Cargando…

Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hormonal treatments, especially those used to treat menopause symptoms are known to increase breast cancer risk. It is thus necessary to identify new formulations with a better benefit/risk profile. The aim of this translational study was to evaluate the breast cancer risk associated...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Gallez, Anne, Blacher, Silvia, Maquoi, Erik, Konradowski, Erika, Joiret, Marc, Primac, Irina, Gérard, Céline, Taziaux, Mélanie, Houtman, René, Geris, Liesbet, Lenfant, Françoise, Marangoni, Elisabetta, Sounni, Nor Eddine, Foidart, Jean-Michel, Noël, Agnès, Péqueux, Christel
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8160902/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34065180
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13102486
_version_ 1783700389032361984
author Gallez, Anne
Blacher, Silvia
Maquoi, Erik
Konradowski, Erika
Joiret, Marc
Primac, Irina
Gérard, Céline
Taziaux, Mélanie
Houtman, René
Geris, Liesbet
Lenfant, Françoise
Marangoni, Elisabetta
Sounni, Nor Eddine
Foidart, Jean-Michel
Noël, Agnès
Péqueux, Christel
author_facet Gallez, Anne
Blacher, Silvia
Maquoi, Erik
Konradowski, Erika
Joiret, Marc
Primac, Irina
Gérard, Céline
Taziaux, Mélanie
Houtman, René
Geris, Liesbet
Lenfant, Françoise
Marangoni, Elisabetta
Sounni, Nor Eddine
Foidart, Jean-Michel
Noël, Agnès
Péqueux, Christel
author_sort Gallez, Anne
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hormonal treatments, especially those used to treat menopause symptoms are known to increase breast cancer risk. It is thus necessary to identify new formulations with a better benefit/risk profile. The aim of this translational study was to evaluate the breast cancer risk associated with a combination of a natural estrogen named estetrol, with progestogens such as natural progesterone and drospirenone. Since the assessment of breast cancer risk in patients during drug development is not possible given the requirement of long-term studies in large populations, this study provides new evidence that a therapeutic dose of estetrol for menopause treatment or contraception, combined with progesterone or drospirenone, may provide a better benefit/risk profile toward breast cancer risk compared to the hormonal treatments currently available for patients. ABSTRACT: Given the unequivocal benefits of menopause hormone therapies (MHT) and combined oral contraceptives (COC), there is a clinical need for new formulations devoid of any risk of breast cancer promotion. Accumulating data from preclinical and clinical studies support that estetrol (E4) is a promising natural estrogen for MHT and COC. Nevertheless, we report here that E4 remains active on the endometrium, even under a dose that is neutral on breast cancer growth and lung metastasis dissemination. This implies that a progestogen should be combined with E4 to protect the endometrium of non-hysterectomized women from hyperplasia and cancer. Through in vivo observations and transcriptomic analyses, our work provides evidence that combining a progestogen to E4 is neutral on breast cancer growth and dissemination, with very limited transcriptional impact. The assessment of breast cancer risk in patients during the development of new MHT or COC is not possible given the requirement of long-term studies in large populations. This translational preclinical research provides new evidence that a therapeutic dose of E4 for MHT or COC, combined with progesterone or drospirenone, may provide a better benefit/risk profile towards breast cancer risk compared to hormonal treatments currently available for patients.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8160902
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-81609022021-05-29 Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer Gallez, Anne Blacher, Silvia Maquoi, Erik Konradowski, Erika Joiret, Marc Primac, Irina Gérard, Céline Taziaux, Mélanie Houtman, René Geris, Liesbet Lenfant, Françoise Marangoni, Elisabetta Sounni, Nor Eddine Foidart, Jean-Michel Noël, Agnès Péqueux, Christel Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Hormonal treatments, especially those used to treat menopause symptoms are known to increase breast cancer risk. It is thus necessary to identify new formulations with a better benefit/risk profile. The aim of this translational study was to evaluate the breast cancer risk associated with a combination of a natural estrogen named estetrol, with progestogens such as natural progesterone and drospirenone. Since the assessment of breast cancer risk in patients during drug development is not possible given the requirement of long-term studies in large populations, this study provides new evidence that a therapeutic dose of estetrol for menopause treatment or contraception, combined with progesterone or drospirenone, may provide a better benefit/risk profile toward breast cancer risk compared to the hormonal treatments currently available for patients. ABSTRACT: Given the unequivocal benefits of menopause hormone therapies (MHT) and combined oral contraceptives (COC), there is a clinical need for new formulations devoid of any risk of breast cancer promotion. Accumulating data from preclinical and clinical studies support that estetrol (E4) is a promising natural estrogen for MHT and COC. Nevertheless, we report here that E4 remains active on the endometrium, even under a dose that is neutral on breast cancer growth and lung metastasis dissemination. This implies that a progestogen should be combined with E4 to protect the endometrium of non-hysterectomized women from hyperplasia and cancer. Through in vivo observations and transcriptomic analyses, our work provides evidence that combining a progestogen to E4 is neutral on breast cancer growth and dissemination, with very limited transcriptional impact. The assessment of breast cancer risk in patients during the development of new MHT or COC is not possible given the requirement of long-term studies in large populations. This translational preclinical research provides new evidence that a therapeutic dose of E4 for MHT or COC, combined with progesterone or drospirenone, may provide a better benefit/risk profile towards breast cancer risk compared to hormonal treatments currently available for patients. MDPI 2021-05-20 /pmc/articles/PMC8160902/ /pubmed/34065180 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13102486 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Gallez, Anne
Blacher, Silvia
Maquoi, Erik
Konradowski, Erika
Joiret, Marc
Primac, Irina
Gérard, Céline
Taziaux, Mélanie
Houtman, René
Geris, Liesbet
Lenfant, Françoise
Marangoni, Elisabetta
Sounni, Nor Eddine
Foidart, Jean-Michel
Noël, Agnès
Péqueux, Christel
Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title_full Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title_fullStr Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title_full_unstemmed Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title_short Estetrol Combined to Progestogen for Menopause or Contraception Indication Is Neutral on Breast Cancer
title_sort estetrol combined to progestogen for menopause or contraception indication is neutral on breast cancer
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8160902/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/34065180
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13102486
work_keys_str_mv AT gallezanne estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT blachersilvia estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT maquoierik estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT konradowskierika estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT joiretmarc estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT primacirina estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT gerardceline estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT taziauxmelanie estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT houtmanrene estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT gerisliesbet estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT lenfantfrancoise estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT marangonielisabetta estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT sounninoreddine estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT foidartjeanmichel estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT noelagnes estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer
AT pequeuxchristel estetrolcombinedtoprogestogenformenopauseorcontraceptionindicationisneutralonbreastcancer