Cargando…

Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries

OBJECTIVE: A consensual definition of occupational burnout is currently lacking. We aimed to harmonize the definition of occupational burnout as a health outcome in medical research and reach a consensus on this definition within the Network on the Coordination and Harmonisation of European Occupati...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Canu, Irina Guseva, Marca, Sandy Carla, Dell’Oro, Francesca, Balázs, Ádám, Bergamaschi, Enrico, Besse, Christine, Bianchi, Renzo, Bislimovska, Jovanka, Bjelajac, Adrijana Koscec, Bugge, Merete, Busneag, Carmen Iliana, Çağlayan, Çiğdem, Cernițanu, Mariana, Pereira, Cristiana Costa, Hafner, Nataša Dernovšček, Droz, Nadia, Eglite, Maija, Godderis, Lode, Gündel, Harald, Hakanen, Jari J, Iordache, Raluca Maria, Khireddine-Medouni, Imane, Kiran, Sibel, Larese-Filon, Francesca, Lazor-Blanchet, Catherine, Légeron, Patrick, Loney, Tom, Majery, Nicole, Merisalu, Eda, Mehlum, Ingrid Sivesind, Michaud, Laurent, Mijakoski, Dragan, Minov, Jordan, Modenese, Alberto, Molan, Marija, van der Molen, Henk, Nena, Evangelia, Nolimal, Dusan, Otelea, Marina, Pletea, Elisabeta, Pranjic, Nurka, Rebergen, David, Reste, Jelena, Schernhammer, Eva, Wahlen, Anny
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Nordic Association of Occupational Safety and Health 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8114565/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33258478
http://dx.doi.org/10.5271/sjweh.3935
_version_ 1783691082555457536
author Canu, Irina Guseva
Marca, Sandy Carla
Dell’Oro, Francesca
Balázs, Ádám
Bergamaschi, Enrico
Besse, Christine
Bianchi, Renzo
Bislimovska, Jovanka
Bjelajac, Adrijana Koscec
Bugge, Merete
Busneag, Carmen Iliana
Çağlayan, Çiğdem
Cernițanu, Mariana
Pereira, Cristiana Costa
Hafner, Nataša Dernovšček
Droz, Nadia
Eglite, Maija
Godderis, Lode
Gündel, Harald
Hakanen, Jari J
Iordache, Raluca Maria
Khireddine-Medouni, Imane
Kiran, Sibel
Larese-Filon, Francesca
Lazor-Blanchet, Catherine
Légeron, Patrick
Loney, Tom
Majery, Nicole
Merisalu, Eda
Mehlum, Ingrid Sivesind
Michaud, Laurent
Mijakoski, Dragan
Minov, Jordan
Modenese, Alberto
Molan, Marija
van der Molen, Henk
Nena, Evangelia
Nolimal, Dusan
Otelea, Marina
Pletea, Elisabeta
Pranjic, Nurka
Rebergen, David
Reste, Jelena
Schernhammer, Eva
Wahlen, Anny
author_facet Canu, Irina Guseva
Marca, Sandy Carla
Dell’Oro, Francesca
Balázs, Ádám
Bergamaschi, Enrico
Besse, Christine
Bianchi, Renzo
Bislimovska, Jovanka
Bjelajac, Adrijana Koscec
Bugge, Merete
Busneag, Carmen Iliana
Çağlayan, Çiğdem
Cernițanu, Mariana
Pereira, Cristiana Costa
Hafner, Nataša Dernovšček
Droz, Nadia
Eglite, Maija
Godderis, Lode
Gündel, Harald
Hakanen, Jari J
Iordache, Raluca Maria
Khireddine-Medouni, Imane
Kiran, Sibel
Larese-Filon, Francesca
Lazor-Blanchet, Catherine
Légeron, Patrick
Loney, Tom
Majery, Nicole
Merisalu, Eda
Mehlum, Ingrid Sivesind
Michaud, Laurent
Mijakoski, Dragan
Minov, Jordan
Modenese, Alberto
Molan, Marija
van der Molen, Henk
Nena, Evangelia
Nolimal, Dusan
Otelea, Marina
Pletea, Elisabeta
Pranjic, Nurka
Rebergen, David
Reste, Jelena
Schernhammer, Eva
Wahlen, Anny
author_sort Canu, Irina Guseva
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVE: A consensual definition of occupational burnout is currently lacking. We aimed to harmonize the definition of occupational burnout as a health outcome in medical research and reach a consensus on this definition within the Network on the Coordination and Harmonisation of European Occupational Cohorts (OMEGA-NET). METHODS: First, we performed a systematic review in MEDLINE, PsycINFO and Embase (January 1990 to August 2018) and a semantic analysis of the available definitions. We used the definitions of burnout and burnout-related concepts from the Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine Clinical Terms (SNOMED-CT) to formulate a consistent harmonized definition of the concept. Second, we sought to obtain the Delphi consensus on the proposed definition. RESULTS: We identified 88 unique definitions of burnout and assigned each of them to 1 of the 11 original definitions. The semantic analysis yielded a first proposal, further reformulated according to SNOMED-CT and the panelists’ comments as follows: “In a worker, occupational burnout or occupational physical AND emotional exhaustion state is an exhaustion due to prolonged exposure to work-related problems”. A panel of 50 experts (researchers and healthcare professionals with an interest for occupational burnout) reached consensus on this proposal at the second round of the Delphi, with 82% of experts agreeing on it. CONCLUSION: This study resulted in a harmonized definition of occupational burnout approved by experts from 29 countries within OMEGA-NET. Future research should address the reproducibility of the Delphi consensus in a larger panel of experts, representing more countries, and examine the practicability of the definition.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8114565
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher Nordic Association of Occupational Safety and Health
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-81145652021-05-28 Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries Canu, Irina Guseva Marca, Sandy Carla Dell’Oro, Francesca Balázs, Ádám Bergamaschi, Enrico Besse, Christine Bianchi, Renzo Bislimovska, Jovanka Bjelajac, Adrijana Koscec Bugge, Merete Busneag, Carmen Iliana Çağlayan, Çiğdem Cernițanu, Mariana Pereira, Cristiana Costa Hafner, Nataša Dernovšček Droz, Nadia Eglite, Maija Godderis, Lode Gündel, Harald Hakanen, Jari J Iordache, Raluca Maria Khireddine-Medouni, Imane Kiran, Sibel Larese-Filon, Francesca Lazor-Blanchet, Catherine Légeron, Patrick Loney, Tom Majery, Nicole Merisalu, Eda Mehlum, Ingrid Sivesind Michaud, Laurent Mijakoski, Dragan Minov, Jordan Modenese, Alberto Molan, Marija van der Molen, Henk Nena, Evangelia Nolimal, Dusan Otelea, Marina Pletea, Elisabeta Pranjic, Nurka Rebergen, David Reste, Jelena Schernhammer, Eva Wahlen, Anny Scand J Work Environ Health Review OBJECTIVE: A consensual definition of occupational burnout is currently lacking. We aimed to harmonize the definition of occupational burnout as a health outcome in medical research and reach a consensus on this definition within the Network on the Coordination and Harmonisation of European Occupational Cohorts (OMEGA-NET). METHODS: First, we performed a systematic review in MEDLINE, PsycINFO and Embase (January 1990 to August 2018) and a semantic analysis of the available definitions. We used the definitions of burnout and burnout-related concepts from the Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine Clinical Terms (SNOMED-CT) to formulate a consistent harmonized definition of the concept. Second, we sought to obtain the Delphi consensus on the proposed definition. RESULTS: We identified 88 unique definitions of burnout and assigned each of them to 1 of the 11 original definitions. The semantic analysis yielded a first proposal, further reformulated according to SNOMED-CT and the panelists’ comments as follows: “In a worker, occupational burnout or occupational physical AND emotional exhaustion state is an exhaustion due to prolonged exposure to work-related problems”. A panel of 50 experts (researchers and healthcare professionals with an interest for occupational burnout) reached consensus on this proposal at the second round of the Delphi, with 82% of experts agreeing on it. CONCLUSION: This study resulted in a harmonized definition of occupational burnout approved by experts from 29 countries within OMEGA-NET. Future research should address the reproducibility of the Delphi consensus in a larger panel of experts, representing more countries, and examine the practicability of the definition. Nordic Association of Occupational Safety and Health 2021-03-01 2021-03-01 /pmc/articles/PMC8114565/ /pubmed/33258478 http://dx.doi.org/10.5271/sjweh.3935 Text en Copyright: © Scandinavian Journal of Work, Environment & Health https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
spellingShingle Review
Canu, Irina Guseva
Marca, Sandy Carla
Dell’Oro, Francesca
Balázs, Ádám
Bergamaschi, Enrico
Besse, Christine
Bianchi, Renzo
Bislimovska, Jovanka
Bjelajac, Adrijana Koscec
Bugge, Merete
Busneag, Carmen Iliana
Çağlayan, Çiğdem
Cernițanu, Mariana
Pereira, Cristiana Costa
Hafner, Nataša Dernovšček
Droz, Nadia
Eglite, Maija
Godderis, Lode
Gündel, Harald
Hakanen, Jari J
Iordache, Raluca Maria
Khireddine-Medouni, Imane
Kiran, Sibel
Larese-Filon, Francesca
Lazor-Blanchet, Catherine
Légeron, Patrick
Loney, Tom
Majery, Nicole
Merisalu, Eda
Mehlum, Ingrid Sivesind
Michaud, Laurent
Mijakoski, Dragan
Minov, Jordan
Modenese, Alberto
Molan, Marija
van der Molen, Henk
Nena, Evangelia
Nolimal, Dusan
Otelea, Marina
Pletea, Elisabeta
Pranjic, Nurka
Rebergen, David
Reste, Jelena
Schernhammer, Eva
Wahlen, Anny
Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title_full Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title_fullStr Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title_full_unstemmed Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title_short Harmonized definition of occupational burnout: A systematic review, semantic analysis, and Delphi consensus in 29 countries
title_sort harmonized definition of occupational burnout: a systematic review, semantic analysis, and delphi consensus in 29 countries
topic Review
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8114565/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33258478
http://dx.doi.org/10.5271/sjweh.3935
work_keys_str_mv AT canuirinaguseva harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT marcasandycarla harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT dellorofrancesca harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT balazsadam harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT bergamaschienrico harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT bessechristine harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT bianchirenzo harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT bislimovskajovanka harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT bjelajacadrijanakoscec harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT buggemerete harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT busneagcarmeniliana harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT caglayancigdem harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT cernitanumariana harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT pereiracristianacosta harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT hafnernatasadernovscek harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT droznadia harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT eglitemaija harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT godderislode harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT gundelharald harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT hakanenjarij harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT iordacheralucamaria harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT khireddinemedouniimane harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT kiransibel harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT laresefilonfrancesca harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT lazorblanchetcatherine harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT legeronpatrick harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT loneytom harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT majerynicole harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT merisalueda harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT mehlumingridsivesind harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT michaudlaurent harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT mijakoskidragan harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT minovjordan harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT modenesealberto harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT molanmarija harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT vandermolenhenk harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT nenaevangelia harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT nolimaldusan harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT oteleamarina harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT pleteaelisabeta harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT pranjicnurka harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT rebergendavid harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT restejelena harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT schernhammereva harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries
AT wahlenanny harmonizeddefinitionofoccupationalburnoutasystematicreviewsemanticanalysisanddelphiconsensusin29countries