful biomarker in the diagnostic workup of a subset of patients with polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS), the investigation of virilizing endocrinopathies, and for monitoring pediatric patients with congenital adrenal hyperplasia. The gold standard for the measurement of androstenedione is LC-MS/MS. A newly developed androstenedione competitive immunoassay is now available in the US, the Roche Elecsys Androstenedione (ASD) immunoassay. Until recently, the Siemens Immulite assay was the only non-radioimmunologic immunoassay available. We characterized the analytical and clinical performance of the ASD across different patient populations and in comparison to the Immulite and an LC-MS/MS assay. Methods and materials: The experiments performed were: linearity and analytical measuring range (AMR), precision (intra- and inter-assay), and accuracy. Androstenedione was measured on de-identified residual serum samples (n=40) using the ASD and Immulite immunoassays and an LC-MS/MS assay. The reference intervals (RIs) provided by Roche for healthy male (0.280-1.52 ng/mL), healthy female (0.490-1.31 ng/mL), postmenopausal women (0.187-1.07 ng/mL), healthy children (<0.519 ng/mL), and patients with PCOS (0.645-3.47 ng/mL) were verified with at least 20 specimens, according to CLSI C28A3. Statistical analysis was performed using EP Evaluator and R program. Results: The ASD had a linear response across the AMR of 0.3 to 10.0 ng/mL. The inter- and intra-assay coefficients of variation were 4.5% and 2.0% or lower, at concentrations 0.5-6.7 ng/mL, respectively. The ASD and LC-MS/MS assays had a mean bias of -0.0542 ng/mL (-2%), Deming regression of y = 1.000 [0.961; 1.039] x - 0.0548 [-0.1806; 0.0709], and r = 0.9930. The Immulite assay had a mean bias of 1.15 ng/mL (44%) and 1.22 ng/mL (32%) compared to the LC-MS/MS and ASD assays, respectively. The recommended RIs from Roche for healthy male, female, and postmenopausal female groups were successfully verified in our patient population. However, the androstenedione concentrations for the healthy children and PCOS groups were outside of the suggested RIs, with concentrations up to 1.41 ng/mL and 0.527-2.24 ng/mL, respectively. Unlike published elsewhere, hormone therapies such as contraceptive pills and steroid treatments did not significantly affect serum androstenedione concentrations in healthy females and patients with PCOS. Conclusion: The ASD is superior to the Immulite immunoassay, and it has excellent comparability with the LC-MS/MS for serum androstenedione measurement. The RIs published by Roche may not be universally transferable; verification is recommended, and establishing RIs for the pediatric population may be necessary.